What about gas stoves?

RadishRose

SF VIP
Location
Connecticut, USA
Skip to main content




Home
U.S. Government Accountability Office


< WatchBlog: Following the Federal Dollar









Gas Stoves Can Pose Health and Safety Risks—What’s Being Done to Make Them Safer?​


Posted on March 25, 2025




Millions of Americans have gas stoves in their homes. While some swear by them, others have concerns about their health risks. We recently looked at what some experts had to say about gas stove safety. We also reviewed what is being done to improve gas stove safety.
Today’s WatchBlog post looks at our report.
Gas Stove Health Concerns

Illustration of a gas stove showing harmful emissions like nitrogen dioxide and particulate matter.


Why do some experts think gas stoves are a health risk?

Indoor pollutants can pose health risks—from headaches to heart disease. Gas stoves contribute to these pollutants by emitting potentially harmful gases, such as nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide, methane, and more.

But can gas stove use make you sick?
It depends. Experts agree that a malfunctioning stove can produce dangerous amounts of carbon monoxide. However, experts disagree about the extent to which health issues stem from gas stove use alone.

For example, one study on nitrogen dioxide—a respiratory irritant—found a correlation between gas stove use and increased asthma risks in children, and suggested that nitrogen dioxide production could be a contributing factor.

A different study argued that family medical history and other factors would need to be more effectively accounted for before associating asthma with gas stove use alone.

If you’re worried about these risks and have a gas stove, there are options to make gas stove use safer. One of the best ways is to cook on the back burners and use a range hood that ventilates gases and debris to the outside. If you have a range hood that doesn’t vent to the outside, be sure to change or clean the filter regularly. Opening windows while cooking can also help.

External Ventilation of Gas Stove Emissions

Illustration of a gas stove showing how external ventilation can help remove harmful emissions.


What’s being done to make gas stoves safer?

Many states, localities, and retailers require gas stoves to meet certain safety standards. There are also several organizations that set voluntary manufacturing standards. These organizations are typically comprised of industry representatives, researchers, experts, and government entities. They develop standards to protect against accidental burns and prevent defects in stove design that can lead to carbon monoxide exposure, among other safety measures.
While the standards set by these organizations are voluntary, major retailers, as well as state and local building codes, generally require that new stoves follow their guidance.

At the federal level, the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), a government agency, works collaboratively with standards development organizations to improve the safety of gas stoves. It has the authority to create mandatory standards if it believes voluntary standards are inadequate.

CPSC has taken actions to help ensure manufacturers meet safety standards. For example, CPSC recalled about 60,000 units of a particular gas stove product in 2022 and 2023 after discovering that it could emit dangerous levels of carbon monoxide while in use.

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has also promoted research on indoor air quality. And both EPA and the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) have provided guidance recommending that gas cooking appliances be vented to the outdoors, if possible.

Finally, manufacturers are also taking steps to address safety concerns. Gas stove manufacturers have made a number of safety improvements over the past 25 years, including the removal of pilot lights, the development of automatic shut off features, and the reduction of surface temperatures.

To learn more about gas stove safety and efforts to improve it, read our full report.

  • GAO’s fact-based, nonpartisan information helps Congress and federal agencies improve government. The WatchBlog lets us contextualize GAO’s work a little more for the public. Check out more of our posts at GAO.gov/blog.
  • Got a comment, question? Email us at blog@gao.gov.

Gas Stoves Can Pose Health and Safety Risks—What’s Being Done to Make Them Safer?
 

Last edited:
There is lots of talks about phrasing out gas stoves / heating / hot water connections in Australia
it appears Victoria is kicking off the phrasing out .

copied
The Victorian government will be kicking off processes in 2024 to examine phasing out new gas appliances, ending gas connections in new homes and improving rental standards.
The Victorian government just updated their plan to get off gas: what does it mean? - Environment Victoria

Our neighbour’s son has just had a home built next to them ….he was not allowed to have gas appliances fitted to the home
( we don’t have gas lines here ,you have to use bottles )
 
There is lots of talks about phrasing out gas stoves / heating / hot water connections in Australia
it appears Victoria is kicking off the phrasing out .

copied
The Victorian government will be kicking off processes in 2024 to examine phasing out new gas appliances, ending gas connections in new homes and improving rental standards.
The Victorian government just updated their plan to get off gas: what does it mean? - Environment Victoria

Our neighbour’s son has just had a home built next to them ….he was not allowed to have gas appliances fitted to the home
( we don’t have gas lines here ,you have to use bottles )
They may be phased out here, too.
 

I've read about the concern over nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide and methane. I have CO detectors, have never gotten an alert, or have any symptoms of respiratory irritation, even-though I do have asthma and mild emphysema. I have thought of replacing the stove, but more for shifting the utility expense from propane towards electric.
 
I have an electric range, but gas heat. Texas is investing in and promoting natural gas production and infrastructure, so I don't see natural gas going away in my lifetime - not here, anyway.

Replacing a gas range with an electric range requires a dedicated 240-volt circuit with a specific amperage rating, which is not part of standard kitchen wiring. This means alterations to the electric panel. And switching from gas heat to electric presents considerably more expense.
 
The Human Body's Emissions of VOCs


Introduction​

Various volatile organic compound (VOC) sources in indoor environments (such as building materials, furniture, equipment, and human activities) have been widely studied [1]. Unlike the above-mentioned sources, humans, as the occupants and users of the environment, continuously emit VOCs to the environment through multiple processes, which are difficult to intervene and control. Although the human body is an important VOC source, it is often ignored [[2], [3], [4], [5], [6]]. To improve control of VOC levels, especially in densely occupied environments [[7], [8], [9]], the emission characteristics of the human body require urgent study.
 
I thought it was hilarious to read a warning on power mowers to not place feet under mower deck when it was running. But that must have happened to generate the warning/

So
I hope they put a warning on the electric stoves warning people to not place their hands on a hot surface. Lit gas you can see a still hot electric burner.
 
Do I think burning gas creates things that aren't good for you? Sure. Burning anything will do that, from candles to tobacco. But, I think the data showing a significant health risk from gas stoves is pretty flimsy. I suppose if your home is really air tight it might be more of a problem.

On the other hand, moving away from fossil fuels in general is worth doing, as long as there is a sufficient alternative that doesn't rely on them anyway.
 
I grew up with gas stoves and learned to cook on one. I love the ability to control heat on a gas stove. Electric doesn't do this as well. I'm not afraid of carbon monoxide, or carbon dioxide, candles or flames or smokes. I know I'm going to die sometime. I don't think gas stoves are speeding me to my grave, but this is just me.
 
The good thing about a gas stove is that when electric power goes out, you still have a source of heat in the house. Boiling a pot of water on the stove helps heat the kitchen. If the electric goes out and your stove ignites burners with an electric spark, you can still use a handheld igniter to light the burner.

All electric houses are cheaper to build. That's why they became popular.
Same thing with forced hot air duct systems. They became a cheaper alternative to radiator heat in building houses.
 
I've had gas poisoning before. It was horrible. I don't like gas. It makes me nervous. But I have it in my furnace and water heater. Have no choice. It's how the place came. It doesn't take much of it to get really sick or die. I try to stay on top of things if I suspect a leak. I would much rather have all electric.
 
I prefer gas stoves over electric……most chefs in the world prefer gas also because they can control the cooking temp better.
Currently we have electric 😢 there is no natural gas lines close to us.
 
I've had gas poisoning before. It was horrible. I don't like gas. It makes me nervous. But I have it in my furnace and water heater. Have no choice. It's how the place came. It doesn't take much of it to get really sick or die. I try to stay on top of things if I suspect a leak. I would much rather have all electric.
Your furnace and water heater are vented outside. So, unless there is a faulty installation or a leak they are safe.

I'm curious about your gas poisoning. Natural gas is mainly methane and methane is not rated as poisonous, even here in California. The worst it can do is displace oxygen and cause asphyxiation. And, natural gas has such a strong smell that it should be very noticeable.
 
Your furnace and water heater are vented outside. So, unless there is a faulty installation or a leak they are safe.

I'm curious about your gas poisoning. Natural gas is mainly methane and methane is not rated as poisonous, even here in California. The worst it can do is displace oxygen and cause asphyxiation. And, natural gas has such a strong smell that it should be very noticeable.
I lived in an apt over a building years ago that wasn't vented properly inside and I got poisoned by it. I got really sick. Luckily I caught it in time. Even the dog I had got sick. It was something to do with the flue that led to the ceiling. Landlord got in trouble for that one.
 
I prefer gas but it makes sense to me that we should all migrate towards some form of clean energy alternative.

When we were kids my grandmother had an enormous old wood/gas combination range in her kitchen.

We all were sure that we were going to die when she built a small wood fire in it to take the chill off during the fall and winter.

AE033531-217A-458B-A2EA-2CD3F5EACF79.jpg
 
I prefer gas but it makes sense to me that we should all migrate towards some form of clean energy alternative.

When we were kids my grandmother had an enormous old wood/gas combination range in her kitchen.

We all were sure that we were going to die when she built a small wood fire in it to take the chill off during the fall and winter.

AE033531-217A-458B-A2EA-2CD3F5EACF79.jpg
wow you could build fires in those?
 
wow you could build fires in those?
The section on the left was a wood fire box with two ‘eyes’.

The white top lifted up and slid down the back out of the way. The same with the center section where the gas burners and oven were located.

The right side on my grandmother’s stove was for storing pots and pans but this one looks like it might have a second oven.
 
The section on the left was a wood fire box with two ‘eyes’.

The white top lifted up and slid down the back out of the way. The same with the center section where the gas burners and oven were located.

The right side on my grandmother’s stove was for storing pots and pans but this one looks like it might have a second oven.
What did they do back then for ventilation?
 

Back
Top