It's certainly a can of worms and we shouldn't be comparing ditch diggers with brain surgeons because there is a lot more than education separating them. Education alone won't enable a person without the inate penchant for medicine, plus the skill and mental/emotional stability to endure and excel in that high stress occupation to brain surgeon level. There's more involved than education alone.
Those big wheel corporate high rollers with the multi$$$ bonus perks didn't get there by education alone either. There was fang and claw determination and something strange to do with lack of conscience awareness involved in most of them.
But education did play a part, firstly for their networking contacts and a degree in business management never goes astray.
But let's ask ourselves this: How exactly has their education credentials benefited the overall Nation? (everybody's nation, same everywhere.)
They don't pay enough tax and other than a very few they don't even produce anything tangible.
How many college grads are in IT and banking? Neither grows a bean. They're all busy as hell but they don't have a thing to show for it at the end of the day, not even dirty hands. Just numbers on a screen which a spectacularly good solar flare or hacker, or a 'cyber war' could make vanish in a blink.
Who ya gonna call if the internet goes kablooey? "Hey I'm hungry let's pay a banker or nerd with degrees protruding from their earholes to deliver some numbers to crunch on."
Guess who's gonna be making the big dollars then? Ditch diggers would come in right handy when it comes to planting time and crop pickers would be the new high $$p.hour workers.
Sure it comes down to market and demand of the times, but more than that it comes down to talent.
So too is talent involved at almost all levels of work. A good burger flipper will make more for his employer than a sloppy lazy one and deserves to be paid a tad more accordingly.
That's where the problem occurs. It's just too damned hard to legislate pay rates at the ratio of how much each worker contributes to the profit margin of their employer. Too hard for me anyway, I'm out of that side of the argument. Still have ammo for the education aspect though.
Maybe the education is too focused in one direction? It seems that IT based jobs are the must haves and anyone not geared to that is being left behind and alienated as useless.
I remember when schools here were divided up into specialised learning focus'. Who would believe that the high school I attended was officially named "Burwood Girls Domestic High School."?? Boy didn't that get changed in the 60s. .
The higher exam passers in primary school were sent to the posher Strathfield Girl's High School, which churned out the Uni types. The also rans like me, who were doomed to be housewives, or typists or shopgirls while they awaited that 'happy' event, went to Burwood.
The first year curriculum consisted of the normal basics of the 3Rs plus time spent in the specially built teaching laundry and kitchen. We were put through cooking classes and taught how to make soap. We even had a room full of treadle sewing machines that we were put to work on to learn how to sew. We were taught how to draft patterns and about fabrics etc because that's what good potential housewives had to know back in the 50s.
What a waste of time that was, and thankfully gone, but those type of courses, better thought out and geared to today's needs, for the less academically inclined wouldn't go astray. At least it gives the opportunity to get some education in something that potential ditch diggers can comprehend and use instead of dropping out and lining up for the dole as first resort. They don't need to taught the finer points of the stock market, they just need to be taught how to budget their lives around what they have, not what they think they might have been entitled to if the world wasn't so bloody unfair.
I was taught touch typing at school. I hated it, it was repetitive and boring beyond belief, but it got me a job in an office instead of sweeping the platforms. It was all the extra 'education' I needed as I wasn't going to Uni so didn't need to know calculus. .
Touch typists were considered skilled back then. I had been taught something useful that kept me off the dole, out of a factory and off the marriage registry. What skills are potential drop-outs being taught these days? Higher education is becoming more and more elitist and more and more resented by those not qualified. People who were once respected for their ability to attain higher learning are now seen as the enemy of those less luckily talented.
The frenzy to make everyone appear equal has done more to split society than the old the system did. It makes failure more devastating than it ever was and no education in how to handle not being talented enough is available. The shortcomings we took for granted as part of what life hands us is now seen as a devastating shock to the 'self esteem' of many. They react by dropping education entirely and waging war, both passive and aggressive, on those who have it.
Long bow sure, but hopefully you get the gist. It's past 2am and I'm outa gas so be kind.
I'm all for private enterprise, don't get me wrong here, but seems to me that the latest round of financial misery sprang from these highly educated corporate clowns stuffing up royally. Who the hell is educating them that lending more money than something is worth to people who can't pay it back is a sound plan?
Who was running the business courses they graduated from that taught them that gaining a short term commission on selling a loan was worth dragging the world's economy down as long as they got their own stash to the Caymans in time? Gordon Gekko??
The all time biggest idiot I ever encountered in management wasn't one who had clawed his way up the ranks, it was a highly credentialed 'civil engineer', recruited from the the top percentile of Uni grads, who couldn't tie his bloody shoelaces and didn't know a freight wagon from a Volkswagen!
I think we need to define the values and types of education we are striving to inflict on everyone.
...aaaannnd I'm off to bed.

fftobed:
.