COMMENTARY: Canada and the U.S. are neighbours but miles apart when it comes to COVID-19

The COVID19 pandemic has shone a light on the core strengths of Canada’s health-care system while at the same time laying bare the serious shortcomings of the American system.

In this country, we have started to flatten the curve. Ontario and Quebec are not quite as far along as other provinces, but their spread rate of the virus has slowed considerably.

https://globalnews.ca/news/7163753/canada-vs-us-pandemic-response/
 

We've got a mini-version of that here. The UK consists of 4 distinct countries with England being the largest. The rate of new cases and deaths in England is higher than the other countries (allowing for differences in population). To be fair, it is not the whole of England and the cases of COVID-19 vary enormously over the country.

Scotland has managed to get the rate of infection into low figures with very few deaths and is now saying "We don't want the virus imported from other parts of the UK". This is a difficult one because the UK borders are open and Scotland is a popular tourist destination. Of course the press is having a field day with talk of making visitors quarantine for two weeks and accusing the Scottish government of trying to force a rift with England.
 
I don't see it as a referendum on the two health care systems at all. Canadians are simply following the guideliines more than Americans are. And Canada is way more spread out population wise than the US.
 

None of us should be feeling smug about success in dealing with the virus because it hasn't finished with us yet.

Things were looking good in Australia and even better in New Zealand but even gradual lessening of restrictions has seen resurgence of new outbreaks and the number of new cases is growing at an alarming rate. On the news tonight I have seen a report about Israel and six weeks after removing restrictions they have peaks worse than the initial wave.

The trouble is that people have become complacent, partying in greater numbers that we should be doing just yet. A local hot spot near me is traced to the Cross Roads Hotel where people gathered in large numbers without wearing masks or observing social distancing. This pub is on a truck route from Victoria to Queensland and someone seems to have brought the virus with them and shared it around. A niece of ours was at the the Cross Roads recently with her two adult children. They are now in isolation pending swab tests and so are her parents. Her mother has heart and lung problems.

Also at the pub were 30+ guards from an immigration detention facility. There were having a birthday party. We are still not allowed to congregate indoors in groups of more than 10 people. The inmates at the detention compounds have zero protection, not even hand sanitiser. The main strategy seems to have been a belief that the contagion would not pass through the security gates. These poor wretches are waiting deportation and will most likely set off new flare ups in their home countries. The guards are being swabbed and are all off duty.

Various footballers, supposed to be in tight quarantine/social isolation so that some sort of competition can be staged, keep getting caught ignoring the rules. This weekend another one, and his parents and siblings, have been found to be infected after a large birthday party at home.

Adults are behaving like children. They are ignoring the reason behind the rules and guidelines and seeing how far they can push the envelope and break the rules, hoping not to be caught. As a result we are seeing outbreaks in nursing homes rising again and death tolls are beginning to increase..

This is a global war we are fighting, against an enemy that it as silent as it is invisible, and when we say, "We're all in this together", we need to understand that we all need to pull together, not just in our state or county, and not just in our country but as one planet. This is not time for competitions, or political point scoring. Nothing less than international co-operation is required and on an individual scale we need to think about how our behaviour threatens the welfare of others.
 
Last edited:
I don't see it as a referendum on the two health care systems at all. Canadians are simply following the guideliines more than Americans are. And Canada is way more spread out population wise than the US.
We can get fined for not following orders and the fines are huge but we have FAR less people here and FAR more open spaces to get away. We should be doing better.
 
The U. S. Has a dense population in many areas. This is the problem. Too many people packed into too small a space.
Most humans prefer to live in clusters. You're right though, dense centers of population are very efficient settings to transmit respiratory illnesses.

I sincerely wonder how NYC will return to business (and commuting) as usual, given its heavy reliance on mass transportation.
 


Back
Top