I can only respond as a mother,
@grahamg. I find it impossible, for right or for wrong, to step outside of that role and respond any other way.
One of my boys chose to stay with his dad after our divorce. He was the youngest boy, though not the youngest child. He has always been a people pleaser, a “can’t we all get along?” kind of person, so it didn’t take me by surprise too much when he chose to stay with his dad, who was abusive as the reason I left him.
Did it crush me? Absolutely. Did I feel like I was going to die? Yeah I did (I know that sounds dramatic, but if you know me at all thru this forum you know I don’t tend towards histrionics or drama.) I couldn’t breathe. I felt overwhelmed with crushing emotion. But at NO time did it ever occur to me, did I ever give even a passing thought to feeling less for my son for his decision.
I was frantic with worry for him, felt that his dad was going to take advantage of him financially, (he did) felt like my son would come to deeply regret this decision (he did) and that he would feel trapped( again yes) but at NO time did it even occur to me to think less of my kid, to feel animosity or anger or anything other than a bone deep worry.
So no, I didn’t feel a failure, or less, or that I couldn’t accept the love and affection and kindness that my son extended to me. Did I feel hopeless? Absolutely. I was frantic because I KNEW my son had made the wrong decision, but was powerless to change his mind.
It was a terrible time and I was devastated and wretched and torn and helpless. But my son ultimately came to understand what an awful decision he’d made, and I was there as his soft place to fall, his safe space, his succor and sanctuary, and he pulled out and made his life work in spite of that wrong decision.
He works for NASA now, as a programmer, has a beautify girlfriend, owns his own house, and is successful and thriving. Our relationship is as close as it’s possible to get and his GF loves me like a Mother. I couldn’t ask for anything more! It just took some time to get here.