Heart breaking photograph

Warrigal

SF VIP
This is an iconic photograph that ought to make the world stop and think.

Let there be peace on earth. And let it begin with me.

Syrian girl 'surrenders': The story of the child who mistook a camera for a gun

Date April 1, 2015
Megan Levy

syrian refugee child.jpg

Heartbreaking: The photograph of Syrian refugee Hudea, taken by Osman Sagirli, was first published in Turkish newspaper Türkiye,
It's been described as the image that broke the internet's heart.
When a photographer pointed his camera lens at a young girl in Syria, the child mistook it for a gun and raised her tiny hands above her head, as if to surrender.

The haunting image of the child, with fear in her eyes and her lips pursed, was tweeted last week by Nadia Abu Shaban, a photojournalist based in Gaza, and has been shared nearly 20,000 times since then.


Shaban did not take the photo herself, and did not know who had. Little was known of the image's origins or the circumstances of the child.
This led some to speculate that the image had been staged; that the child was in fact a boy; and that the photograph was taken in 2012.

But now, the BBC has tracked down the photographer, Osman Sagirli, who recounted how he had taken the image of the four-year-old girl, Hudea, at the Atmeh refugee camp in Syria in December last year.

Sagirli, who was working in Tanzania when the BBC spoke to him this week, said Hudea, her mother and two siblings had travelled about 150 kilometres from their home in Hama in Syria to the refugee camp, which is close to the border with Turkey.

"I was using a telephoto lens, and she thought it was a weapon," Sagirli told the BBC. "I realised she was terrified after I took it, and looked at the picture, because she bit her lips and raised her hands. Normally kids run away, hide their faces or smile when they see a camera.

"You know there are displaced people in the camps. It makes more sense to see what they have suffered not through adults, but through children. It is the children who reflect the feelings with their innocence."

The photograph of Hudea was first published in January in the Turkish newspaper Türkiye, the BBC reported.

At that time it was shared widely among Turkish-speaking social media users, but it was only when Shaban tweeted the photograph that it was exposed to an English-speaking audience.

It breaks my heart to look into her eyes.
 

It brings to mind the little boy with his hands up being led away by German soldiers with rifles at the beginning of WW2...
 
Kim Phuc is the little naked and burned girl in this photo. This picture shows the reality and horrors of war. Kim is married and has a child of her own now.

I can't imagine what is going through their minds. The picture Warri posted says it all. Children scared to death.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    97.2 KB · Views: 15
If a real photo then, yes, very sad indeed, but of course to a small child a pro camera looks very like a weapon, perhaps photographers could think about this in future, they seem to think they have carte blanche to take pics of all kinds of disturbing and private activities and people.
 
Kim Phuc is the little naked and burned girl in this photo. This picture shows the reality and horrors of war. Kim is married and has a child of her own now.

I can't imagine what is going through their minds. The picture Warri posted says it all. Children scared to death.


Yes we all remember the awfulness of that photo which brought effects of war on civilians a truism to many of us who'd not really realised . I was just a teen when that photo was released and of course I've seen it used many many times since as a propaganda tool..as explained by Kim who in fact will celebrate her 52nd birthday tomorrow 2nd of April and living in Canada since the 90's, and who still bears the terrible scars and yes the mental and physical pain of those scars to this day...an interview with her in the following link

http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/re...forgiveness/BrLEcMnoycAj90gHbCJPBJ/story.html


kim_phuc2.jpg
 

Back
Top