Reality of nature: I fed the bluebirds and got them killed :(

AnnieA

AnnieA

Well-known Member
Location
Down South
Put breadcrumbs out on the snow for the bluebirds. While they were feeding, crows swooped down, killed two of them and carried them off. Most of us are so insulated from the brutality of the natural world. Even spending most of my life rural, something like this is still jarring.

I once heard a game warden in the Rockies say that he'd never seen an elderly elk or pronghorn. In addition to legal hunting (with parameters set each year based on herd management numbers), bears, mountain lions and re-introduced wolves kill the aging animals before they die naturally from advanced age.
 

Last edited:
AnnieA said:
Put breadcrumbs out on the snow for the bluebirds. While they were feeding, crows swooped down, killed two of them and carried them off. Most of us are so insulated from the brutality of the natural world. Even spending most of my life rural, something like this is still jarring.

I once heard a game warden in the Rockies say that he'd never seen an elderly elk or pronghorn. In addition to legal hunting (with parameters set each year based on herd management numbers), bears, re-introduced wolves and mountain lions culled the aging animals before they died naturally from advanced age.
Click to expand...
I've never heard of this happening before.

Crows and ravens will eat eggs in nests, but I have never heard of them attacking full-grown adults.
 
Aunt Marg said:
I've never heard of this happening before.

Crows and ravens will eat eggs in nests, but I have never heard of them attacking full-grown adults.
Click to expand...

Me neither. Nor my 83 year old farmer dad. I think it's the extended, highly unusual snow cover for us this week. Usually when it snows here, it melts after a couple of days at most. We're in our fifth or sixth day so all the birds are hungry.
 
Aunt Marg said:
I've never heard of this happening before.

Crows and ravens will eat eggs in nests, but I have never heard of them attacking full-grown adults.
Click to expand...
We have a lot of large crows and across the street there is what I call a crow meeting place where at least 15 to 20 of them will show up. It’s a dead tree. They kill the smaller birds which I think are called starlings (misspelled probably). They get enough “food“ that way and leave the other birds alone.

However, we have hawks. The hawks will kill the doves and the bluebirds and whatever they can get. We also have a dove tree, at the end of the block, where 20 plus doves roost because a bird feeder is right below it 😂. Guess they don’t mind bird droppings in their food. 🤣🤣🤣
 
Aneeda72 said:
We have a lot of large crows and across the street there is what I call a crow meeting place where at least 15 to 20 of them will show up. It’s a dead tree. They kill the smaller birds which I think are called starlings (misspelled probably). They get enough “food“ that way and leave the other birds alone.

However, we have hawks. The hawks will kill the doves and the bluebirds and whatever they can get. We also have a dove tree, at the end of the block, where 20 plus doves roost because a bird feeder is right below it 😂. Guess they don’t mind bird droppings in their food. 🤣🤣🤣
Click to expand...
I'm surprised the crows have any success preying on the starlings.
 
AnnieA said:
Put breadcrumbs out on the snow for the bluebirds. While they were feeding, crows swooped down, killed two of them and carried them off. Most of us are so insulated from the brutality of the natural world. Even spending most of my life rural, something like this is still jarring.
Click to expand...
It happens. My first autumn here I hung up 2 hummingbird feeders in a tree outside my back door, unaware that a large colony of feral cats lives here too. It was a slaughter and I haven't hung up any kind of bird feeder since.
 
Murrmurr said:
It happens. My first autumn here I hung up 2 hummingbird feeders in a tree outside my back door, unaware that a large colony of feral cats lives here too. It was a slaughter and I haven't hung up any kind of bird feeder since.
Click to expand...
Two helpful rules of thumb related to hummingbird feeders.

The first, hang them high.

The second, ensure the feeders are protected by an overhang or by shade to help keep the nectar from becoming overheated in the direct sun.
 
Aunt Marg said:
Two helpful rules of thumb related to hummingbird feeders.

The first, hang them high.

The second, ensure the feeders are protected by an overhang or by shade to help keep the nectar from becoming overheated in the direct sun.
Click to expand...
I was amazed at how high these feral cats can jump.

Unfortunately for the hummingbirds, the trees outside my place are currently only about 7 feet tall, maybe just a foot taller than when I got here 6 yrs ago. They're orange trees, so not sure if they'll get much taller.
 
Murrmurr said:
I was amazed at how high these feral cats can jump.

Unfortunately for the hummingbirds, the trees outside my place are currently only about 7 feet tall, maybe just a foot taller than when I got here. They're orange trees, so not sure if they'll get much taller.
Click to expand...
That's a shame.

Are you allowed to hunt feral cats in your State?
 
Aunt Marg said:
That's a shame.

Are you allowed to hunt feral cats in your State?
Click to expand...
Yes, to catch and release. I contacted the local humane society and they sent me 2 spay-neuter vouchers, the maximum pre household, but it's up to me to get a trap. Then I'm to take the animal to a vet who accepts the vouchers, then after it's spayed or neutered I'm to bring it back here to release it.
 
Aunt Marg said:
Not the answer I was hoping for.
Click to expand...
Yeah. And the problem is there's about a dozen feral cats and kittens here at any given time but you can only get 2 of those vouchers per household per year. That will barely put a dent in the numbers. Plus, if the animal you catch allows you to pet it, they're disqualified, so you have to pay for the spay-neuter. And some of the ones I feed will let me pet them.
 
Murrmurr said:
Yeah. And the problem is there's about a dozen feral cats and kittens here at any given time but you can only get 2 of those vouchers per household per year. That will barely put a dent in the numbers. Plus, if the animal you catch allows you to pet it, they're disqualified, so you have to pay for the spay-neuter. And some of the ones I feed will let me pet them.
Click to expand...
I'm probably not doing them a favor by feeding them :(
 
Murrmurr said:
Yeah. And the problem is there's about a dozen feral cats and kittens here at any given time but you can only get 2 of those vouchers per household per year. That will barely put a dent in the numbers. Plus, if the animal you catch allows you to pet it, they're disqualified, so you have to pay for the spay-neuter. And some of the ones I feed will let me pet them.
Click to expand...
Smacks forehead with disappointment.
 
Glowworm said:
I have my feeder near to the lilac hedge to provide cover and it's in a large wire mesh cage that only the smaller birds can get through. The larger birds like magpies can forage on the ground for the food the small birds discard.
Click to expand...
Lovely idea, Glow!

That's how ours is setup, only the little birdies can gain access to the aviary account the fine wire openings.
 
Aneeda72 said:
[snip]

However, we have hawks. The hawks will kill the doves and the bluebirds and whatever they can get. We also have a dove tree, at the end of the block, where 20 plus doves roost because a bird feeder is right below it 😂. Guess they don’t mind bird droppings in their food. 🤣🤣🤣
Click to expand...

Yup, I see this all the time, including doves sitting in trees above our bird feeder.

feb2015_hawk1.jpg
 

Back
Top