Penny Pinchers Are Evil-Praising The Thrifty Shames Those Not Financially Savy-huh?

WhatInThe

SF VIP
A commentary piece basically saying by praising penny pinchers or the thrifty at the same time shames others not so thrifty. Says the 'subtext' of praising the thrifty basically shames the financially incompetent or strapped. Or even others personal choices. HUH???

http://www.slate.com/articles/busin...ge_in_3_years_by_saving_ignore_his_story.html

Political correctness gone berserko, someone trying to justify their financial 'competence' & lifestyle/personal choices or so called extreme thriftyness not good. Article cites a man who paid off his mortgage in 3 years.
 

Try doing what he did if you are married with children.

It is important to balance your life a little so that at the end of it you can say "I lived a good life" rather than simply see yourself as an outstanding financial success.

Where in his three years of paying off his mortgage did he even consider giving anything to even one other human being - time, money, pleasure?
 
Try doing what he did if you are married with children.

It is important to balance your life a little so that at the end of it you can say "I lived a good life" rather than simply see yourself as an outstanding financial success.

Where in his three years of paying off his mortgage did he even consider giving anything to even one other human being - time, money, pleasure?

I see what you are saying but lets face it money makes the world go round. Money doesn't solve everything but being financially stable sure helps-ALOT. And debt is frequently not only living off of borrowed money but borrowed time. SOONER or later those debts have to be paid. Money is a tool and if it is borrowed it should be returned.

That being said one size does not fit all. That also means if one is thrifty it does not mean they are shamming those who are not. The first time I bought a new car paying upfront in cash I caught all sorts of heck. Anything from being stuck in a cheaper but practical car to who the heck uses cash/checks anymore. The most grief I got were from those who declared bankruptcy and have made an art of eluding bill & tax collectors. I don't want dozens of calls & letters saying I owe someone. Some of the most happy & honest people I know in life do not have a credit card, paying cash for everything. Some value stability more than adventure shall we say "living" life off of someone else's dime.
 

An ex-boyfriend of mine loved to scrape and save and spent very very little. Yes, he had a nice nest-egg and no debts, but he lived a miserly small little life in his cheap run down apartment, picking things up off the curb because 'they were still good' and looking down when he walked in case he found some money on the street. Not very generous either. Needless to say he is still living alone in that little hole in the wall piling up his money and feeling smug because others aren't as good with money as he is.
 
An ex-boyfriend of mine loved to scrape and save and spent very very little. Yes, he had a nice nest-egg and no debts, but he lived a miserly small little life in his cheap run down apartment, picking things up off the curb because 'they were still good' and looking down when he walked in case he found some money on the street. Not very generous either. Needless to say he is still living alone in that little hole in the wall piling up his money and feeling smug because others aren't as good with money as he is.

Some take it to extremes I'll admit but I've seen money problems also take people to extremes of poor/bad behavior & attitude. Some are truely a victim of bad timing, crime etc but there are those with extreme debt & problems that are victims of their own poor & selfish decisions. And not all thrifty penny pinchers are a Howard Hughes recluse.

But in the case of the man who paid his mortgage in 3 years, he now has/owns a house. Any money that comes in after that is play money so to speak. So now a man in his 20s will able to host full fledged parties, barbeques, have space for hobbies, work, etc and/or rent out for future income. Sure there was some sacrifice but he gets more pay offs than many who will rent an apartment and not sacrifice. Cheap skates my be no fun but neither are those with money troubles many of which they probably created themselves.
 
I agree Whatinthe. I grew up with bill collectors knocking on Mom's apartment door every day. We started out as a couple with low paying jobs and poor prospects. My marriage proposal; "We will never have a house. We will never have a car."..but she married me anyway. Wife stayed home while we raised two kids to age ten in a rent controlled, three and a half room apartment. Never happier. No vacations for thirteen years. Scraped a 2000. down payment together and bought a house with our last dime. Lived paycheck to paycheck for about five years. Ended up with a paid up home, two cars, totally debt free, and forty years of happily ever after. We had stuff. Our cars were always small VW's or Honda's. They got us to the same places as the Porsche's did. We ended up having many great vacations. Often more than once a year, particularly after retirement. Our two big "secrets" were to enjoy each other more than stuff and staying out of debt! Once we got out from under car payments, we never again paid interest charges on anything. Our credit card company pays us. Been retired for twenty years. Now living alone on SS and a very small pension and coming out ahead at the end of the year. Have a very comfortable IRA, which I really don't need and treat as my son's money. I'm happy!
 
During my entire Army career, we lived on base housing for free. Officer's Row was really nice. We paid ourselves a mortgage, $1,000 a month for 25 years. We paid ourselves $300 a month each for car payments to ourselves. The trick was, get a good used car with the old car and cash and drive the wheels off it. Take care of it, drive it for 15 years, get another, keep paying yourselves.

Not everyone has this unique opportunity to finally, at 49 own a home with no mortgage. During these years of savings, we used coupons, and while in different countries, we travelled. Going from Germany to France is a lot cheaper than going from the US to France. See what I mean?

We took advantage of our blessings. We traveled the world and managed to live well, and along the way, we saved about $200 a month for our daughter's college. She won a scholarship, the Navy picked up the tab for the rest, but we made investments from 1986 on.

We took a chance in 1986. She was four years old. There was this company called Microsoft, and that's when we started investing.

We worked hard for our money; we made our money work for us as well.

During both our careers, we were both volunteer firefighters and EMTs in our communities. We rang bells outside stores for the Salvation Army for free, we volunteered to drive elderly folks to the polls on voting days, and for six years between 2007 - 2013, I flew Angel Flights; flying organs and tissue to hospitals for transplants.

I had to give up actively flying in 2014. I prided myself on flaring and setting down on a runway within 3 feet of its beginning. One day I flared and set down over 8 feet. My depth perception was failing.

Now I teach ground school, volunteer for Meals on Wheels, hubby and I are active in the DAV, we still drive the elderly and handicapped to the polls, and we do a monthly food drive for poor families in our town. We donate blood (Ow!!), and still work at least 32 hours a week.

I do not believe there's any truth to the notion that penny pinchers miss out on life and aren't assets and volunteers in their community. This is a misconception harbored by people who may not be well-informed and who may not understand there are ways of life that allow us to invest, be comfortable, have no payments except taxes and utilities, and serve our communities in a viable fashion.

We believe as we have been blessed, so we bless others by giving of our time, even while working still. We penny-pinchers sometimes aren't so bad. Make sense?
 
Some amazing stories here. :). I've enjoyed them all. Pookie, I admire your commitment to the community. Volunteers rock our world!

:glitter-heart::thankyou:
 


Back
Top