I too have personal experience with suicide. My Mother ( by accident ), my step-Mother, my Father, and older brother ( by accident ), and friends. Were they mentally ill? Who is to judge this? My feeling is that sometimes it is probably a mistake to try to kill yourself, but if your situation becomes intolerable and the suffering too much I feel like it is up to the individual. Helping someone with a horrid condition just to keep them alive seems wrong to me. Putting them in an institution and keeping them sedated is wrong IMO.