Lewkat
Senior Member
- Location
- New Jersey, USA
I think they are a nationality which is different from race.But aren't English and Scots the same race? How could that be "racism?"
I think they are a nationality which is different from race.But aren't English and Scots the same race? How could that be "racism?"
You hit the nail right on the head EM, no one is born racist. They are created by others.I believe segregation builds solidarity and, sadly sometimes, the "us versus them" mentality. When I bought my first house, I purposely sought a diverse community. It was enriching and we all shared our histories, our cultures, our trials and tribulations, and our recipes.
I wasn't raised by racists and wasn't taught to be a racist. That's one thing from my childhood that I actually appreciate. Growing up, we enjoyed the company of many different races and cultures in our home.
As a former teacher of young children, I know in my heart that they are not born racists - It is taught by parents. They instill children with fear of differences and the notion that some are superior to others.
Why are we using the word race for nationality?"So what exactly do you consider to be 'white culture'???" .... good question!
I have friends of many races and I like it that way! .... I've been told by a black friend that I'm not white anyway, since I'm Italian, Greek and Russian.
I've never stayed up at night worrying about it ..lol
And it shows exactly how idiotic the entire subject is... and it's NOT anything new.I think they are a nationality which is different from race.
I was told not to tell my grandmother that my fiance wasn't Hungarian, as it would upset her! He was half Dutch, half Blackfoot Indian! His coloring was Dutch, so he could 'pass' as Hungarian as long as he kept his mouth shut and the subject didn't come up! Sheesh!And it shows exactly how idiotic the entire subject is... and it's NOT anything new.
Example: there was a couple, older than my parents, who got married. The husband's parents never stopped ragging on his wife that she was nothing, not good enough, etc., because her 'people' (family) had come from a different country than themselves.
Both members of the couple were white, they even shared the same religion, but her in-laws made national origin a big issue.
I've seen the same recently, too- individuals who actually claim they hate other ethnic groups within their own race.
![]()
No, the English and the Scots are not the same. Some Scottish people are descended from Irish people, others are descended from Saxons who moved from Northern England, some are Viking, some are Celts. A real mixture, just as the English are.But aren't English and Scots the same race? How could that be "racism?"
Standardized definitions from https://debbyirving.com/are-prejudice-bigotry-and-racism-the-same-thing/:There no such thing as race. Humans are all on one continuum. Race is kind of what we want to call it. And , as C'est moi noted, it hard to visibly tell an Irishman, and Englishman, and a Scot from one another. Yet, they've been killing each other for millennia. Whatever feature makes "us" and not "them", and makes us superior, or inferior is what we refer to as racism.
I believe that every country on the planet has what is now call 'racism'.
For thousands of years 'tribes' have fought each other for land, they didn't like each other very much and the colour of their skin was not the issue, it was that one tribe was trying to steal the other tribes women or property, they enslaved each other. And no amount of laws will force people to 'like' each other whatever their colour or religion. The best we can hope for is that everyone will tolerate each other and just 'rub along', if not the world will again see massive world wars.
It's too easy to dismiss racism as having no basis, but humans are animals. We think of ourselves as civilised but we still have animal instincts. Animals are territorial, and naturally suspicious of other species. In other words...it's perfectly natural to be racist!Race isn't really a thing. Genetically humans are all one species with what used to be localised variations. In the past people talked about lesser races and this could mean that the Celts were inferior to the Anglo Normans, or the Jews of Europe to the so called Aryan race. It isn't about race; it is about differences and very slight ones at that.
Today we wouldn't think of the former example (Celts v Anglos) as racism but we would probably consider the second example (relating to religion), like Apartheid, to be racist. Today most racism is skin colour or eye shape. When these attitudes are the foundations for discrimination they need to be recognised as a major problem.
It doesn't help to be debating what racism is. We need to attack the disadvantage that is its fellow traveller. We must learn from last century and do better in this one.
Yes I do Pepper. Thank you!@OneEyedDiva
I only checkedin your above post to mean I strongly support your words, not that I approve what happened. But, you know that already.
"We're not going to Kill Today"It's too easy to dismiss racism as having no basis, but humans are animals. We think of ourselves as civilised but we still have animal instincts. Animals are territorial, and naturally suspicious of other species. In other words...it's perfectly natural to be racist!
What is happening lately in the U.S. with riots and tearing down statues and even changing logos on pancake syrup shows that racism is far from dying even receding. It's not long ago that public schools were integrated by force.I do not believe the U.S. to be a racist country, although we do have racists living within our borders. To me, it's all in what you want to believe. If you choose to believe that the U.S. is a racist country, then for you it is, but for those that don't believe that it is, then it isn't. There is no 'yes' or 'no' that makes it official.
What is happening lately in the U.S. with riots and tearing down statues and even changing logos on pancake syrup shows that racism is from dying even receding. It's not long ago that public schools were integrated by force.
I don't understand your post. Can you help me out here?What is happening lately in the U.S. with riots and tearing down statues and even changing logos on pancake syrup shows that racism is from dying even receding. It's not long ago that public schools were integrated by force.
I'd venture to say if you, or worse, your young child, was on the receiving-end of 'the N. word' and various other examples, that you wouldn't consider it a matter of 'choosing to believe.'I do not believe the U.S. to be a racist country, although we do have racists living within our borders. To me, it's all in what you want to believe. If you choose to believe that the U.S. is a racist country, then for you it is, but for those that don't believe that it is, then it isn't. There is no 'yes' or 'no' that makes it official.