Teacher forced to apologize for saying, "Good afternoon, girls"

Going slightly off track for a moment, when I was a girl at school I was taught that the words man, mankind and he, him and his could include the female versions. Out school motto was translated from the Latin as "Every man is the maker of his own fortune". It was a girls only school.

Other famous quotes such as ""We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness" are supposed to apply equally to men and women but in fact they didn't seem that way when as a woman I faced so much discrimination.

As a consequence I identified with the Women's Liberation movement.

Thinking about the 11 year old student in the OP I am of the opinion that she is likely to be a young girl who believes herself to be male rather than female. She may be taking hormones to delay puberty with her parents' consent so that later, should she still want to transition, she will not have to have masectomies. We know nothing about the child but I could well imagine that the parents chose this progressive school for a reason. Bullying would be very likely in a co-ed school from both the boys and the other girls.

The catholic girls' school, where I taught for 25 years, accepted a non catholic student from a public school for pastoral reasons. She had uneven breast development and once the boys found out they gave her hell every day. When she was in an all female environment she was accepted and supported. Being accepted and supported is vitally important for any child who feels different.
 

Perhaps we could get away from potentially offensive gender-specific names by taking a clue from The Addams Family. Character Cousin Itt with their mate produced a baby, What, named after the first word to come from the mouth of the doctor who delivered them. Baby What may be seen below. I can’t venture their sex, can you? Is it even relevant?

IMG_1561.jpeg

For group address, perhaps a clue could be taken from the American South, where more than one person is routinely referred to as “Y’all.” Usage might include something along the lines of, “Good morning, Y’all.” No feathers ruffled. Just a bit of southern folksy hospitality, y’all…

Would y’all like some grits with that? 🙂
 
I also wondered about that, Fuzzybuddy. It seems very strange that a big story like this, broadcast and printed in media all ove the world, did not mention the name of the school, or even its general location, or the name of the teacher.

The only reason I can imagine is for the safety of the teacher and the children. With the insane world we are now living in, it might open the door to some more lunatic violence.
 
Back on topic, what is the exact name of this girls' school? Some school in a school system is not the name of the school.
A school with wealthy attendees. Neither the school nor the parents like bad press when school tuition is 20,000 pounds a year. Snotty school, snooty parents, snooty kid who probably has watched her family denigrate others.
 
Why is it even mentioned as "news" and broadcast throughout the world?Would we have all heard about some minor thing, a few years back?

If I'd have been sitting in on the class (being a guy) it would have passed by like a passing car blowing it's horn. Of no importance whatever.

The young lady or man (?) could have quietly spoken to the teacher after class, mentioning that she felt discomfort from the teacher's class greeting. I'm sure that the next day the greeting would have been modified - - -unless the teacher was a total jerk.
 


Back
Top