We've never had an artificial tree. While the kids were still at home, the expedition to cut a tree was an annual ritual, except ...
During our first year living in Alaska we were told not to cut a tree locally - "They're frozen and will drop their needles very quickly" (For some thoroughly inexplicable reason we
actually believed that!?!

) So we bought an overpriced tree imported from Washington state at a commercial lot in town and naturally within a week it was shedding needles like crazy. The following year we simply walked into the woods and cut the perfect tree. When we took it down three weeks later, it still had all of its needles and had new growth at the end of each branch!
Initially our "used" trees would be put on the curb where the town would pick them up, put them through a chipper, and make the chips available to whoever wanted them. In later years, they were placed at the edge of our yard to provide shelter for wildlife. The following summer they would become part of one of our backyard campfires.
Since the kids have grown and moved away, we've taken to "Charlie Brown" trees . . . sparse three foot white pines decorated with small glass ornaments that sit on a countertop or coffee table. Our woods are full of them. No muss, no fuss, and they're easy to dispose of.