When the Diaper Pin reined supreme...

Aunt Marg

SF VIP
After reading and responding to the topic - Mom cries in viral video when she can't find diapers to buy, I couldn't help but feel a topic on traditional cloth diapers was in order, and unlike so many parenting topics that exclude those without children, I've tailored this conversation as a generic one, where everyone, regardless of whether you have children or not, can voice their opinion and experience related to, so come on all you moms, grandmas, dads, and babysitters of the past, come share what you remember about the old days of cloth diapers, safety pins, and rubber pants.

Pin-pricks galore, the stinking diaper pails so strong with ammonia, the odour would burn at your nose and eyes when you lifted the lid to drop a diaper inside, and then there were the hot, greenhouse rubber pants. Those plasticy-rusting panties with stretchy elastics... off and on at every diaper-change, making for the cutest little balloon baby bottoms ever. When weather was hot and tiny little legs and feet were sweaty, trying to get all the piggy's in through the elasticized leg holes of rubber pants could prove to be a challenge at times, but all was remedied with a little dusting of baby powder applied to baby's feet, with a hint sprinkled inside the rubber pants for good measure.

Diapers on the line, diapers in the washing machine, diapers in the pail, diapers in the laundry basket waiting to be folded. When baby filled their pants, off to the bathroom we'd go with diapers in-hand, and assuming a safe position in relation to the toilet, and while holding onto diapers with an extra-firm grip, toilet flush lever was depressed, and poopy diapers were dunked up and down in the swirling toilet water until rinsed, followed by a quick hand-wring, and into the plastic diaper pail the didies would go.

My poor chapped hands, red and irritated around the clock. No amount of hand lotion cured the soreness, and then there were those unexpected moments, like when you'd open the dresser drawer to fetch a clean pair of rubber pants at change-time, only to realize that all of the rubber pants were in the diaper pail or hanging on the line.

Identifying a seasoned cloth diaper veteran was easy, for diaper pins were held between pursed lips when diapering, and when pants were changed, baby was off and running, and with a duck-like waddle, the result of bulky double diapers, all that could be heard was the unmistakable plastic beat of rubber pants rustling with baby's every step, and when baby got into something they knew better than to get into, a few light swats with the flat of ones hand on their rubber-panted bottom was all that was needed, for those rubber baby pants emitted the loudest plastic-popping sound ever, making the spanking sound far more serious than it was.

Ah, yes, those were the days.
 

I remember the early disposable diapers. They were just flat things, no elastic at the legs, so they leaked like sieves and stuff rolled out. They weren't very absorbent, either. For emergencies and travel only.

The cloth diapers were good for some many other things, too. Polishing, drying dishes, etc.

The great thing about cloth diapers were their size versatility. You could fold them like an origami project to fit the smallest or largest baby.
 

All thee of my kids wore cloth diapers. Disposables weren’t on the market yet. At least we were not filling up the landfill with dirty diapers.
Disposable diapers had already been around for a good 20-25 years when my first was born, but having grown-up helping my mom with baby siblings and changing their cloth diapers, I opted to diaper my own children the same old-fashioned way. I always thought of it as being the better, more proper way.
 
I remember the early disposable diapers. They were just flat things, no elastic at the legs, so they leaked like sieves and stuff rolled out. They weren't very absorbent, either. For emergencies and travel only.

The cloth diapers were good for some many other things, too. Polishing, drying dishes, etc.

The great thing about cloth diapers were their size versatility. You could fold them like an origami project to fit the smallest or largest baby.
I don't remember the early, early disposable diapers, but do remember disposables from the 70's, where if you attempted to pop open a sticky tape to check the diaper, the tape would tear the waterproof plastic cover on the diaper, and when those tapes lost their stick, I remember pinning Pampers on like a cloth diaper to keep them fastened.

The disposables I remember had no elasticized gathers either, and I also remember them being really bulky.

Yes, that's what I loved about using old-fashioned cotton diapers, the versatility. Didn't matter how old of a child you were diapering, or what shape they were, those old-fashioned cotton-fold diapers always fit and worked from newborn, to toddler, and even beyond.

I still have a collection of leftover cotton diapers I use for cleaning windows and dusting. They're some 30 years old now and still going strong.
 
1948: Johnson & Johnson introduces first mass-marketed disposable diaper in the U.S.

1961: Procter & Gamble unveils Pampers.

1970: American babies go through 350,000 tons of disposable diapers, making up 0.3% of U.S. municipal waste.

1980: American babies wear 1.93 million tons of disposables, 1.4% of municipal waste.

1981: Disposables start using super-absorbent polymers; size reduced 50%.

1984: Cabbage Patch Kids appear on the first “designer diaper.”

1990: Disposable diapers now constitute 1.6% of municipal waste. 7 in 10 Americans say they would support their ban.

1990-91: Dueling studies by Procter & Gamble and the National Association of Diaper Services assert the merits of disposables and cloth, respectively.

1999: Pampers-funded pediatrician T. Berry Brazelton tells parents not to rush toilet training.

2000: Diapers compose 2% of municipal waste.

2005: The ultimate low-impact trend for people without shag carpets: “elimination communication,” i.e. teaching your infant to go diaper free.

2006: American babies wear 3.6 million tons of disposables, constituting 2.1% of municipal waste.

2007: Julia Roberts touts flushable diapers, with one caveat: “If you don’t really break it all the way up, it doesn’t go all the way down.”

Added note: diapers disposed in 2007 will take until 2500 to biodegrade.

I was working in a grocery store in 1959 and I don’t remember these diapers. If we did, it hadn’t caught on yet.
 
1948: Johnson & Johnson introduces first mass-marketed disposable diaper in the U.S.

1961: Procter & Gamble unveils Pampers.

1970: American babies go through 350,000 tons of disposable diapers, making up 0.3% of U.S. municipal waste.

1980: American babies wear 1.93 million tons of disposables, 1.4% of municipal waste.

1981: Disposables start using super-absorbent polymers; size reduced 50%.

1984: Cabbage Patch Kids appear on the first “designer diaper.”

1990: Disposable diapers now constitute 1.6% of municipal waste. 7 in 10 Americans say they would support their ban.

1990-91: Dueling studies by Procter & Gamble and the National Association of Diaper Services assert the merits of disposables and cloth, respectively.

1999: Pampers-funded pediatrician T. Berry Brazelton tells parents not to rush toilet training.

2000: Diapers compose 2% of municipal waste.

2005: The ultimate low-impact trend for people without shag carpets: “elimination communication,” i.e. teaching your infant to go diaper free.

2006: American babies wear 3.6 million tons of disposables, constituting 2.1% of municipal waste.

2007: Julia Roberts touts flushable diapers, with one caveat: “If you don’t really break it all the way up, it doesn’t go all the way down.”

Added note: diapers disposed in 2007 will take until 2500 to biodegrade.

I was working in a grocery store in 1959 and I don’t remember these diapers. If we did, it hadn’t caught on yet.
Reflecting on American babies in the 1980's, wearing 1.93 million tons of disposables, makes me cringe. I would never have guessed disposable diaper use to be so established by that time.

In the 1980's, where we reside, cloth diaper use was still huge... very, very popular. Our entire family (both immediate and extended) were cloth diaper users, and that was throughout the 80's and 90's.
 
Oh you poor souls. We don’t have kids but I’ve babysat and changing diapers is so gross. I can understand mothers doing it . It’s their child after all but can’t wrap my head around why anyone would want to do that with aging people like in nursing homes but am glad they do. They must really like their job. 🤢 Such a compassionate soul I am. 🥺
 
Oh you poor souls. We don’t have kids but I’ve babysat and changing diapers is so gross. I can understand mothers doing it . It’s their child after all but can’t wrap my head around why anyone would want to do that with aging people like in nursing homes but am glad they do. They must really like their job. 🤢 Such a compassionate soul I am. 🥺
That it is. :)

My oldest daughter was around age 8, when I taught her how to change her baby brother. She used to bug me constantly over wanting to learn how to change the baby's diapers.
 
I remember the cloth diapers as well. We only used the disposable ones on my second child when we traveled, for some reason I took a photo of the hubby in 1976 hanging the cloth ones up to dry in our garage. I guess we didn't have a dryer at that time. He doesn't look to happy. View attachment 100390
Oh, Ruth, what a great tid-bit of history in that picture! LOL!

I could never get my husband onboard with diapers... not changing, not washing, nothing. He is and was just so old-school, he wanted no part of it. :)

As for hanging diapers to dry, I line-dried diapers, too, and when the weather was cold, wet, or made line-drying out of season, I used my wooden drying rack for drying diapers. Out of the way and standing in the back porch, I could hang 2-3 days worth of laundered diapers on the rack, and with the sidewall heaters on in the porch, diapers were dry and ready for use in a few hours time.

Something so nostalgic about diapers hanging on a line drying.
 
Last edited:
I remember helping my mom wash baby siblings diapers in her old wringer washing machine, and popping a few pairs of rubber pants doing so. Rubber pants had to go through the rollers bottom or crotch first, because if you put the pants through the rollers waistband first, the rollers would squeeze the water towards the seat and crotch area of the rubber pants and the pants would pop! Boy, did they ever make a loud bang!
 
I will just comment that: Real Men know how to change diapers and do it when needed. It wasn't a task that I enjoyed, but I have sure changed a lot of them.

The topic is covered in "The Real Man's Handbook" by Larry Winget and Chris Widman.

Real Men also get a grip on their own demons, at least to the extent that they don't harm other people physically or emotionally.
 
They have big huge pins and had to be washed so I’m guessing yes but I didn’t wash them. I just held my nose while i stuffed them in a container. Then I used the disposable ones too. You mothers deserve gold medals I tell ya. 😖
You're a sweetie! :)
 
I will just comment that: Real Men know how to change diapers and do it when needed. It wasn't a task that I enjoyed, but I have sure changed a lot of them.

The topic is covered in "The Real Man's Handbook" by Larry Winget and Chris Widman.

Real Men also get a grip on their own demons, at least to the extent that they don't harm other people physically or emotionally.
Good man. That was going to be my next question .
How many men actually helped change the diapers? Back then there didn’t seem to be as many hands on fathers as there is today but then again , most women stayed home.
 
I will just comment that: Real Men know how to change diapers and do it when needed. It wasn't a task that I enjoyed, but I have sure changed a lot of them.

The topic is covered in "The Real Man's Handbook" by Larry Winget and Chris Widman.

Real Men also get a grip on their own demons, at least to the extent that they don't harm other people physically or emotionally.
I still feel blessed, as dear husband made up for his shortfalls in so many other ways. :)
 
Good man. That was going to be my next question .
How many men actually helped change the diapers? Back then there didn’t seem to be as many hands on fathers as there is today but then again , most women stayed home.
Well said, Keesha! Stay-at-home moms was so big back in the day.
 


Back
Top