Lilac
Well-known Member
- Location
- Flyover Country
A Palestinian Doctor working in the NHS at a Liverpool Hospital who mocked terrified Israelis fleeing Hamas gunmen is today facing calls to be suspended over her 'repugnant' comments.
In a recent turn of events, NHS medic Dr. Mennah Elwan has attracted criticism for a series of contentious social media posts where she allegedly mocked Israeli festival goers and expressed support for Hamas attacks. The neurology registrar, employed with the Walton Centre, claimed that there are no civilians in Israel and questioned the behavior of individuals fleeing the attacks, further intensifying the controversy.
![]()
Medical Bodies Distance Themselves
Both the British Medical Association (BMA) and the Walton Centre have distanced themselves from Dr. Elwan’s comments. They released statements emphasizing that her views do not align with their values. The General Medical Council (GMC) has also been alerted and will be conducting an investigation into the matter.
The source added that the views posted by the medic — who appeared at a British Medical Association (BMA) rally on NHS pay this month — posed 'serious questions' about how the union is run.
It comes after a wave of protests about the escalating conflict between Israel and Hamas.
Clashes also occurred last night between pro-Palestinian and Israel supporters in High Street Kensington, as police desperately tried to keep the peace.
A spokesman for the Campaign Against Antisemitism charity told this website there was no place in the NHS for comments like those made by Dr Elwan.
'These despicable comments demonstrate, at a minimum, a lack of empathy unworthy of an employee of the NHS, and we shall be submitting a complaint to her regulator,' they said.
'But, at worst, rhetoric such as this fuels anti-Semitism in the UK, and we will also be exploring legal options. '
They added that such attitudes could make Jewish patients and staff feel unsafe in the NHS.
Support for Palestine and Hamas in the UK
While Dr. Elwan’s comments have sparked outrage, they come at a time when several demonstrations in support of Palestine and Hamas have taken place in various UK cities. These demonstrations signify a growing support for Palestine in the UK, which, however, does not justify or validate the endorsement of violence or attacks against civilians.
She, along with other individuals like her, who have openly showed their comments/actions to all have no place in the medical community. I would also include any other job where lives may be at stake.
You have to have trust in your doctor to do the right thing & I couldn't trust someone like her for myself, let along anyone in my family.
So sad & disturbing to hear something like this.