Q
OK I could mention a few.. but they're all still running so I better not.... but yes Cliques and personal attacks on other members were a major factor in them being dreadful places..as well as Mods who took sides with the cliques..
Bingo! I have been on several legal Q&A forums over the years, here is one example. This chick who claimed to be a lawyer who clearly was not attacked me the 1st day I posted.
Q from asker: I am in florida, I pleaded guilty to X, I want to change my plea, can I?
Me: Yes it is possible to withdraw a guilty plea, consult counsel.
Her response: Where do you get this stuff?
Me: I thought you said you were a lawyer?
Her: I am!
Me: Then it should be easily verified.
Being true meant nothing, the Clique still supported her acting like I was causing trouble. She had tons of negative comments on her profile, and of course it was the "I tell it like it is, you did not hear what you wanted to hear, so you attack me". I got nothing but hassle from the cliquers. The site no longer exists.
Another site, the stupid owner, an Attorney, put some ignorant jerk chick in charge as a moderator. Anyone who disagreed with her was banned. Time and time again. The site is still online, but no longer active.
One site, certain posters questioned every answer I posted, constant harassment. I called one a Jerk and got banned for 6 months, yet he was the harasser. When I rejoined after the ban under another name, well, you know, same crap. One poster kept reporting my posts for no reason but to be a jack ass. Since you had to give a reason why you were reporting it, I sure wonder what he put down, as the pig moderator did delete them. These Were proper legal responses, not smart A answers. He was a regular for over 10 years and answered a lot of questions, most very stupidly, so he was too important to ban. The main thing about those forums, is they rely on volunteers to answer, even if you are a smart A, does not matter. That jerk moderator wanted to keep his job, and if he ticked off the regulars and they left, so might the message board.