There is no one size fits all. It really depends on where you live, how large a presence the insurance company has in your community and your lifestyle, finances, overall health, etc...
In many cases we will never know if we made the right choice until we have a health emergency.
I started by reading the annual Medicare manual to see what benefits original Medicare covers and what they don’t. Then I looked at the out of pocket expenses for deductibles and coverage caps.
Compare the actual Medicare coverage and costs to your situation then start shopping for a plan that actually bridges the gap.
In my case the drug formulary, part D deductibles and copays are important to me along with healthcare providers that agree to accept the Medicare assignment for treatment and care as payment in full.
Good luck.