What is Your Impression of India

Mike

Well-known Member
Location
London
I ask because mine is wrong, I have an image of mass poverty
with mega traffic jams everywhere, all the time, but that is not so.

I was brought up there when I was very young and have an affinity
with India and Indians, yet I was surprised this evening by a TV show,
about India's hidden gems/secrets, it was very interesting and also
very informative.

A Temple in Amritsar, it might have been the Golden Temple, feeds
pilgrims, free of charge, round the clock, their dining room is never
closed, this generosity, is not surprising, what shocked me was the
numbers, the British Lady, who was talking, about the country and
has visited for many years, stated that they feed between 75,000
and 100,000, souls every day!

That has to be the busiest restaurant on the globe.

Mike.
 

I fell in love with India. I tried to go without pre-conceived notions, but that was hard. It was worse than I expected, it was better than I expected.

India is a jarring juxtaposition of splendor and squalor. You'll have a luxury hotel that was the palace of the Rajah of Something-or-the-Other right next to a slum that is actually a garbage heap. You'll see beauty and you'll see horror.

We saw dead bodies lying on the sidewalks. I asked what happened with the bodies and was told that the police come by and kick the bodies three times. If there's no response, they call for a dead-wagon. It might not be a dead body, though....just someone wrapped up in a blanket sleeping on the sidewalk. Whole families live on the sidewalk. Walk by in the mornings and people are bathing.....they pour cups of water over themselves pretty much fully dressed. They're cooking, they're tending to their kids. Life goes on.

Cows do wander around the streets. I was told that there are so many cows not necessarily because they are "holy" as I had always heard, but because people move in from the city, bring their cow with them and then can't feed them, so they turn them loose.

You can actually "taste" the air in the cities. You can definitely "see" it. Everything is covered with a layer of dust made up of stuff you don't even want to think about. A deep breath will make you cough, especially in Delhi.

Traffic lanes and signs are mere "suggestions", none of which are heeded. I think all tuk-tuk drivers are immediately escorted into heaven when they die, because they have scared the devil out of more people than all the preachers, priests, imams, and rabbis in history have accomplished. If there's room for three tuk-tuks to fit in between two cars, five tuk-tuks will be there. As they say that there are no atheists in foxholes......there are none riding in tuk-tuks.

Indian people are among the friendliest in the world, I think. They are somewhat reserved, probably because of the population crush, but if you smile at one and say "hello", you will be rewarded with a thousand-watt smile and a friendly greeting. Service is unbelievably good. Waiters, hotel staff, drivers.........they are there to really make sure you are comfortable. I know a lot of it is because they're hoping for a good tip, but here in the U.S., those same people are also hoping for the tips but a lot of time aren't interested in earning them.

A lot of the former "royalty" are really struggling these days. We were at some fort and an elderly man was pointed out to us as the Rajah of ________, whose family had owned the fort. He was getting into a less-than-new Toyota Corolla with about six members of his party. It looked like a clown car at the circus. Very few royal palaces are residences any more. Most are hotels. They may still be owned by the family, but the palace has to pay for itself. There are a few grand high poobahs left, though. The Rajah who owned the hotel we stayed in in Mumbai had an entire floor that was just for him, even though he almost never came to town.

We visited a Hare Krishna temple, where we were treated like honored guests. Luckily, we got there in time to take photos, because it was almost time for the Gods to have lunch, and that had to be covered by a curtain.

Every temple we went in, someone was eager to show us around and tell us about their beliefs. We were "blessed" at every temple.

I hope some day to go back to India. There's so much to see and experience.

And the food. Oh, the food!
 

Immensely overcrowded with vast regions of unnatural environments due to centuries of overpopulation and pollution. Huge wage gaps with poverty with foul smelling slums in urban regions. Silicon Valley has large numbers of intelligent, educated, hard working Asian Indian engineers I've worked with. Nephew married an Indian software engineer.
 
I liked Mumbai for shopping because of the prices, but talk about crowds of people and the streets were jammed. After that, we flew down to Bangalore, which is also called by another name, which I can’t spell. It was less crowded and the nightlife was better. We had to meet with one of their military leaders (can’t say the name) and listen to him talk for almost 3 hours. He surprised me at how good he could speak English. The women in Bangalore are friendly. I didn’t quite feel welcomed in Mumbai. The air isn’t quite up to snuff. When I blew my nose, it looked like the colors of the rainbow in my hankie. (Just kidding, but it wasn’t all clean.)
 
There is a large Indian population in the Bay Area and most are very well to do. Usually, within a few years of arriving here they buy new expensive homes and cars. It is common for them to take a month off work to travel the world and love to buy the latest electronics. I have no desire to visit India, in part because of the politics and wonder how they will balance China/Russia with their desire to be part of the West.
As for the dead bodies, when I took a Religious Studies class I learned that since they don't have money to bury their dead, they use funeral fires or just leave them in the rivers or fields for buzzard feed. I don't have what it takes to watch a buzzard pick at a loved one, or anyone else
They don't consider the cows holy but since they provide the mother milk for survival, they are protected.
 
Last edited:
My impression of India is pretty much what others who have been there have described. I had a friend who visited there with her husband. She described the cows on the street, monkeys on bicyclists' shoulders, wealthy hotels and homes overlooking slums, beautiful sights like the Taj Mahal and general chaos.

I'm sure it would be a fascinating place to visit, but I'm not fond of crowds and the fact that I haven't yet visited New Zealand, Japan and South Africa puts it very low on my bucket list.
 
India is definitely not the place for anyone afraid of getting out of their comfort zone.

We stayed in lovely high rise modern hotels, hunting lodges, and beautiful old palaces where the furnishings were original and you felt that you were in a dream.

Outside, you *knew* you weren't dreaming.....the history and opulence was the dream, the poverty was the nightmare.

I think Kolkata (formally Calcutta) would be 90% nightmare. I don't think I want to go there.

We also went to Ranthambore, a rajah's hunting estate, Jaipur, Jodhpur, and Udaipur, along with short visits in other tiny towns whose names I cannot recall. After a while, the head started spinning.
 
My family goes back 200 years. Great-great-grandfather was a merchant seaman and sailed from India to England carrying goods backwards and forwards. When the Indian railways opened up, they were wanting train drivers and engineers. This is how we came to be there. My mother's
father was in a Scottish Regiment which was posted to India, Lahore, which is now Pakistan. Served many years there then retired to become a Police Officer and eventually Deputy Commissioner. Mother and Father both born there and went to boarding schools. They loved India and lived the good life until partition when rioting began, that's when my father decided to migrate to Australia. They had wonderful stories to tell us and with 2 daughters to think about growing up, he made the good decision to leave. I still can live those years from the many photos they had collected. My Father said he would never go back as Australia was now our home, and they loved living here. Mother and Father have now passed on and we have been living here for 77 Years My grandmother entered a competition about India, which she won, and it was,
"India is the land of palaces and palms, and the happy hunting ground for beggars". She won a box brownie camera, which we still have.
 
Last edited:
My one nephew married an Indian lady, which caused a bit of a stir in the family as he was Catholic and she was a believer in Jainism. It took a while to get used to seeing the blue statues of Lord Ganesha in their house. But my nephew’s now ex-spouse is an awesome woman and medical professional who coming from one culture manages to live and thrive in another.

My primary care physician is Indian, and can converse from personal experience in detail about the area that I grew up in. The appliance repairman coming to my house today is Indian, as are a number of the small store owners and operators in my area. India is a diverse nation of extremes, opposites co-existing, and untapped potential…
 
Dave has been there several times on business. He‘s told me stories that made my skin crawl. Beggars, people sleeping on the street, and human excrement everywhere. on the plus side, he loved the food. Not a place I’d want to visit.
 
Seeing your picture of the train, Pappy, reminded me of
a series of programmes that I watched a few years ago,
all about the "Indian Railways", a most prestigious job
for an Indian.

Over here we have "Peak" times in the morning and evening
"Rush" hours, on the Indian trains, they are always busy like
our "Peak" times, when it gets to a "Peak" time on the Indian
Railway system, in Bombay, or Mumbai, as it is now known,
they call the early morning and the evening periods, "The
Super Dense Crush Times", a time when there is no room
inside the train, so any foothold will do.

Mike.
 
My partner is Filipino and his in-laws are staunch Catholics. His brother-in-law actually studied to be a priest at one point.

His sister-in-law married an Indian guy. We went to their wedding and ceremony and it was spectacular. First the traditional Catholic wedding in the church, then the Indian wedding outside by the water followed by Hindi music and dancing inside.

They are probably the most successful couple in the extended family. She is a pharmacist and he is a doctor. And they have been together for many years while the Catholics in the family are divorced. Nothing at all against Catholicism, but I think sometimes adversity makes couples stronger.
 


Back
Top