Are you an intuitive cook? Do you follow recipes?

Ronni

Well-known Member
Location
Nashville TN
I don't often use recipes these days, unless it's a dish I don't make very often that's a little complicated. I have a couple Thanksgiving dishes like that, but for the most part if I just throw stuff together to make what I want. Occasionally I'll ask for a recipe from someone, or look up recipe suggestions if I'm trying to use up produce from the garden or an abundance of something. But even when I do that, I use the recipe mainly as a general guideline rather than a hard and fast series of steps.

I mentioned that to a friend I'd gotten a recipe from....I didn't have cream cheese so I used garlic and cream cheese spread, no fresh roma tomatoes so I substituted a combo of fire roasted diced canned ones and dried, no sour cream so I used half and half etc. It called for ground beef or turkey. I had neither so I used sweet italian sausage, and replaced the spices the recipe called for with a others that leaned more towards the italian side of things. When I was done, my dish bore little resemblance to the original recipe, but it was still delicious.

She was amazed! She said there's no way she could do that! If she didn't follow recipes to the letter the dish was seldom as tasty. If she tried substituting ingredients in dishes she routinely cooked, it often didn't end well etc. I was surprised, and figured that it's just because I've been cooking longer than her so I have more experience in the kitchen.

On the other hand, my daughter cooks this way because she learned how to cook from me, so she started out with the idea that there were no hard and fast rules, other than basics like baking powder makes baked goods rise, you can use corn starch as a thickener instead of flour, heat too high will curdle dishes with milk, sour cream etc in them, and like that.

So then I started to think about it. I actually have no idea if other cooks do this? Do you have to have a recipe? Do you vary what you put in dishes, depending on what you have on hand, or the kind of flavor you want to end up with? Do you cook intuitively?
 

I cook intuitively. Once upon a time, I used recipes, but found myself very often changing them as I went along. I like to vary ingredients so I don't get bored with the same flavours.

Hubby, on the other hand, adheres strictly to recipes .. even those he has used a hundred times :ROFLMAO:
 
Intuitive. Like your daughter, I learned to cook that way from my mom. If trying something new, I'll look at recipes for ideas, then do my own thing. The downside is that sometimes when I love the results, I can't remember exactly the amounts used to get there!

My sister uses recipes by the letter though, and gets very frustrated with directions to "cook it 'til its done" or "smells ready." 🤣

I got her these as a gag gift years ago.


7171085a5c9540183478afab0ebe11d8.jpg
 

Last edited:
I rarely cook much to the chagrin of my wife. When I do I'm pretty much a chemist in the kitchen being very careful to measure the ingredients before using them. The biggest exception is onions where I usually cut the amount called for by about 1/2 because I am very sensitive to them and usually like less than what's called for.
 
I don't often use recipes these days, unless it's a dish I don't make very often that's a little complicated. I have a couple Thanksgiving dishes like that, but for the most part if I just throw stuff together to make what I want. Occasionally I'll ask for a recipe from someone, or look up recipe suggestions if I'm trying to use up produce from the garden or an abundance of something. But even when I do that, I use the recipe mainly as a general guideline rather than a hard and fast series of steps.

I mentioned that to a friend I'd gotten a recipe from....I didn't have cream cheese so I used garlic and cream cheese spread, no fresh roma tomatoes so I substituted a combo of fire roasted diced canned ones and dried, no sour cream so I used half and half etc. It called for ground beef or turkey. I had neither so I used sweet italian sausage, and replaced the spices the recipe called for with a others that leaned more towards the italian side of things. When I was done, my dish bore little resemblance to the original recipe, but it was still delicious.

She was amazed! She said there's no way she could do that! If she didn't follow recipes to the letter the dish was seldom as tasty. If she tried substituting ingredients in dishes she routinely cooked, it often didn't end well etc. I was surprised, and figured that it's just because I've been cooking longer than her so I have more experience in the kitchen.

On the other hand, my daughter cooks this way because she learned how to cook from me, so she started out with the idea that there were no hard and fast rules, other than basics like baking powder makes baked goods rise, you can use corn starch as a thickener instead of flour, heat too high will curdle dishes with milk, sour cream etc in them, and like that.

So then I started to think about it. I actually have no idea if other cooks do this? Do you have to have a recipe? Do you vary what you put in dishes, depending on what you have on hand, or the kind of flavor you want to end up with? Do you cook intuitively?
Nope. At home I just throw it together. I'm not a chef. I just cook the crap. I figure out what I think would taste good and go for it. At work I have to follow recipes and it's miserable. At the nursing home I worked in for many years I was allowed to be creative. I would get so tickled watching the residents eat things when they enjoyed it.

My chicken for today for example: A couple heaping tablespoons of mayo with a couple cups of Almond Milk and used that to moisten the chicken before tossing it in seasoned bread crumbs. Baked it uncovered at 350° for 1 hr and 45 min. It's divine. No measuring really. I just was winging it. Tastes like my grandma's chicken. It's like having my own home version of dinner impossible. LOL!
 
I also will look up recipes online but I just need the ingredients. I can manage from there as long as I know what goes in it. I've never made homemade pepper gravy before. I went online and looked up a recipe and wrote things down and was going to just whip it up. We didn't have the milk we needed so our lead had me use non-dairy creamer which actually worked out better. I got a little too much pepper in it but next time look out! LOL
 
I do alot of cooking.... and Im one that starts tossing in ingredients until I hear the ghosts of my ancestors scream
"GOD CHILD THATS ENOUGH"
 


Back
Top