Beethovens' true face revealed

hollydolly

SF VIP
Location
London England
The true face of Beethoven has been revealed almost 200 years after his death – and it's every bit as 'intimidating' as his reputation suggests.

Despite his status as one of history's great composers, Beethoven is also remembered for his surly disposition and unkempt appearance.

It's a reputation often reflected in his portraits, which invariably depict him as an unsmiling man with an icy gaze.

Now a scientific reconstruction of his face has revealed what he actually looked like – and it seems he really did look that grumpy.

Cicero Moraes, lead author of the new study, has completed the first ever reconstruction of the composer's appearance based on his skull.

'I found the face somewhat intimidating,' he admitted.

To complete the work, Mr Moraes used historical photographs of the musician's skull provided by the Beethoven House in Bonn, Germany.


The face we all associate with Beethoven...


98814565-0-image-a-132_1748419315066.jpg


...and the new reconstruction.... not a great deal of difference in fact a little improvement I think


98814567-0-image-a-131_1748419295268.jpg

Along with the images, which were taken by Johann Batta Rottmayer in 1863, he used measurement data collected in 1888.

He said: 'The facial approximation was guided solely by the skull.

'First I created 2D outlines – frontal and lateral – from the skull photographs.

'Then I modelled the skull in 3D using a virtual donor's tomography, adjusted to match the photos' proportions.

'I then added soft tissue thickness markers based on data from living Europeans, projected the nose, and traced the facial profile.

'I interpolated all these projections to form the basic face.'

With the objective face complete, Mr Moraes added subjective features like clothes and hair, using as his guide a famous portrait of Beethoven painted in 1820 by Joseph Karl Stieler.

Finally, some of the finer details were enhanced with an AI tool.

Beethoven's true face is revealed for the first time in 200 YEARS
 

I Googled "photographs of Beethoven" and searched images. I found several photographs. Below is one of them. Apparently all "photos" are fakes, since photography wasn't invented until after his death. ;)

51hWDqIEE2L._AC_.jpg
 
I've never seen people smiling in 19th Century photos or paintings. Perhaps people just didn't feel good, or maybe because quality dental care wasn't widely available back then.
true but there was also a lot of superstition back then about photography, probably because photographers hunkered under a cloth, and then people imagined it was some kind of black magic to get their image inside that box... ..also there was very long exposure times, sometimes as long as 3 or 4 minutes...
 
Most were paintings !
Here's the website I got the photo from I posted earlier today -> Amazon. They are representing it as a photograph, but maybe in the Library of Congress, where it allegedly came from, it is more correctly identified as a photograph of a painting, I don't know.
 
Here's the website I got the photo from I posted earlier today -> Amazon. They are representing it as a photograph, but maybe in the Library of Congress, where it allegedly came from, it is more correctly identified as a photograph of a painting, I don't know.
Amazon ?... they're just sellers ...... and yes it's got to be a photograph of a painting there must be millions...
 
The true face of Beethoven has been revealed almost 200 years after his death – and it's every bit as 'intimidating' as his reputation suggests.
...
That's fascinating, Holly. We'll never know precisely what LB looked like, but Moreas' reconstruction might be the closest yet. I'm surprised there hadn't been more portraits of the genius composer done. Perhaps he was too curmudgeonly to sit for them!
 
That's fascinating, Holly. We'll never know precisely what LB looked like, but Moreas' reconstruction might be the closest yet. I'm surprised there hadn't been more portraits of the genius composer done. Perhaps he was too curmudgeonly to sit for them!
from all that we''re told about his bad temper I think you could be right....
 
I Googled "photographs of Beethoven" and searched images. I found several photographs. Below is one of them. Apparently all "photos" are fakes, since photography wasn't invented until after his death. ;)

51hWDqIEE2L._AC_.jpg
Yeah, I have a hunch that this painting is more like the real LB than was Stieler's from 1820, especially since LB was 50 years old in 1820, so Stieler's impression was a little too youthful.
 
I read two biographies . He was known to have a surly aloof temperament later in life by contemporaries. He had ailments besides some deafness. Very introverted.
Anyway, it is hard to hold a smile for a long period for an artist. Ever try it? I have and it's not easy. Cameras changed that, gradually. Obviously, no one prepares for posterity.
 
I've never seen people smiling in 19th Century photos or paintings. Perhaps people just didn't feel good, or maybe because quality dental care wasn't widely available back then.
Because it's not easy to smile for hours while when you are very still and unflinching.
 


Back
Top