I am an Atheist and always have been.

What is the point of this thread? Should anyone one of us care who is an atheist or a believer in God? I've been reading these comments and shaking my head. It's like who is the most atheistic of us all? Is this a contest, or what?

Frankly, it is a given that we all have free will and you can believe what you wish. No big deal.
The problem is, too many religious people want to force their religion on those who doesn't think like they do. That's one of the main things that turns me off regarding religion. What people do in their own homes is none of my business, as long as they're not hurting anyone in there and as long as there's no child abuse, but all too often, people do get hurt.
 
If there is no higher being, ok. What if there is, what if they're right? I err on the side of caution, if there's nothing else, no harm no foul.
That doesn't seem to be a very faith based belief to me, but I bet many approach religion the same way, hoping it's a get out of jail free card.

I'm an atheist who spent a lot of time and energy trying to convince myself to believe. The more I researched the foundation of religious practices, the more time I spent attending different denominational churches and learning their beliefs, the further away from believing I got.

Religion is a tool used to exercise power and control, it's base is fear.
 
I've heard many similar stories like that all my life. But I've never experianced anything in my life that didn't have a logical scientific explanation. Therefore I remain unconvinced.
If there is a god who can cure people, I always wonder why he made them sick in the first place. Is he a frickin' sadist who wants to make people suffer so he can step in and cure them? Jeeze! What a narcissist!

It's like people who survived plane crashes and emerge saying that god protected them. Maybe god was trying to kill them and they just got lucky, unlike all the people he was successful in killing.

Look at all the people god supposedly killed during The Great Flood. If that actually happened, 100s of millions of people would have died. So god is not averse to killing a huge number of people. Maybe plane crashes are just mini-floods -- just to keep his skills up.
 
My old man dies when I was nine and my mom when I was 20. For several years afterwards I had dreams in which they were alive. There's a psychological explanation for that. It doesn't mean that they came back in anything other than my sub consious mind.
I didn't mean to show it as proof, but more like I'm not an ass who doesn't want everyone to go to heaven.

This guy was dead for 3 days and in a morgue in Nigeria. He had a car accident. His wife took him in the casket to a church service.


 
If there is a god who can cure people, I always wonder why he made them sick in the first place. Is he a frickin' sadist who wants to make people suffer so he can step in and cure them? Jeeze! What a narcissist!

It's like people who survived plane crashes and emerge saying that god protected them. Maybe god was trying to kill them and they just got lucky, unlike all the people he was successful in killing.

Look at all the people god supposedly killed during The Great Flood. If that actually happened, 100s of millions of people would have died. So god is not averse to killing a huge number of people. Maybe plane crashes are just mini-floods -- just to keep his skills up.

Acts 10:38
New King James Version
38 how God anointed Jesus of Nazareth with the Holy Spirit and with power, who went about doing good and healing all who were oppressed by the devil, for God was with Him.

Oppressed by the devil. He makes people sick.

Why come up with half the story? You don't even believe the flood happened, but you skip the part that fallen angels mated with women and they bore them giants, like the book of Enoch says.

Now it came to pass, when men began to multiply on the face of the earth, and daughters were born to them, 2 that the sons of God saw the daughters of men, that they were beautiful; and they took wives for themselves of all whom they chose.

”4 There were giants on the earth in those days, and also afterward, when the sons of God came in to the daughters of men and they bore children to them. Those were the mighty men who were of old, men of renown.

5 Then the Lord saw that the wickedness of man was great in the earth, and that every intent of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually.

Every intent was only evil continually. That's worse than Hitler. He at least was kind to his dog before he killed him.
 
I only studied one year physical geography and just assumed that what they said was true. Soil layers, billions of years old, geology, all that stuff. I didn't really care. Okay. Maybe 6 days are 6 periods of millions or billions of years. What does it matter. And later I saw GAP theory. Then dino's were still old, but God recreated. Okay. Sounds plausible. And then they found soft tissue in a dinosaur and I didn't believe that it was so old anymore.

This guy was not dumb:

That person who died in 1997 despite some biology teaching credentials has little credibility in refuting modern evolution theory if one bothers to drill down on the web as I just did. The video immediately struck me as a manipulative and staged with a common strategy of appearing to be falsely be against what he was promoting. Numbers of YEC books play that same game.

Evolutionary theory is not complete and never will be in our lifetime, just like many science theories but rather are ongoing processes with parts that are solid knowledge through a range of softer knowledge to mere speculative conjecture. Those trying to criticize theories generally often pick on trivial marginally accepted parts of theories and then to convince science ignorants, their target audiences, use whatever as an excuse to reject whole theories.

In recent years, evolution theory has moved beyond the simpler theory Darwin proposed as there are obvious more complex mechanisms involved that allow species to more rapidly change than from mere random genetic mutations when environmental factors put pressure on species to do so.

Google AI:

Species can evolve significantly faster than the pace of random genetic mutations when environmental pressure is high, largely by utilizing existing genetic variation, altering gene expression, and adopting non-genetic inheritance mechanisms. While random mutations occur continuously, environmental stress triggers, selects for, and speeds up evolutionary change in a matter of generations—rather than millennia—through several mechanisms.
.
 
I'm an atheist who spent a lot of time and energy trying to convince myself to believe.
Same here. I even went so far as to get baptised in a southern Baptist church no less. That's where they have you put on this silly gown and get in this tub of water up in front of the whole congregation and the preacher dunks you under and then pulls you up as some kind of symbolic rebirth in Christ.

And then I waited for the spirit to move me. And I waited, and I waited and I waited. But all I got was Zip, Zero Nada.

You know what Nada means? Hint, it's not a light chicken gravy.

 
In recent years, evolution theory has moved beyond the simpler theory Darwin proposed . . .
You make a valid point, even if it failed to accomplish your bigger objective. Early theories were flawed, just as many of today's theories are. Future discoveries will reveal those flaws. So the "proof" many seek from science may never be known -at least not in our lifetimes. I alluded to the same in my post #100.
 
Since this thread has by this point on page 5, run its course, and is now expanding beyond the original OP post topic, and it is near to Easter, the most celebrated Christian religious period of the year, I'll offer the below that lists some of the obvious reasons people have been moving away from Christianity, from one of my much longer MS Word document. Because of the short paragraph length limit on this web board, I've had to reformat the Word document a bit, ie bullets. And to be clear, I am one that has chosen to follow Jesus, though in new ways given modern science and Internet access to vast information.
=============================================================

People dismiss possibility of God

In this modern 21st Century science and technology era, more and more Western world people, especially younger adults are increasingly dismissing the possibility that God exists without making much effort to personally research or consider the issue. Instead, they are likely to rely on societal awareness that there is increasing secularism among credible successful people, media, peers, scientists, their acquaintances, and society that confirms what they suspected about an invisible, hidden deity that modern science shows no certain evidence for. 60% of Millennials that grew up with religion have dropped out, 35% have an anti-religious stance, and only 20% under 30 believe church going has value in their weekly lives.

Against making that decision is the understanding that we sentient human earth creatures are mortal with otherwise limited lifetimes. The one and only hope for individuals to escape the otherwise certain eternal non-existence of death is by the very clear New Testament promises from Jesus of salvation into his Father’s Heavenly kingdom. Thus, many today though not actively religious and living reasonably moral lives, are in fact on the fence when directly asked, continuing to lean publicly towards the existence of God.

Accordingly, when confronted with moral, ethical, or sinful choices in their lives, unlike when I grew up in the USA, choosing to be agnostic or atheist is now a popular choice without much social consequence. Although it may not be possible to prove God or an UIE exists, I can provide argumentation that Christian churches have created much dogma from misinterpretations and supposed inspiration that God has apparently allowed without corrections. In this modern science and technology era the consequences of two centuries of such has now become a problem that God and son Jesus may be reconsidering intervening again at least in some subtle way, while remaining invisible unprovable.

summary list of current realities
  • 1, throughout human history there have been a long list of gods people across the planet believed in or still do. Some viewed from this modern era are comically ridiculous while others still practiced widely today have some credibility. The Christian religion itself is fractured into many denominations with serious differences in belief that detracts from the possibility any of them are valid, with full guidance from God. If he exists, at least in our region of spacetime, there can only be but one god. Jesus did not start his Christian Church with a goal of multiple beliefs and churches.
  • 2, at least at a shallow limited science level of knowledge, most people see no solid evidence of a god in the universe while science increasingly supplies logical natural mechanisms for physical reality.
  • 3, although some Christian denominations like Catholics, have in recent decades quietly embraced evolution and science, the dominant perception at individual levels continues to follow strict literal interpretations of creation and Genesis that is being ravaged by atheists that attack all Christians like rigid Baptist Young Earth Creationists.
  • 4, people can consider our long list of serious human problems like wars, suffering, and the poor that generation after generation through centuries remains unchanged, as evidence a deity is not there or does not care while not considering that is our human responsibility and not God’s. Making that less believable on the other hand are Evangelicals touting how God is intimately involved in everyone’s lives with elaborate plans, regardless of how evil, and loves all of us equally.
  • 5, people note how historically many unjust wars and punishments were the result of beliefs of religious people against external people with different beliefs as though God was not really helping religious leaders understand what was moral. In doing so they disregard the reality of political powers habitually compromising the church that one has to suspect was not led so by God.
  • 6, additionally, the recent sexual abuse scandals cry out to our religious denominations over a lack of godly guidance. How could God if he was involved have tolerated such? He wasn’t. People don’t consider history showing God abandons such leaders just like he did in the Old Testament with the Levites as Jesus made quite clear when he arrived.
  • 7, people conversely notice how many of the most wealthy, famous, and powerful people in the world including those through history, are not religious and often sinful as though it makes no difference at least while we are organically alive on Earth.
  • 8, people notice how many of the non religious atheists are just as happy and content as any religious if not more so and are freer to live their lives unconstrained even sinfully however they wish as long as such does not break civil laws.
  • 9, even agnostics on the fence are likely to pray when they or those they love and care for are ill or in danger. When such prayers seem to have no effect, they may blame God or conclude he does not exist.
  • 10, most Christian churches continue to cling to the strict Bible recorded historical narratives of miracles, that from physical science standpoints are not defendable even with an extreme allowance of what is possible. Thus, may appear as nonsense imaginary magic that is logically impossible instead of considering the flexible nature of orally passed down stories of ancients. Such passed down oral stories often had embellishments for the sake of effective public story-telling to science primitive audiences. Just consider the variance in same subject New Testament gospel verses. Since agendas would include convincing an audience to believe such were acts of gods with vast powers, it ought not be surprising that some passages are embellished so. That does not mean they should be rejected but rather ought to be flexibly interpreted.
  • 11, when young adults have gained enough knowledge and skill to actually read The Bible, they may be disappointed in how unbelievable some of it is, how disorganized and difficult it is to interpret confidently, and how there is so much disagreement between denominations and scholars on interpretations. Accordingly, they may reject it as interpreted by authorities. All this is not to say parts are very well presented but rather some are not. Accordingly, the insistence of fundamentalists that this was all 100% inspired by the Holy Spirit comes off as rigid inflexible nonsense with an agenda.
  • 12, there are a list of issues relevant only in this modern era like over population of the planet, priest celibacy, abortion, and senior sexual behaviors, that we humans are struggling to deal with in part because referring to the Bible is not adequately relevant in this modern science era while church authorities have boxed themselves into impossible corners due to tradition.
  • 13, people also may see self-serving manipulative agendas in those that scare people into religion via lack of salvation in Heaven or eternal damnation in Hell.
  • 14, there are considerable conflicts between the dominant sexual culture of young single people and what ancient Christian religious law considers proper. However, the subject of sexual behavior is a difficult and embarrassing issue for adults to publicly address, especially in church whether speaking to other adults or worse to children.
  • 15, some religious people use modern media like television to show supposed miracles in plain view while never being able to prove such and then beg for donations. Thus, are not credible that tends to reduce believability of more serious and logical religious authorities.
  • 16, among those brought up in a religious environment, a major issue has always been how boring young children often find the church experience. When later as young adults they are left to decide for themselves after having been so behaviorally damaged, some would obviously choose to play video games.
  • 17, many today see advantages to moral independence, free from historical moral constraints, especially regarding materialism, sexual behaviors, and drug and alcohol use. Examples are, the enormous recent increase in pornography addiction and self sexual gratification with the rise of the Internet.
  • 18, as increasing percentages of non-believing, non church going parents have children, the probability increases of those children never becoming religious.
no wonder people are leaving the Christian church

Is it any wonder in the modern, educated, scientific age so many people as adults from logic and common sense, choose to leave the church? Well, I hope to offer this wisdom as flawed as some of it may be, expanding on some of the above, to those innately good people, minus the evildoers and wicked, that have lost their way.
 
@Messy said
Why come up with half the story? You don’t
even believe the flood happened, but you skip the part that fallen angels mated with women and they bore them giants, like the book of Enoch says.

Skipped because it’s so ridiculous? IMO with love.
 
I have read all the above commentaries. I have tried to understand where folks are coming from based on their experiences and upbringing. I have tried to understand all the issues expressed.
I am at a loss to offer argument or to agree or disagree with what is being said.
I can offer some thoughts however.
We are all created by God. Think about it. You were created by God. You can't find any opposing answer to what I just said. I understand the biology but where did it start? Who was first? Even if you embrace the evolution of man from monkeys where did it all start? Freak accident? All of a sudden we are here? All of a sudden???????????????
What are the odds?
 
@rbtvgo

The answer for you is obviously god, but how did god come to be? I usually hear people say that god always was and always will be. It's just as valid to say that the conditions which lead to the big bang existed before it and they lead to the conditions that allowed us to exist due to evolution.

A number of experiments trying to recreate the conditions that existed at various times during the history of the universe have shown that there is a tendency for those conditions tend to move towards conditions where life can come to be.

I find it far more plausible that conditions existed to allow evolution than to believe that there is a being that is capable of creating the heavens and the Earth, plants, animals and humans.

There's a good chance that neither of us will never know. We just have to live the way that's right for us and make sure we're true to our beliefs about the universe.
 
I don't know about athiests necessarily trying to force their beliefs or non beliefs on people, but it irks me when they talk about the spaghetti fairy, the flying spaghetti monster, and things like that referring to God. Whether it's religeon, politics, or anyone's way of thinking, I don't like it when people or their beliefs are being made fun. (exp: Sleepy Joe). I think it's disrespectful.
 
Back
Top