Can You Really Taste The Difference Between Cast Iron And Other Pans?

fmdog44

Well-known Member
Location
Houston, Texas
Last week I bought a cast iron skillet and it says to wash with a mild soap and nonabrasive scrubber. I have never seen a direction to use soap on cast iron. So I got to thinking if you had a few friends over and cooked some burgers on a cast iron skillet and others on a non-cast iron skillet could they really taste the difference? I'm guessing the answer would be no. Would you agree or disagree?
 

I've never noticed a different taste.

I do notice the ability to brown potatoes and some other foods.

I also like them to make pancakes because IMO they provide a more even heat than a thinner pan.

I've read that you do get a minute amount of iron in your diet when you use a CI pan but I have no idea if that is correct.

My problem these days is being able to lift them. I use a 6" and a 9" but I've had to retire my 12" and 14" CI frying pans.
 
Aunt Bea said:
I've read that you do get a minute amount of iron in your diet when you use a CI pan but I have no idea if that is correct.
I'll tell you where you can get a ton of iron in your diet. My dad used to eat smoked oysters on crackers out of a small tin with a flip top (like soda cans). I was in Trader Joe's the other day and looked at the Nutrition facts on the back...35% iron!!!!!!!!!...(per serving which they said is the whole can).

I have never seen more than 10% iron per serving on a nutrition label before.
 

I agree with Aunt Bea but I think because of better browning the food tastes better. Those pans certainly are heavy to lift. Sometimes I call the hubby in to take them off the burner.
I've never noticed a different taste.

I do notice the ability to brown potatoes and some other foods.

I also like them to make pancakes because IMO they provide a more even heat than a thinner pan.

I've read that you do get a minute amount of iron in your diet when you use a CI pan but I have no idea if that is correct.

My problem these days is being able to lift them. I use a 6" and a 9" but I've had to retire my 12" and 14" CI frying pans.
 
I've never noticed a different taste.

I do notice the ability to brown potatoes and some other foods.

I also like them to make pancakes because IMO they provide a more even heat than a thinner pan.

I've read that you do get a minute amount of iron in your diet when you use a CI pan but I have no idea if that is correct.

My problem these days is being able to lift them. I use a 6" and a 9" but I've had to retire my 12" and 14" CI frying pans.

My lady has a seventeen incher
well seasoned
it doesn't get moved....it gets used
Pancakes are simply the best from that flat iron...the best
 
The very old, well-seasoned cast iron is my 'go-to' skillet but can't say things actually taste better from it. I just find it easier to cook with. Things don't stick, goes from stove top to oven, easy to clean but must remember to dry in warm oven or over warm burner.
 
I don't use a cast-iron skillet (though I have two old ones) but I cook a lot in my cast-iron Dutch ovens (one of which was my grandmother's who got it in 1921). I firmly believe EVERYTHING tastes better when cooked in that Dutch oven. I can cook the cheapest cut of roast and make it tender as a baby's bottom.
 
I do love cast iron frying pans and like Jujube, the Dutch ovens! However, they scratch glass top stoves.

I have a nice enameled cast iron Le Creuset Dutch oven, but the bottom is not enameled and scratched up my cook top no matter how I tried not to drag it around.

Then I bought On Sale (deep discount), the more shallow Le Creuset pot or pan (3 & 3/4 qt) but the bottom IS enameled, so that helps. With the lids they are soooo heavy, but they wash up nicely. Just remove the lids first after cooking.

Also have a Lodge cast iron grill pan, just the right depth and the ridges high enough so your steak doesn't boil in it's own juice and browns well on stove top, then can put in oven to finish. Drawback - scratches on the glass cooktop.

The even heat with cast iron is great. Lodge is a good cast iron name and yes, steaks do taste better with the cast iron grill pan. Make sure the ridges are high enough.
 
I'll tell you where you can get a ton of iron in your diet. My dad used to eat smoked oysters on crackers out of a small tin with a flip top (like soda cans). I was in Trader Joe's the other day and looked at the Nutrition facts on the back...35% iron!!!!!!!!!...(per serving which they said is the whole can).

I have never seen more than 10% iron per serving on a nutrition label before.

I too was raised on smoked oysters with Ritz crackers. Can't beat that combo for a snack. I miss the smoked perch we used to get in the Chicago area. Not available in Houston.
 
I'll tell you where you can get a ton of iron in your diet. My dad used to eat smoked oysters on crackers out of a small tin with a flip top (like soda cans). I was in Trader Joe's the other day and looked at the Nutrition facts on the back...35% iron!!!!!!!!!...(per serving which they said is the whole can).

I have never seen more than 10% iron per serving on a nutrition label before.

Lara, you're right- shellfish is very high in iron, which I, at one time desperately needed. I learned that a 3 ounces of fresh clams has Iron: 12mg / 66% DV.

I was making whole wheat pasta with white clam sauce every week or so for awhile with fresh chopped clams, etc. Fortunately, my supermarket sells them like that, shucked, chopped and chilled in containers.

https://www.fitday.com/fitness-articles/nutrition/healthy-eating/the-nutrition-of-clams.html
 
I use a cast iron skillet sometimes for frying things like sliced potatoes in olive oil, steaks, etc. I've never noticed any change in taste when using the cast iron or a stainless steel or other pan.

I've been using iron-free multi-vitamins for years now, even though I used iron supplements when I was young (SSS Tonic). Older men and post-menopausal women can have iron overload which may have a negative effect on their organs. More for those interested here.

Although iron is an essential element for healthy life, too much iron can overwhelm the body’s natural storage capability leading to oxidative stress, tissue damage, and early aging. Iron is particularly dangerous and can catalyze these processes even in small amounts (less than a few extra grams) when mixed with other risk factors such as obesity, family history of diabetes or heart disease, inadequate consumption of antioxidants (fruits and vegetables), hormone replacement therapy, unhealthy cholesterol levels, smoking and regular alcohol consumption and for women who no longer menstruate.


Cell and tissue damage caused by iron can either initiate and/or contribute to the following causes of that can shorten lifespan or cause sudden death:

  • Cirrhosis of the liver
  • Cardiovascular diseases
  • Cancer (particularly cancers of the liver and colon)
  • Type II diabetes
  • Septicemia (excessive iron nourishes dangerous microbe colonization)
  • Early onset neurodegenerative diseases (Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s diseases, among others)
Individual symptoms and degree of expression will vary between people (as will the amounts of stored iron). Excessive body iron accumulation can also lead to depression, loss of muscle mass and strength, enlargement and impairment of liver and spleen, loss of body hair, hypothyroidism, loss of libido (sexual interest) and function, with noticeable changes (darkening) of skin color, chronic fatigue and joint pain (especially in the first two knuckles of the hand referred to as “iron fist”.) Too much iron should be suspect in the presence of any of these symptoms.

In women, the greatest risk for and indicator of suspect iron overload is when the monthly period stops for whatever reason: taking birth control pills, hysterectomy or menopause. With the monthly blood loss from a period iron is also lost, keeping excess iron under control.
 
We have a 12" cast iron fry pan that just stays on the stove. We use him off and on, mostly for burgers, pancakes, stuff like that. I can't say that I've ever noticed a difference in taste but I really like the way it cooks food.
 
Back to the question.

The taste. Since the cast iron pan is 'seasoned' with cooking oil I would think frying a burger would have a different taste especially if bacon has been fried before. It's the fat that gives the taste.

I just bought a ceramic fry pan and I think it's great for everything. Truly non stick and easy to wash and keep clean.

Never use olive oil for frying is what Lidia says.
 


Back
Top