Trying to imagine thinking without language

The infant has not yet acquired sentience, which goes side by side with internal dialogue, maybe?
I'm pretty sure an infant has acquired sentience.

Sentience: sentient condition or character; capacity for sensation or feeling.

Also will speculate that the newborn makes noise to complain that removal from that warm & comfortable previous living environment is not appreciated.
 

That is hard to imagine, 'tho I've tried. Sometimes when walking to dogs I try to focus on the sounds, the feelings(tactile) the sun light and such, to try to experience the in the moment way that the dogs experience life.
I've watched male dogs courting. That is not living in the moment. That is living in the future.
They're planning ahead.
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty sure an infant has acquired sentience.

Sentience: sentient condition or character; capacity for sensation or feeling.

Also will speculate that the newborn makes noise to complain that removal from that warm & comfortable previous living environment is not appreciated.
My newborn son was circumcised without a local. You betcha he was sentient.
Your definition of sentience is right, but that's not what I meant.
I should have said that the infant has not yet acquired self awareness, the ability to observe himself observing. Or maybe he has, I don't know.
 

Thread has about run its course, so lets see what AI looking at much of our written information has to say. Reads like pretty much what I've already related and expected.

AI Overview: Google: what mental activities do not require language

Mental activities that do not require language are those that rely on non-verbal, visual, and sensorimotor processes
. Research in neuroscience has shown that regions of the brain responsible for language are silent during many complex thinking tasks, proving that language and thought are separate entities.

Examples of non-linguistic mental activities include:
Spatial and visual reasoning

Art and creative tasks: Drawing, painting, and sculpting all rely on visual and spatial thinking rather than words.
Mental rehearsal: A gymnast visualizing a floor routine or an architect mentally picturing a new building depends on visual and kinetic imagery, not language.
Navigating: Driving a car, navigating through a building, or judging the distance of objects requires spatial reasoning, not inner monologue.

Problem-solving and logic

Chess and strategy games: Playing chess, poker, or other strategy games requires reasoning and planning that can occur without verbal thought.
Solving puzzles: Logic puzzles, Sudoku, and building with blocks or Legos are often performed with visual and structural thought processes.
Tool use and invention: The process of inventing or designing a mechanical object can be a visual or image-based activity, often conceived before it can be described in words.

Sensory and emotional experiences

Processing sensations: Enjoying a delicious meal, feeling the exhaustion in your legs after a long hike, or experiencing a strong emotion can be deeply felt without being verbalized.
Non-verbal communication: Interpreting and expressing body language, facial expressions, and gestures involves understanding social cues without words.
Musical cognition: Composing or remembering a song is an auditory mental activity. A person who suffered a stroke, and as a result had aphasia, could still write music.

Physical and motor skills

Athletic activities: Many sports require split-second decisions and physical reactions that are much faster than verbal thought. Hitting a baseball or dribbling a basketball are examples.
Reflexive actions: Automatic or reflexive brain-based processes like sneezing are performed without language.

Memory and consciousness

Unsymbolized thinking: This is a type of thought that occurs without the use of either words or visual images. Many people engage in it, though they may not realize it because it is difficult to describe.
Recalling events: While we often use language to recount memories, the initial experience and retrieval of a memory can be a non-verbal process rich with images, sounds, and emotions.
 
Physical and motor skills

Athletic activities: Many sports require split-second decisions and physical reactions that are much faster than verbal thought. Hitting a baseball or dribbling a basketball are examples.
Reflexive actions: Automatic or reflexive brain-based processes like sneezing are performed without language.

I agree with all your points here but I think this one might be the most obvious. If you're working on your stroke in tennis there is no way that thinking any words is going to help you.
 

Back
Top