British Humor vs American Humor

Mr. Ed

Be what you is not what you what you ain’t
Location
Central NY

British Humor vs American Humor – The 3 Key Differences​



British humor vs American humor: One of the biggest debates that leaves everyone with mixed feelings is whether you prefer British humor or American humor.
Naturally, our sense of humor is primarily affected by both. They’re the leaders of popular forms of entertainment such as TV shows, movies, and funny content on social media, with English being the most used online language.
What makes British humor and American humor particularly interesting is the fact that there is a clear difference in the general sense of humor in their culture, even though the language is the same.
In today’s article, we will answer the question:
What makes British humor distinctly different from American humor and vice versa?
Keep reading to find out!


What are the Key Differences?​

We can’t precisely generalize the everyday humor of either British people or Americans, since in that case, what makes people laugh is very prone to being subjective.
However, we can draw some lines connected to their own sitcoms and popular hosts of comedy shows, which shape the overall sense of humor of the audience.
So here are the key differences between British humor and American humor:


#1 – Irony​

The most common trait of British humor that the rest of the world associates with them is their use of sardonic remarks and a pessimistic outlook.
However, is irony all there is to British humor?
Firstly, most people would argue that sarcasm and wittiness are Britain’s signature sense of humor.
But what’s also as common in British jokes as sarcasm is their ability to shock the audience with the unexpected crossing of the line of what’s appropriate and what’s not. That’s why you would mostly hear absurd and dirty jokes full of innuendos in either the British pub or their popular sitcoms like the UK version of The Office.
The key difference between these two is that British comedy heavily relies on surprising the audience by saying things most people dare not to, especially by telling embarrassing jokes about themselves or others.
And, of course, it’s not like Americans do not like to put a few sarcastic jokes here and there in movies. It’s just that American humor is more associated with slapstick comedy, background laugh track, and punchlines after punchlines in their entertainment.
Take Chandler Bing from the sitcom Friends as an example. He’s one of the most beloved characters of the show, primarily due to his sarcastic demeanor and relatable self-deprecation, which are both considered more to be the trait of British humor.

#2 – The Art of Being Subtle vs. Direct​

The next key difference would be that being direct is very commonly related to American culture, while British people are more known for their subtle, indirect humor.
That is why American humor is often associated with observational comedy. Its culture is generalized as to saying everything directly and being literal in the sense of what they mean, without too many implications like British comedy.
The perfect example of putting the audience to the test of who will understand subtle British humor the best was Ricky Gervais’ opening speech at the Golden Globes in 2020.
The audience, consisting of mostly American actors and celebrities, tasted the peak British humor. Gervais was making fun of them all and calling them out, which was disguised under his deadpan expression, subtle implications, and point-on delivery.
It made some people laugh out of simply not believing how the host had guts to mock them all, yet some looked uncomfortable because they weren’t too sure if Gervais was joking or actually being serious.


#3 – Funny Characters or Funny Situations​

One of the standard rules of British humor is getting used to absurdity and their tendency to make characters the laughing stock, rather than having characters tell a funny anecdote as mainstream American comedy prefers.
British humor in sitcoms and movies favors putting the funny, self-deprecating character in the center where the audience can laugh at his foolishness and failures. As a result, they often make the relatable person embarrass themselves in regular everyday situations, become the joke or simply have funny sarcastic traits. In contrast, American humor does the exact opposite.
In most American shows, the character is exaggerated to the point the audience can’t relate to, yet they only laugh at the jokes the character says about the funny situation. However, that’s not always the case, it’s just a common pattern which is interesting to observe.

Conclusion​

We absolutely love both American and British humor even though they have their differences.
If you enjoy laughing at relatable characters in the everyday situation that’s turned slightly absurd and embarrassing, British sitcoms and movies are the ones for you. You can sit on the sideline and be happy that you’re not in their shoes!
And after all, because the shows that the audience watches shape their sense of humor, you will understand and relate to British people and their jokes in regular everyday life more.
On the other hand, if constant punchlines and observational humor are more your thing, American humor and stand-up comedians will probably be your favorite. Short jokes that are usually upbeat and lighthearted are in the center of American comedy, too.

Your Turn!​

Now, we would love to hear from you:
Do you prefer the slapstick kind of comedy and direct punchlines that are common in American sitcoms? Or do you prefer a good dose of British irony with wordplays and sarcastic delivery?
Please share your thoughts in the comments down below!
 

American Humour has become more British of late.. at least Stand up comedy.. like George Carlin.. was very much more British in it's way than any other American Comedian.. he was sarcastic and witty.. and like British comedy veered from being politically correct... IOW.. making jokes about what people were actually thinking and feared to say out loud.

I of course prefer British Comedy to any other.. we don't take ourselves seriously at all... but situation comedy.. is best and funniest from Americans..IMO..
 

We used to cross the pond many times, American humour, or should that be humor? Is funny, but you have to view it through American eyes. It also works the other way around. Staying with some friends in Savannah, out for a meal with some of their friends, we were asked to explain why, in a sitcom, someone enters the room to find a fellow doing press ups. The one who entered the room apologised and added, "anyone I know?" Everyone at the table had a good laugh when I told them that the one entering the room implied that the one doing press ups was fantasising about having sex. The apology emphasised the joke.

Who would have thought that this man's brilliant stand up comedy could have Americans doubled up with laughter.

There again, it was a British born American that would often appear on UK TV chat shows and by example explain American humour. The late Bob Hope brought laughter to us all.
 
Last edited:
We used to cross the pond many times, American humour, or should that be humor? Is funny, but yo have to view it through American eyes. It also works the other way around. Staying with some friends in Savannah, out for a meal with some of their friends, we were asked to explain why, in a sitcom, someone enters the room to find a fellow doing press ups. The one who entered the room apologised and added, "anyone I know?" Everyone at the table had a good laugh when I told them that the one entering the room implied that the one doing press ups was fantasising about having sex. The apology emphasised the joke.

Who would have thought that this man's brilliant stand up comedy could have Americans doubled up with laughter.

There again, it was a British born American that would often appear on UK TV chat shows and by example explain American humour. The late Bob Hope brought laughter to us all.
Initially Billy's audience when he moved to America were mostly made up from Expats and they couldn't get enough of him .. and then unfortunately as the years went by he changed his routine to suit the American market more than the British...
 
We have an American friend (from Michigan) in the village and in spite of living in the UK for many years she still has difficulty understanding British humour. The same was the case of an American colleague (from California). I think they take things too literally and don't realise you're making a joke of something.
 
Well, Lucy was not a favorite of mine, Holly. Just short of silly slapstick. No substance.
I understand... I hate slapstick myself in British shows as well... ..one American comedian who the American people seemed to love was Carole Burnett.. I have no idea why she was so popular. to us she wasn't funny at all.. and she never made it in the Uk .. no-one like her style of humour..
 
I understand... I hate slapstick myself in British shows as well... ..one American comedian whothe American peope seemed to love was Carole Burnett.. I have no idea why she was so popualr. to us she wasn't funny at all.. and she never made it in the Uk .. no-one like her style of humour..
I first saw Carole Burnett in a play in NY called, Once Upon A Mattress. Based on the fairy tale, the Princess and the Pea. Well, I hated that show with a passion. Years later, when she had her own show, she employed the likes of Tim Conway and Harvey Korman who were excellent comics. They were the reason I would watch that show on occasion.
 
I first saw Carole Burnett in a play in NY called, Once Upon A Mattress. Based on the fairy tale, the Princess and the Pea. Well, I hated that show with a passion. Years later, when she had her own show, she employed the likes of Tim Conway and Harvey Korman who were excellent comics. They were the reason I would watch that show on occasion.
I know many so called comedian hired joke writers.. but to me that's not being a Comic... it's like calling yourself a nurse and having someone do the job for you...
 
There was a story about Bob Hope.. told by one of our best ever comedians Bob Monkhouse..

he said when he was an up and coming comedian, ( comic actor as well as stand up).. he was one of the Dozens of Comedians that would write jokes for Bob Hope.. and they had to fight to get paid... he was so tight, and when he eventually would agree to pay them, he would call them to his home or hotel and stand at the top of the stairway and throw the money down onto the floor for them to scramble for it.. treating them like skivvies in essence..
 
For many Americans, British humor is an acquired taste, but one that I would say is well worth the acclimation to it. Other Americans are simply left scratching their heads upon the exposure. British comedy can be quite iconoclastic; I used to eagerly await my weekly dose of Monty Python. Too much American comedy panders to gratuitous vulgarity in my opinion; hearing the F-bomb thrown out in every sentence turns me off. Sadly, the culture wars of the past few years have also diminished the capacity of some Americans to laugh at themselves…
 
British Humor vs American Humor – The 3 Key Differences
Interesting post @Mr. Ed

Comparisons like this often point out to me how little real difference there is between US and British culture (Canadian, Australian, New Zealand etc. also). Particularly when compared to vs Chinese or something. It all came from the same place not so long ago. Finding the differences is interesting, and can be fun, but in the big picture those differences are not too great.

I like both, and at least a little of any humor, or is it humour? My American spell checker likes humor better...

My first reaction might be to say I like British better, but I always suspect we only get the best of British TV and the like here. We get all of the US stuff, lots of mediocre, some good.

Monty Python is without a doubt my favorite comedy group, or whatever you'd call them. As an adult there are not many sitcoms I like well enough to watch more than one or two episodes, I don't love Lucy. Yes Minister is an exception. Woody Allen was once a favorite, but I will not watch him again...

Bill Cosby was a real favorite as a kid, and I think he served a good purpose. I grew up in a very redneck segregated place, but a lot of us liked Bill, it kind of helped open a lot of us up to seeing blacks as real people. Too bad the way it ended.

I have tried to watch Benny Hill, but have not yet quite figured out what language he speaks... I like Rake and Red Green as well.

Then their are the shows that are made both in US and British versions. Not sure if they are comedy or not, but I prefer the US version of Shameless to the British, but I much prefer the British House of Cards. Of course ours ended badly for unusual reasons. If I find one I like I always try to watch both versions.
 
In the early days of television, it was American humor. There was a lot of physical humor, like there is in British humor now, or at least in the 90's and early 2000's. A newer generation came along with their own sense of humor, ignoring or rejecting the humor of the 50's & early 60's. Their humor wasn't so funny. Then it came to actors saying lines, followed by the laugh track (aka canned laughter). Some comedy shows let you know that the show was filmed before a live audience.

Other than The Big Bang Theory, I don't watch American comedy shows anymore. I could never understand why people watched Two Broke Girls, for 6 seasons.

But I have been watching British comedies, since the 1970's on PBS. I still watch Keeping Up Appearances and As Time Goes By, every Saturday on PBS. I own the entire series of both shows on DVD. I also have on DVD the entire series of both The Vicar of Dibley and Open All Hours.

Back to American comedy shows, I have on DVD, the classic 39 episodes of The Honeymooners. That just may be my all time favorite comedy show. I have watch and enjoyed I Love Lucy and The Jack Benny Program, in rerun over the years also.
 
@Paladin1950 .. Comedies like ''as time goes by'' will never age.. even tho' I watched all of those shows way back in the 90's I can still watch the reruns today.. and it's just not aged.. I love that show... :D

..another one is To The Manor Born, can watch those over and over , I get to know the script....... and also The Good Life.. ( altho' tbf the good life was filmed and set in the 70's).. it's still very funny even 50 years on..

Then of course there's Fawlty towers.. no mention of Great british Comedy can be said without mentioning Fawlty towers even with shaking walls... it was Hilarious

Our very top situation Comedy of all time is Only Fools and horses.. set in London.. follows a family living in poverty ducking and diving to make money, and making a big hash out of it .. and starring David Jason..

Sadly it didn't travel well to US audiences, it was very British Humour, .. .. but it won every award for comedy in the UK.. and still to this day ( it was filmed and recorded in the 80's).. people vote it the best Comedy show ever !
 
Well, Lucy was not a favorite of mine, Holly. Just short of silly slapstick. No substance.
True

one American comedian who the American people seemed to love was Carole Burnett.. I have no idea why she was so popular. to us she wasn't funny at all
Yeah, not a fan

I love British humor

But there's some comedians here that I greatly enjoy

Dave Chappelle being one
 
True


Yeah, not a fan

I love British humor

But there's some comedians here that I greatly enjoy

Dave Chappelle being one
I've not heard of Dave Chappelle Gary, so I popped over to YT and watched 5 minutes of a recent show.. unfortunately I could barely understand a word of what he was saying..:(
 
Last edited:
Following on from the tale about Bob Hope, he was apparently a notoriously bad loser. The champion racing driver, Jackie Stewart tells the story of playing against Bob Hope in a charity golf tournament. Stewart's team was winning 5 & 4 in a 9 hole match, but said that they should play on to entertain the spectators who had paid to watch. Hope refused to play and stormed off the course.
 
I'm Canadian. I guess I like British humor better. Some popular US shows, like Seinfeld, are "Why the heck would anyone watch this?"

Ditto the US The Office. So I was surprised to find that I loved the British version.

However, I don't get the British thing about men in drag. An Irish friend invited me to watch Mrs. Brown's Boys. I didn't get it at all. I found out much later that the Mrs. Brown character was played by a man. I guess that was the point. But I just assumed the actor was a woman.

(Also, poking fun at clergy -- apparently another British favorite -- is lost on me.)

Still, the British get my vote. Especially The Four Yorkshiremen. Luxury!
 
As far as sitcoms go, I always preferred the US sitcoms over the British ones. However as far as overall humor goes, I do prefer the dry and witty humor of the Brits. The movie "A Fish Called Wanda" pretty much sums up everything I love about the British humor.
 


Back
Top