After sitting in my imaginary closet for a long time last night, I finally made a decision---NOT to recess the shelves into the walls. I'm going to write down the reasons why, in case I start having second thoughts later.
I'm afraid the changes that would have to be made would not be good for the house. All the roof attic spaces have a brace extending underneath the roof about half way up. The one behind this closet was moved back about a foot, long ago to make more room for the closet. The rafters are only 2x4's, albeit BIG OLD FAT ones, and the supports are already not now at the correct place, or angle, to be of much use, just a gut feeling.
In order to put in recessed shelves I'd have to move this brace back another foot. That would make it even less useful. It is long and heavy and should go the full length of the roof. Even though the house only has to last 20 more years, and it would probably be just fine, all that hammering and climbing around back there with lumber might mess up something downstairs.
I'm sure everyone our age is familiar with the old plaster and lath walls. From the back side you can see all these plaster "keys." Kind of pretty. If a lot of those keys are broken, the plaster will come off the other side, or at least sag, especially on ceilings. The closet is right above the bedroom ceiling downstairs, which already has some cracks. I could imagine likely things that could cause a *real* mess to fix downstairs.
Years ago someone said I should remove all the old plaster and lath and have sheetrock put all over everywhere, but the previous owners already did that in the kitchen and it didn't turn out so well (even longer story). Depends on who you get to do it I guess, and I couldn't (or wouldn't) have spent the money on it back then.
The closet layout wasn't great as it was. With a different layout it will be just as useful I think, and I might be able to buy a shelf to put in there. Who knows, I might get lucky and find a nice sturdy one that just fits. (Yeah, right

)
So I'm ready to move on, but moving on just means more thinking, about the *next* step.



layful:

nthego: