Hmmm.....I enjoy See's Candy (love those Walnut Squares!). But there is no way it compares to the many fine artisan chocolatiers in the U.S. See's is one of the best values, however; high quality for the very modest cost.
Here's just a few of the best high-end US chocolatiers. Okay, I snuck in Royce', but one taste and you'll agree it should never be overlooked - plus they ship all over the world:
- La Foret, Napa (supplies The French Laundry and all of Thomas Keller's restaurants)
- Michael Recchiuti, SF. Our personal favorite chocolatier: his Bergamot truffle (the flavoring in Earl Grey tea) and his Salted Caramel are both exquisite
- TCHO Chocolates, SF. If you love mocha flavoring, its Mokaccino bar is the best ever. We're bittersweet chocolate fans, but TCHO makes amazing milk chocolate. It's the only one we like.
- L. A. Burdick, NYC and a few other ECoast locations
- Royce' Chocolates, NYC. Original store is in Japan. Possibly the finest chocolate cream truffle in the world, and priced accordingly. Japan, btw, has several high-end, high quality chocolatiers that regularly win awards in chocolate competitions
- Feve Artisan, SF.
- Vosges Haut-Chocolat, Chicago
- Compartés, Southern CA
- diane krön/K Chocolatier, Southern CA (she actually started in NYC, but closed it and reopened in Beverly Hills)
- Milla Chocolates & Confections, Southern CA
- Forte Chocolates, Washington state
The finest chocolatier in the world is usually held to be
Richart of Paris - it has won France’s most prestigious confectioner’s honor, the
Ruban Bleu, seven times. I haven't tried it personally, but we have friends who are bittersweet chocolaholics also, and have tried most of the above companies. They said Richart was the best chocolate they've ever had.
A few years ago we went on a chocolate tour in San Francisco, just prior to Christmas. Festive and great fun! We stopped in at six different chocolate shops, including Recciuti, Dandelion, TCHO, and the famed Teuscher (Switzerland) which has a store in downtown's Union Square. Spouse and I weren't impressed with the Teuscher champagne truffle; too sweet and very little finish compared to Recciuti and TCHO.
Godiva's had a lot of corporate owners; some were good but some were REALLY bad. They had a short period where like Lindt, they were putting way too much cheap paraffin-like wax in their chocolates, but they have fortunately gone back to the better quality mid-tier market.
Neiman Marcus was the first to import Neuhaus into the U.S. We tried it, but although very fine quality, you could tell it was slightly stale compared to buying local or chilled domestic chocolates. Scharffenberger/SF was still open at the time, and the difference was very noticeable. Just not enough turnover in stock to compete equally; not Neuhaus' fault but just the way the economics worked.
I think that's why Royce' et. al. don't open many retail stores. Really fine quality doesn't scale well into the hundreds of thousands of boxes demanded by dozens of locations. You can't keep it fresh forever.