Have you ever had Petty Rules ruin your day ?

hollydolly

SF VIP
Location
London England
A Frenchman who spent eight years building a 23ft tall replica of the Eiffel Tower out of match sticks has seen his dreams go up in smoke - because he used a brand that can't be bought from stores.

Richard Plaud claims he found out his dreams had flamed out when Guinness World Records delivered their verdict without even visiting the replica.

And the ruling organisation says the 706,900 sticks the 47-year-old used were not commercially available and had been changed beyond recognition from their original form - meaning they could not take his attempt.

Council-worker Mr Plaud, raged against the decision - horrified that his patriotic project had met its match against record-breaking bureaucracy.

'It's disappointing, frustrating, incomprehensible and not very fair play,' he told The Times.

In a furious post on social media, he added: 'Tell me how 706,900 sticks stuck one by one are not matches.

'My matchstick tower still stands and will be 7.19 meters for a long time.'

Mr Plaud, who works in the artworks and bridges department of the Charent-Maritime departement council in southwest France, finally completed his project on December 27, the 100th anniversary of the death of the original tower's engineer.

He created 402 panels from the matches, which he then built into the huge structure.

The amazing tower would have dwarfed the current record for the tallest matchstick sculpture ever, which is held by Lebanese craftsman Toufic Daher, who created a 6.53 meter tall model of the Eiffel Tower in 2009.

Mr Plaud, who has loved making models since he was eight, had originally bought matches in supermarkets to build the structure.

But his arduous plans to win the Guinness World Record fell away when he decided the process was too 'fastidious' - and instead persuaded French matchstick maker Flam'Up to supply him with huge boxes of filled with 190,000 headless matches.

80942983-13054275-image-a-29_1707269288126.jpg

Richard Plaud claims he only found out his dreams had flamed out when Guinness World Records delivered their verdict without even visiting the replica


80943445-13054275-image-a-30_1707269294112.jpg

read the full story Here... Frenchman who assembled matchstick Eiffel Tower has Record rejected
 

The Guinness organization is notoriously finicky about their categories. Plaud built his tower out of wood, and obviously not mere matchsticks. Maybe he should have gone for "largest wooden replica" of the Tower?
BTW, his replica is beautiful.
They were matchsticks.. however he'd asked for the heads to be chopped off.. and the rules by the Guinness Book of record was that the matchsticks still had to have some semblance of head on them.. that in fact they had to be scraped off, and not chopped off..
 
Last edited:
They were matchsticks.. however he'd asked for the heads to be chopped off.. and the rules by the Guinness Book of record was that the matchsticks still had to have some semblance of had on them.. that in fact they had to be scraped off, and not chopped off..
Yeah, they were supplied by a match stick company, but they were wood pieces, not matches. People take Guinness records very seriously, there is a written criteria hopefuls have to follow. It's very legalistic.
 
Having the Matchstick Head scraped could leave the matchstick a great accelerant when
Your wife decides to burn the thing. Haha

Building one from steel would be more fun. It seems like not having a life fits in well too.
Some fill a basement with HO model Trains & tracks and Depots and Bridges, road crossings
People and animals. Some of the Engines are very expensive. I'd play golf!
 
..but the size of matchsticks...and what are matchsticks made from ?..plain old sticks...
I think you have to create a standard. What if the next person has matchsticks made without heads and also longer, or a larger diameter? Or has them manufactured with little notches in them so they nest together for easier assembly?

Where do you draw the line?
 
Matchsticks with the ends on would be much harder to build something out of. Without the bulb end the stick would fit flush with each other making the building much easier. If they accepted this then they’d have to start accepting all exceptions which would defeat the purpose of having a ‘fair’ challenge.

Read the rules and abide by them
 
I call for an immediate boycott of all French products, all wooden matches, and anything with an image of the Eiffel Tower on it. This weekend I will smash the two ashtrays I bought in France that say ”Souvenir of Paris” on the front and “Made in Upper Volta” on the bottom. Furthermore I call for an immediate boycott of all French restaurants anywhere. Shut them down!!!! And we will be picketing McDonalds until they stop selling French Fries!!! The oppressor must be challenged everywhere!!
 
I call for an immediate boycott of all French products, all wooden matches, and anything with an image of the Eiffel Tower on it. This weekend I will smash the two ashtrays I bought in France that say ”Souvenir of Paris” on the front and “Made in Upper Volta” on the bottom. Furthermore I call for an immediate boycott of all French restaurants anywhere. Shut them down!!!! And we will be picketing McDonalds until they stop selling French Fries!!! The oppressor must be challenged everywhere!!
You didn't mention French toast. Will your breakfast ever be the same again?
 
I call for an immediate boycott of all French products, all wooden matches, and anything with an image of the Eiffel Tower on it. This weekend I will smash the two ashtrays I bought in France that say ”Souvenir of Paris” on the front and “Made in Upper Volta” on the bottom. Furthermore I call for an immediate boycott of all French restaurants anywhere. Shut them down!!!! And we will be picketing McDonalds until they stop selling French Fries!!! The oppressor must be challenged everywhere!!
Well that’s the spirit. 🤪😂
 
I call for an immediate boycott of all French products, all wooden matches, and anything with an image of the Eiffel Tower on it. This weekend I will smash the two ashtrays I bought in France that say ”Souvenir of Paris” on the front and “Made in Upper Volta” on the bottom. Furthermore I call for an immediate boycott of all French restaurants anywhere. Shut them down!!!! And we will be picketing McDonalds until they stop selling French Fries!!! The oppressor must be challenged everywhere!!
But the "oppressor" is Guinness World Records review board, not the French or French fries, or the Eiffel tower, or matchsticks. Or are you an equal opportunity boycotter? I'm all for that!
 
Be interesting to see whether this leads to more bending of the rules.
 


Back
Top