BBC apologizes after slurs shouted by awards attendee with Tourette Syndrome

seadoug

Well-known Member
Location
Texas
This was at the British Academy Film Awards. There was an award-winning movie, "I Swear" that was based on the life of John Davidson, a Scottish Campaigner for people with Tourette Syndrome. Of course, he was invited. Among other things, he shouted the "N" word at two black presenters. He left early of his own accord.

I have so many questions. Although he is the inspiration for the film, if his disorder isn't under control why did he think it wise to attend? If the "N" word isn't in someone's vocabulary, would they suddenly blurt it out? Since the show is on a 2-hour delay, why couldn't BBC cut out those parts? I will say I feel very sorry for this gentleman because he must have felt so embarrassed.

BBC apologizes after racial slur shouted during BAFTA awards by guest with Tourette's​

BAFTA and the BBC have apologized after a person with Tourette syndrome shouted a racial slur during the British Academy Film Awards.

LONDON -- Britain’s film academy and the BBC apologized to viewers after an audience member with Tourette syndrome shouted a racial slur during the British Academy Film Awards.

The highly offensive word could be heard as “Sinners” stars Michael B. Jordan and Delroy Lindo were presenting the award for best visual effects during Sunday’s ceremony. Host Alan Cumming had earlier told the audience that a guest at the ceremony was John Davidson, a Scottish campaigner for people with Tourette syndrome, who inspired the BAFTA-nominated film “I Swear.”

Tourette syndrome is a neurological disorder characterized by involuntary, repetitive movements and vocalizations, including the uttering of inappropriate words. Several shouts were audible during the first part of the ceremony, although what was said wasn't intelligible to an Associated Press reporter in the press room.

After the slur was shouted during Jordan and Lindo's presentation, Cumming apologized to the audience at London’s Royal Festival Hall for the “strong and offensive language.”

“Tourette syndrome is a disability and the tics you have heard tonight are involuntary, which means the person who has Tourette syndrome has no control over their language,” Cumming said. “We apologize if you were offended.”

The British Academy of Film and Television Arts referred to Cumming’s statement when asked for comment on Monday.

The epithet could be heard when the BBC broadcast the ceremony about two hours after the live event. The broadcaster apologized for not editing it out before the broadcast, though the offensive word could still be heard on its iPlayer streaming service on Monday morning. The program was later removed, and the BBC said the slur would be edited out.

“Some viewers may have heard strong and offensive language during the Bafta Film Awards,” the BBC said in a statement. "This arose from involuntary verbal tics associated with Tourette syndrome, and as explained during the ceremony it was not intentional.

“I Swear” won two BAFTAs, including best actor for Robert Aramayo, who plays Davidson.

Ed Palmer, vice chair of the charity Tourettes Action, said the BBC should have considered bleeping out the slur.
 
If they would have been more supportive, not judgemental about his outburst, which he has no control over, by just ignoring it and it wouldn't have been an issue.

The Learning channel (TLC) had a weekly program called, "Baylen Out Loud." It was about a young woman with Tourette's and all what she's been going through and dealing with. It was so educational, learning about this syndrome. Interesting knowing how her family and fiance dealt with it, compassionately, even with her public outbursts.
 
If they would have been more supportive, not judgemental about his outburst, which he has no control over, by just ignoring it and it wouldn't have been an issue.

The Learning channel (TLC) had a weekly program called, "Baylen Out Loud." It was about a young woman with Tourette's and all what she's been going through and dealing with. It was so educational, learning about this syndrome. Interesting knowing how her family and fiance dealt with it, compassionately, even with her public outbursts.
No they did ignore it, and that's what caused the issue... because they blatently ignored it...
 
What would have happened if he had said every curse word in the book? Would that have required an apology? Or was it part of his illness. What if he called an Italian a Wop? Or an Irish a Donkey? How about a white person Pecker Nose? etc, etc.

Suppose he called out Heil Hitler?
I do not have an answer, but what is the policy? What else is un-sayable? and deserve an apology? Or would any of them need an apology considering the circumstance ?
 
If they would have been more supportive, not judgemental about his outburst, which he has no control over, by just ignoring it and it wouldn't have been an issue.

The Learning channel (TLC) had a weekly program called, "Baylen Out Loud." It was about a young woman with Tourette's and all what she's been going through and dealing with. It was so educational, learning about this syndrome. Interesting knowing how her family and fiance dealt with it, compassionately, even with her public outbursts.

The issue is, I believe, not John Davidson's Tourettes but rather that it was not edited out of the BBC One broadcast, which was shown on a 2-hour delay and also remained on BBC iPlayer until it was removed following complaints.
 
I don't care what disease anyone has, there is absolutely no excuse to utter words like that.
Research Tourette's Syndrome before you rush to judgment.

The ticks and outbursts are entirely involuntary, completely out of the afflicted person’s control. Drugs don’t control it, it has nothing to do with willpower or self discipline or anything else.

It’s a wretched condition, extremely difficult for the person and their loved ones to endure and live with.
 
The ticks and outbursts are entirely involuntary, completely out of the afflicted person’s control. Drugs don’t control it, it has nothing to do with willpower or self discipline or anything else.
When I first heard this story and did research, I found something interesting that I didn't know... but it especially applies to this instance.

"What about swearing or slurs with Tourette's?

A symptom called coprolalia involves involuntary swearing or saying socially inappropriate words. However:
  • Only about 10–15% of people with Tourette’s experience coprolalia.
  • An even smaller percentage involuntarily say slurs.
  • It is not intentional, and the person does not choose the words.
  • Most people with Tourette’s do not shout profanity at all."
 
I don't think a lot of harm was done by either drawing attention to the event or burying it, and I'm not sure drawing attention to the poor man with Tourette's is a good thing, but it may have both good and bad consequences. Yes, he used an inappropriate slur, but that's what Tourette's does. It's a weird disorder, and is not limited to involuntary curse words. As far as things I don't want in myself, Tourette's comes right under psychosis.
 
I imagine to some people who suffer from Tourette's it's the very word they most don't want to say that is bursting to pop out. It makes me think of one time when I was having a long MRI and had been told, "whatever you do, don't cough." I sure didn't want cough and have to start all over, but after holding a cough back until tears were rolling down my face -- it burst out.
 
I imagine to some people who suffer from Tourette's it's the very word they most don't want to say that is bursting to pop out. It makes me think of one time when I was having a long MRI and had been told, "whatever you do, don't cough." I sure didn't want cough and have to start all over, but after holding a cough back until tears were rolling down my face -- it burst out.
My understanding is different. It’s completely involuntary and only after it happens do they know what they’re said.

In other words, they don’t think of that offensive word or sentence before it bursts out, it just happens. So there’s no “bursting to pop out” phenomena, so there’s no way to hold back. There’s no warning, no runway, no indication that a tic will happen.
 
There was a man at a grocery store that burst out cussing and shouting at customers. Someone explained they had Tourette's and not to be afraid. I felt sorry for the man but it was a little shocking to witness.
 
My understanding is different. It’s completely involuntary and only after it happens do they know what they’re said.

In other words, they don’t think of that offensive word or sentence before it bursts out, it just happens. So there’s no “bursting to pop out” phenomena, so there’s no way to hold back. There’s no warning, no runway, no indication that a tic will happen.
That is different from my understanding so I asked Google and got this:

  • Voluntary Suppression: While some people can temporarily suppress tics, it causes intense discomfort, building tension, and usually requires a release later.
My limited information is from a book I read, years ago, about a boy who had it and would come home from school ready to burst with all his tics and would go behind his family's shed and let it all fly for awhile.

I expect we're both right depending on the person afflicted. Your way is probably more common. The person who had it at my church didn't seem to have any control at all and acted more like you describe it.
 
I don't care what disease anyone has, there is absolutely no excuse to utter words like that.
Yes there is; Tourette's Syndrome. Actually, Tourette's isn't an excuse, it's the cause.

And I don't care how hard they try, there is absolutely no way a Tourette's patient can control the symptoms.

With medication and/or behavior modification treatments, symptoms can become less frequent, but not completely eliminated. Some patients don't respond to treatment at all.

Further, as the name strongly implies, it isn't a disease. Tourette's is a disorder of the nervous system. This man's symptoms include coprolalia, the completely involuntary utterance of obscene words or inappropriate remarks and derogatory slurs.

Symptoms usually start in childhood, and often go away during adolescence. This guy wasn't so lucky.
 
Back
Top