Teen Who Died of Covid-19 Was Denied Treatment Because He Didn't Have Health Insurance

Robert59

Robert59

Well-known Member
Location
Now I live in Tennesee. Did live in Michigan.
A 17-year-old boy in Los Angeles County who became the first teen believed to have died from complications with covid-19 in the U.S. was denied treatment at an urgent care clinic because he didn’t have health insurance, according to R. Rex Parris, the mayor of Lancaster, California. Roughly 27.5 million Americans—8.5 percent of the population—don’t have health insurance based on the latest government figures.

https://gizmodo.com/teen-who-died-of-covid-19-was-denied-treatment-because-1842520539
 

He needed to go to the ER of almost any hospital and he would have received care. I can't imagine that any urgent care clinic would have what is needed to treat covid 19, and he was properly referred to a local hospital, but by then it was too late. My condolences to the young man's family.
 

CarolfromTX said:
I don't believe it. No one in this country is denied medical care.
Click to expand...
I've read some of your replies and it makes me think you live in some kind of fantasy world bubble! Unless your reply here is meant to be facetious or you feel you must challenge every statement. People in this country are indeed denied health care based upon whether or not they have insurance. It's a fact your disbelief (if real) cannot alter or delete. Here's another article about it from a San Francisco news site.
https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/arti...coronavirus-California-Lancaster-15161761.php
 
OneEyedDiva said:
I've read some of your replies and it makes me think you live in some kind of fantasy world bubble! Unless your reply here is meant to be facetious or you feel you must challenge every statement. People in this country are indeed denied health care based upon whether or not they have insurance. It's a fact your disbelief (if real) cannot alter or delete. Here's another article about it from a San Francisco news site.
https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/arti...coronavirus-California-Lancaster-15161761.php
Click to expand...

You are right, as usual.
 
OneEyedDiva said:
I've read some of your replies and it makes me think you live in some kind of fantasy world bubble! Unless your reply here is meant to be facetious or you feel you must challenge every statement. People in this country are indeed denied health care based upon whether or not they have insurance. It's a fact your disbelief (if real) cannot alter or delete. Here's another article about it from a San Francisco news site.
https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/arti...coronavirus-California-Lancaster-15161761.php
Click to expand...

I agree with others, where was the family? He was sick for 5 days before this incident. I understand there are people out there without insurance, but had he gone straight to the ER he would've been cared for. As someone said, an urgent care couldn't do anything for him. And again, had an adult been involved you would think they'd have the common sense to know that urgent cares are for pay and not free. From the sound of his case it's unlikely even going to the ER first would have saved him. It's certainly tragic, but I don't see it as a failure of the medical system. If he couldn't afford ObamaCare, why was he not on Medicaid?
 
garyt1957 said:
I agree with others, where was the family? He was sick for 5 days before this incident. I understand there are people out there without insurance, but had he gone straight to the ER he would've been cared for. As someone said, an urgent care couldn't do anything for him. And again, had an adult been involved you would think they'd have the common sense to know that urgent cares are for pay and not free. From the sound of his case it's unlikely even going to the ER first would have saved him. It's certainly tragic, but I don't see it as a failure of the medical system. If he couldn't afford ObamaCare, why was he not on Medicaid?
Click to expand...
Do you know how Medicaid works? I have an online friend who was about $2 from being able to qualify, yet she didn't get enough income to live without help from her son. ERs have been sending people home who've turned out to have the virus but their symptoms weren't clearly pointing to COVID-19. I've seen where some people have had very mild symptoms the first day or first few days then suddenly take a turn for the worst. So what happened to this child is not necessarily his parents' fault either. We don't know the details of the sequence of events.
 
OneEyedDiva said:
Do you know how Medicaid works? I have an online friend who was about $2 from being able to qualify, yet she didn't get enough income to live without help from her son. ERs have been sending people home who've turned out to have the virus but their symptoms weren't clearly pointing to COVID-19. I've seen where some people have had very mild symptoms the first day or first few days then suddenly take a turn for the worst. So what happened to this child is not necessarily his parents' fault either. We don't know the details of the sequence of events.
Click to expand...

Yes. Medicaid isn't automatic, and many people do not qualify for it for one reason or another. Some people think that if you don't have private insurance you get Medicaid. That is simply not true. Private insurance is very expensive (even with Obamacare) and folks have to choose between food on the table and medical insurance. Medical insurance doesn't always come with employment, either, especially for folks in lower paying or part time jobs, or who are working for medium or small businesses. And even if you get it with your job, once your job ends so does your insurance.

Regardless what some folks continue to believe, there is a huge number of people in America who have no medical coverage at all -- estimates run from 27 million to 44 million. Many of these are in states that declined to expand their Medicaid coverage.

This is an enormous issue in this country and it is one that we seriously need to address one way or another.
 
RadishRose said:
He went to an urgent care HMO office. These are Dr. offices contracted with insurance companies who give minor care. They could not care for him there anyway and he was sent to a hospital.

No hospitals here deny emergency medical care.
Click to expand...

Yes. You can't say the urgent care "denied" medical care to him if they are not equipped or able to treat the kind of thing he presented with, any more than you could say an obstetrician "denied" you medical care if you asked him to fix your broken leg.
 
Our attitude here in Britain is one of compassion. Even the illegal immigrants who find their way here in the backs of lorries are given medical treatment.
 
Butterfly said:
Yes. You can't say the urgent care "denied" medical care to him if they are not equipped or able to treat the kind of thing he presented with, any more than you could say an obstetrician "denied" you medical care if you asked him to fix your broken leg.
Click to expand...
They advised him to go to a hospital ER, which is exactly what they should have done. ERs throughout the US must (and do) treat people regardless of insurance or ability to pay.
 

You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top