I wanted it to work as well, but the cued laugh track was just too distracting. With shows that are well written, the comedic dialogue and interplay carries itself, like Grace & Frankie, or Frasier, or The Marvelous Mrs Maisel. The writing, casting, and characters are the magic recipe that pulls you in. If it's not there, you just can't dress it up and sell it.
When a series comes along like Suits, it's a jewel in the ocean of forgettable attempts of entertainment. It has great writing, great characters, intense emotions, plot twists, and superb acting. After a couple shows, you become addicted, and it's hard to settle for mediocre after that. IDK, maybe everyone's taste is different.