Prosecutors: Dentist Broke Teeth on Purpose.

Scott Charmoli faces up to 20 years in prison.

A Wisconsin dentist is accused of damaging his patients' teeth so he could bill insurance companies for crown procedures, the AP reports. Scott Charmoli, 60, of Grafton, was charged Tuesday in federal court with eight counts of health care fraud and two counts of false statements.

https://www.newser.com/story/300267/prosecutors-dentist-broke-teeth-on-purpose.html
 

I wonder if they can determine the cause of the chipped teeth, just from looking at x-rays.

Who brought the charges? My suspicion is that it was the insurance companies, doing their best not to pay for these procedures. But even then, what insurance companies? I am no fan of insurance carriers, especially when it comes to dental claims. But would a reputable company be likely to drum up phony charges against one dentist? Are chipped teeth really rare enough to arouse suspicion? What did the patients have to say about it?

There are too many unanswered questions in this article to lead to any conclusions at all.
 
Scott Charmoli faces up to 20 years in prison.

A Wisconsin dentist is accused of damaging his patients' teeth so he could bill insurance companies for crown procedures, the AP reports. Scott Charmoli, 60, of Grafton, was charged Tuesday in federal court with eight counts of health care fraud and two counts of false statements.

https://www.newser.com/story/300267/prosecutors-dentist-broke-teeth-on-purpose.html
Sickening greed!

Dentists are paid handsomely, it sickens me that six figures a year isn't enough for some!

Lock him up and throw away the key!
 

There is always a percentage of "crooks" in our health care industry....after all, the primary purpose of Any industry is to make money.
You missed the point. It was the dentist who personally wanted to make money fraudulently.
 
Last edited:
People have to remember something. Like auto mechanics, dentists are in a good position to rip people off, & many are willing to in a bad economy.
Since I've had extensive dental work (30 crowns, 2 bridges & 29 root canals), I've encountered 3 scam dentists. One almost cost me my life.

1. An excellent family dentist who we trusted for several years. He replaced 4 crowns & did 5 root canals. Then, I chipped a front crown when I bit into a peach & hit the stone. He tried to convince me to replace ALL 8 front crowns ($1,400.00 each). Replacing a crown involves a lot of trauma to the teeth, jaws & gums - lots of drilling & pressure. When I asked him why he couldn't replace the one damaged crown, he tried to convince me that it would be hard to match the color. He should have known that I knew that was B.S. A digital photo is taken of the other teeth & sent to the lab to match the color, which is exactly what he did. But I never saw him again; I couldn't trust a dentist who was willing to put me through a lot of unnecessary trauma to rip me off for $11,200.00. He's pretty stupid because everyone in my family stopped seeing him.

2. When an old bridge needed to be removed to treat decay, the dentist tried to talk me into an implant instead of a new bridge. He explained that "The bridge will fail, then I'll need an implant anyway." He didn't know I had already researched the procedure. The real reason he wanted to do an implant was because of the $6,000.00 price vs $3,000.00 for the bridge. I also explained to him that I learned that implants were not a good idea for diabetics due to the higher chance of failure. I made the mistake of allowing him to do the bridge. He deliberately made the bridge too short & I was unable to chew on that side due to the gap between the upper & lower teeth. The purpose was to teach me a lesson about not doing what he wanted. That didn't work out very well for him. After my complaint to the dental board and finding another dentist to re-do the bad bridge, he was forced to refund me the $3,000.00. I had to wait a year for the area to completely heal before replacing the bridge - chewing on one side, only.

3. 4 years ago, I needed a root canal. After having many root canals, I know that constant pain after the procedure is not a good sign. I spoke to the dentist several times & he repeatedly said it was normal & prescribed opiods, which didn't help. A couple of days later, my face started swelling up & I had trouble standing & walking. I went to the ER (barely in time) & they diagnosed Sepsis--which is often fatal-- & also the infection caused my blood sugar to suddenly spike to 705. I was in the ICU for 3 days & 5 more days in the hospital. All because the dentist did a rushed, incomplete root canal, leaving infection behind, then sealing the tooth (verified by another dentist who re-did the root canal). Of course I disputed the $1,100.00 charge & he called me after I was discharged from the hospital, demanding payment. And he was very angry at my detailed review I posted to warn others.
After laughing at him, I told him "You're lucky you're still breathing; quit while you're ahead."
 
You missed the point. It was the dentist who personally wanted to make money fraudulently.

The last time I checked, Dentists, along with eye doctors, and virtually every other "specialty", are a part of our Health Care System. In recent years, that Health Care System has become more commonly referred to as our "Health Care Industry"....and the primary purpose of ANY Industry is to make money. There are Always a few individuals or companies who are willing to "milk" the system.

Does that make my "point" any clearer for you???
 
The last time I checked, Dentists, along with eye doctors, and virtually every other "specialty", are a part of our Health Care System. In recent years, that Health Care System has become more commonly referred to as our "Health Care Industry"....and the primary purpose of ANY Industry is to make money. There are Always a few individuals or companies who are willing to "milk" the system.

Does that make my "point" any clearer for you???
No. It makes my point clearer. You aren't comfortable putting the blame where it belongs - on dishonest & greedy dentists. The dentists who ripped me off did it to line their pockets; no one else's.
 


Back
Top