Need A Little Weight Lifting Inspiration?

Yeah, these folks are very impressive but they depress me. Some guys just have it all . . .
 

I'm going to be the wet blanket here and ask what the significance of this event is.

Yes, he set a record - good for him. But records are set every day.

He's got arthritis - I HIGHLY doubt that weightlifting is giving him any relief for that condition. He'd be MUCH better off at that age doing flexibility exercises instead of subjecting his joints to additional weight, which joints were never meant to bear in the first place.

The associated article even quotes a Dr. Dutta from NIA:

The risk of leading a sedentary lifestyle is much greater than anything related to exercise,” Dutta said. “I think it’s important for people to realize that age alone doesn’t determine the intensity of your workout.”


While these people are unusual and exceptional, they illustrate the fact that there can still be people, even in their 90s, who age very successfully,” she said.

I disagree with the first bolded statement. It is a blanket statement and should NOT be taken as gospel for ALL forms of exercise, or even for varied individual exercises within a specific discipline such as weightlifting. You are at a MUCH higher risk of injury engaging in weightlifting at an advanced age, especially if you are not familiar with the proper forms and limitations to be observed, than if you were to just sit in your recliner and read MUSCLEMAG.

Encouraging exercise for seniors is one thing; coming out with statements such as that is just irresponsible.

The second statement gives what I think is the secret to this record-breaking performance: this is an unusual and exceptional individual. Your common run-of-the-mill senior should not expect to hit the iron and immediately get the same results. Much depends not only on your general state of health but your genetic predisposition to exercises as well as your somatotype (body type) - mesomorph, endomorph or ectopmorph.

Yes, it's a wonderful story and he should be proud of his accomplishments. But the media should NOT use this as an example for EVERY senior citizen.
 
SifuPhil;15033[/I said:
. . . this is an unusual and exceptional individual. Your common run-of-the-mill senior should not expect to hit the iron and immediately get the same results. Much depends not only on your general state of health but your genetic predisposition to exercises as well as your somatotype (body type) - mesomorph, endomorph or ectopmorph.

Yes, it's a wonderful story and he should be proud of his accomplishments. But the media should NOT use this as an example for EVERY senior citizen.

Agreed.
 

Ditto to that. We're all different, and and as much as we might like to be able to do those things and be in such good shape, we have to be honest about what we can handle.


Hmm....mesomorph, endomorph, ectomorph?? Could you tell us more about these body types, Phil?? I know; we can look that up, but.....it's so much more fun hearing about things from you... :p :D
 
Hmm....mesomorph, endomorph, ectomorph?? Could you tell us more about these body types, Phil?? I know; we can look that up, but.....it's so much more fun hearing about things from you... :p :D

Thank you, Anne! ;)

While people will of course all have individual variations they are grouped by pshysiologists into three main "body types" - ectomorph, mesomorph and endomorph.

I know it isn't politically correct, but I've always seen them as "skinny, regular and fat".

somatotypes.jpg

It's also how my teacher had shown me how to remember them:

"ecto"="e-c"="emaciated";
"meso"="muscular";
"endo"=endocrine gland ("My thyroid is under-active!")

Traits of an Ectomorph:


  • Small “delicate” frame and bone structure
  • Flat chest
  • Small shoulders
  • Thin
  • Lean muscle mass
  • Finds it hard to gain weight
  • Fast metabolism

Traits of a Mesomorph:


  • Athletic
  • Generally hard body
  • Well defined muscles
  • Rectangular shaped body
  • Strong
  • Gains muscle easily
  • Gains fat more easily than ectomorphs

Traits of an Endomorph:


  • Soft and round body
  • Gains muscle and fat very easily
  • Is generally short
  • "Stocky" build
  • Round physique
  • Finds it hard to lose fat
  • Slow metabolism
  • Muscles not so well defined

Mesomorphs have a seemingly easy time at pursuits such as weightlifting. They see the fastest gains and are usually the ones you see wearing the winner's medals at bodybuilding contests.

Of course there will be exceptions, but you cannot change your somatotype - you can only learn what works for it and what does not. There will also be what appear to be "mixes" - for example, for many years I thought I was a mesomorph with endomorphic tendencies ("muscular and athletic with a tendency to get fat easily"), but I was simply indulging in wishful thinking. I'm just an endomorph who knows how to train my body for maximum results, so in appearance I can almost equal a natural mesomorph, but when I STOP training I quickly revert to being a chubster. Most people can look at me right now and swear that I'm in "great shape" (6', 205 lbs.), but that's just the luck of the draw - the way I carry my muscle and fat "looks" better than the next guy. But I can FEEL that I'm out of shape.

From my mid-teens until I was married (28 years old) my "fighting weight" was 180-185 lbs. and I had no trouble staying at that level, even when I ate like a pig (and all the wrong things to boot). But that was a combination of working-out hard every day and youthful metabolism. Once I was married and was fed a diet rich in fats (think German/Polish cooking) and cut way back on my workouts I quickly blossomed to 200-205 lbs., where I've been ever since. Were I a true mesomorph my weight would have gone back down by now; alas, I'm a natural-born chunker (not excessive, certainly not anywhere near morbidly obese, just enough really for ME to feel and notice) and won't lose that weight unless and until I decide to change both my diet and my exercise schedule.
 
When I was a gym rat, working out to stay in top shape for riding serious waves, my intention was to concentrate on strength training; lighter weight, multiple reps. The guys who were focused on trying to see how much weight they could push around would laugh at me until they finally caught on. We became friendly and gave each other due respect. But, I still am not very impressed because you can lift a billion pounds. Big deal...!
 
When I was a gym rat, working out to stay in top shape for riding serious waves, my intention was to concentrate on strength training; lighter weight, multiple reps. The guys who were focused on trying to see how much weight they could push around would laugh at me until they finally caught on. We became friendly and gave each other due respect. But, I still am not very impressed because you can lift a billion pounds. Big deal...!

How true. And you just KNOW they're going to hit a wall at some point and the urge to experiment with steroids is going to be almost too strong to ignore. That, coupled with the lack of real functional strength, makes power-lifters like that a joke in my book. If you're doing it to compete that's one thing, but don't believe that you're in great shape just because you can push some iron.

I had a student in Cally many moons ago that was a competitive lifter and I challenged him to hang from a pullup bar longer than me. I won. Why? Because I was training my functional grip strength for martial arts, and my fingers and forearms were MUCH better developed than his - he had concentrated only on the body parts that got scored in the contests. He also used those lifting straps constantly; I asked him what he'd do if he faced an emergency where he had to lift something heavy and didn't have his straps.

He just stared at me. :rolleyes:
 
Yep. Weight lifting vs weight training. Big difference. I learned about it in high school when the swim coach sent us to the weight room. I was thinking he was nuts until it all made sense.
 


Back
Top