No one ever loves you as much as your mother, (propaganda or true?)

Grahamg wrote:
"There's nothing guaranteed but it would be fair to say that in general mothers do love their children, (why else carry around a baby, losing your figure maybe, getting driven half way up the wall very often by them for one reason or another, but knowing you'd never want to be without them or so on,.....! 😇)."

You'd agree most women get the chance to choose to have their own child of course, and you'd agree most probably love them more even than the hubby, (or "equally but differently" if that isn't too obvious?). :unsure:
"lose your figure" - What a weird thing to say. Life happens, bodies change. No one ever says that about a woman who lives a full life and encounters sagging breasts and extra padding around the butt, waist, upper thighs. Did living long enough for that to happen make anyone ever say she lived so long that she lost her figure. Weird phrase...
 
"lose your figure" - What a weird thing to say. Life happens, bodies change. No one ever says that about a woman who lives a full life and encounters sagging breasts and extra padding around the butt, waist, upper thighs. Did living long enough for that to happen make anyone ever say she lived so long that she lost her figure. Weird phrase...
Hey, I didn't invent it and we've all herd about getting rid of the baby bump.
https://www.thebump.com/a/post-baby-body-fixers

Not that I mean to say anything other than in my humble opinion, many women look better after having had their children too, and I was simply emphasising some possible aspects of anyone deciding to become a mother.

Btw can I point you towards a thread called, "Are we still allowed to discuss female logic nowadays", (you may find plenty to object to there) :)
 
Last edited:

No one ever loves you as much as your mother, (propaganda or true?)​


I'm gonna say true

Mine was messed up from my Dad's escapades
and she looked at me like I was a smaller version of him

But, she was able to shower my fat little brother with love
after Dad had finally left......and so had I

It was a good thing
He really needed it

Glad, so very glad for him
 
One of my brothers was having mental problems and was advised to try regression therapy. He was told, 'Your elder sister (me) gave you the love and affection which you didn't get from your mother'.
My mother had four children and didn't love any of them. Idealists think that all mothers love their children, but it just isn't the case.
 
I only ever felt conditionally loved and that mother wanted to live vicariously through her children. If I did something 'wrong', it was "what will people think about ME?". If I did something right or noteworthy, it was, "I'm a good mother for bringing him up this way". She deserted me when I really needed her support. I never forgave her for that.
 
One of my brothers was having mental problems and was advised to try regression therapy. He was told, 'Your elder sister (me) gave you the love and affection which you didn't get from your mother'.
My mother had four children and didn't love any of them. Idealists think that all mothers love their children, but it just isn't the case.
I think we all know that is true, but you can't doubt, especially reading the majority of posts on this thread, just how many very good mothers there have been out there, (and when did you read a thread I started where most agreed with the thread title and OP?).
 
I have to agree with that statement.
Like I tell my children, I carried you for 9 months under my heart and you will be in my heart till the day I die.
Motherhood does have its challenges and heartbreak, but to see my children thrive is the most beautiful gift in the whole entire world.
Those who never experience anything like that can obviously live very exciting and fulfilling lives, but without knowing the things you know, (at least in the same way, or to the same degree).
 
You've said some very insightful things here, so much so I'm going to post the whole lot again before commenting on them.

Ronni quote:
"Well, not be be a killljoy, because I agree with you as it relates to me personally, and to the women in my family —my own mother, my daughter and my daughter in law.

That said, I know or have known women over my lifetime who don’t fit that category. Not many, but their love for their children definitely was conditional. One woman whose husband divorced her when he sons were teens told me flat out that he love for her boys died when they chose their dad over her, and wanted to live with him.

She was a pleasant woman, well educated and their family seemed fine, though I didn’t know them as well as I knew some of my friends. Her boys were sweet and seemed to care for their parents equally, as much as you can know those things just from appearances. I was shocked by the divorce because there was no outward sign.

Whatever the reasons for the sons’ choice, it had a hugely deleterious effect on Mom, she just never got past it. Still had a relationship with her kids, still spent time with them, but voiced from time to time how much their decision affected her affection for them.

I never understood her, her attitude. Sure, I’d be crushed if that were my kids, might feel betrayed, but I just can’t imagine turning off my heart that way."


Grahamg's response:
I think I can understand the way the woman/mother you describe behaved.

Is it possible, that as a mother, having done to her what so many of us fathers almost routinely have done to us, was somehow worse? It made her feel some kind of failure that couldn't be remedied, and she couldn't accept whatever love her sons tried to give her thereafter, is that it?

I'm only speculating of course, but "being on the wrong end of things so far as your children after divorce is no joke", (to be intentionally flippant about it, as a way of highlighting or covering the helplessness felt).
I can only respond as a mother, @grahamg. I find it impossible, for right or for wrong, to step outside of that role and respond any other way.

One of my boys chose to stay with his dad after our divorce. He was the youngest boy, though not the youngest child. He has always been a people pleaser, a “can’t we all get along?” kind of person, so it didn’t take me by surprise too much when he chose to stay with his dad, who was abusive as the reason I left him.

Did it crush me? Absolutely. Did I feel like I was going to die? Yeah I did (I know that sounds dramatic, but if you know me at all thru this forum you know I don’t tend towards histrionics or drama.) I couldn’t breathe. I felt overwhelmed with crushing emotion. But at NO time did it ever occur to me, did I ever give even a passing thought to feeling less for my son for his decision.

I was frantic with worry for him, felt that his dad was going to take advantage of him financially, (he did) felt like my son would come to deeply regret this decision (he did) and that he would feel trapped( again yes) but at NO time did it even occur to me to think less of my kid, to feel animosity or anger or anything other than a bone deep worry.

So no, I didn’t feel a failure, or less, or that I couldn’t accept the love and affection and kindness that my son extended to me. Did I feel hopeless? Absolutely. I was frantic because I KNEW my son had made the wrong decision, but was powerless to change his mind.

It was a terrible time and I was devastated and wretched and torn and helpless. But my son ultimately came to understand what an awful decision he’d made, and I was there as his soft place to fall, his safe space, his succor and sanctuary, and he pulled out and made his life work in spite of that wrong decision.

He works for NASA now, as a programmer, has a beautify girlfriend, owns his own house, and is successful and thriving. Our relationship is as close as it’s possible to get and his GF loves me like a Mother. I couldn’t ask for anything more! It just took some time to get here. ❤️
 
Hey, I didn't invent it and we've all herd about getting rid of the baby bump.
https://www.thebump.com/a/post-baby-body-fixers

Not that I mean to say anything other than in my humble opinion, many women look better after having had their children too, and I was simply emphasising some possible aspects of anyone deciding to become a mother.

Btw can I point you towards a thread called, "Are we still allowed to discuss female logic nowadays", (you may find plenty to object to there) :)
I'm not looking to object to anything. Who cares what you think about a woman's appearance after she has given birth. Seriously?
 
My daughter used to work for child protective services, and she could tell you that not all mothers or fathers love their children.
The problem is, many of them think they do. But their actions are something else. Or like in the case of the personality disorders, their actions never happened.
 
I'm not looking to object to anything. Who cares what you think about a woman's appearance after she has given birth. Seriously?
No, not "seriously", I mentioned a woman potentially losing her figure simply for the reason I've stated above, and to indicate a difference between the reality for a mother and anyone else.

So there is no need for anyone to care what I may think about the appearance of any woman under any circumstances, least of all you under these, but I would again just like to point you in the direction of my thread on " female logic", (and without putting too fine a point on it, "for the quality of logic you're employing here"!). :)
 
The problem is, many of them think they do. But their actions are something else. Or like in the case of the personality disorders, their actions never happened.
There are problems everywhere, not least in anyone trying to be fair when steering a thread back onto a topic where there appears to be majority support for the contention that has been put forward in the OP.
No one can argue against social services having a difficult job very often, but its a discussion for another thread surely!
 
I can only respond as a mother, @grahamg. I find it impossible, for right or for wrong, to step outside of that role and respond any other way.

One of my boys chose to stay with his dad after our divorce. He was the youngest boy, though not the youngest child. He has always been a people pleaser, a “can’t we all get along?” kind of person, so it didn’t take me by surprise too much when he chose to stay with his dad, who was abusive as the reason I left him.

Did it crush me? Absolutely. Did I feel like I was going to die? Yeah I did (I know that sounds dramatic, but if you know me at all thru this forum you know I don’t tend towards histrionics or drama.) I couldn’t breathe. I felt overwhelmed with crushing emotion. But at NO time did it ever occur to me, did I ever give even a passing thought to feeling less for my son for his decision.

I was frantic with worry for him, felt that his dad was going to take advantage of him financially, (he did) felt like my son would come to deeply regret this decision (he did) and that he would feel trapped( again yes) but at NO time did it even occur to me to think less of my kid, to feel animosity or anger or anything other than a bone deep worry.

So no, I didn’t feel a failure, or less, or that I couldn’t accept the love and affection and kindness that my son extended to me. Did I feel hopeless? Absolutely. I was frantic because I KNEW my son had made the wrong decision, but was powerless to change his mind.

It was a terrible time and I was devastated and wretched and torn and helpless. But my son ultimately came to understand what an awful decision he’d made, and I was there as his soft place to fall, his safe space, his succor and sanctuary, and he pulled out and made his life work in spite of that wrong decision.

He works for NASA now, as a programmer, has a beautify girlfriend, owns his own house, and is successful and thriving. Our relationship is as close as it’s possible to get and his GF loves me like a Mother. I couldn’t ask for anything more! It just took some time to get here. ❤️
I see your difficulty with the mother who turned against her child under the circumstances you described in your first post on this thread.
I could suggest she maybe faced a different situation, in that her ex., wasn't similar to yours in the way they treated their children, but I admit I'm grasping at straws, and I'm really not sure I'm adding anything to the discussion at all.
 
I think we all know that is true, but you can't doubt, especially reading the majority of posts on this thread, just how many very good mothers there have been out there, (and when did you read a thread I started where most agreed with the thread title and OP?).
My own children have benefited from the lack of love I had. They were all very much wanted and loved and I made sure they knew that. It's the small things that show love. It wasn't until I spent a week-end with my aunt and saw how caring she was, that I realised how cold and selfish my own mother was.
 
I had 2 wonderful parents that both loved and supported me. I miss them so. I love my 3 boys unconditionally. I was a social worker in CPS for 4 years and saw some horrible things. People really can do lasting damage to their children.
 
I had 2 wonderful parents that both loved and supported me. I miss them so. I love my 3 boys unconditionally. I was a social worker in CPS for 4 years and saw some horrible things. People really can do lasting damage to their children.
I think we can easily agree that where there is disfunction in a family to the degree you are referring to, then so much goes wrong, sometimes very quickly.

However, I'll throw this comment in here, as again I think we'll agree easily enough, (though you may wonder why I mentioning it): "We'd all be against cruelty to old people wouldn't we"!

My reason for throwing the comment in is sometimes false accusations, or a kind of witch hunt mentality can creep in. This can lead to even decent parents and grandparents being unfairly or even cruelly treated, and I'd suggest the frequency this kind of thing occurs in our society today, makes it almost respectable, "especially where the interests of another take precedence all the time, over the interests of a loving parent or grandparent", (one where there has never been any suggestion of abuse for social services to rightly concern themselves over).

How easily we are all able to condemn others, (even without any evidence sometimes), is an issue in my view, leading to the cruelty towards old people I know occurs.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top