Which don't you want? Just a question.

[Ruthanne]

What don't you want on Thanksgiving?

 

[Rossana]

I do not want potato salad but I want to add mashed potatoes!

 

[Jules]

Potato salad. That doesn’t even make sense to be on the list. Mashed potatoes are the norm with turkey.

 

[Ruthanne]

Potato salad. That doesn’t even make sense to be on the list. Mashed potatoes are the norm with turkey.

I know what you mean but I found this on FB so go figure!

 

[Ruthanne]

I do not want potato salad but I want to add mashed potatoes!

Oh, I love mashed potatoes and gravy, too! Yum, yum!

 

[hawkdon]

No to the mac n cheese...

 

[C50]

Mac & cheese. I have no idea how a dish like mac & cheese has a place at any holiday meal. It doesn't really pair well with turkey or ham, or for that matter any of the traditional side dishes.

 

[CallMeKate]

What don't you want on Thanksgiving?

Potato salad for Thanksgiving?! Nope, that one can go. Cornbread can go, too... I like it with stews, soups, and chili, but not for Thanksgiving... dinner rolls for that. (But I'll take that potato salad with a hot dog or fried chicken!)

 

[OldFeller]

Mac & cheese. I have no idea how a dish like mac & cheese has a place at any holiday meal. It doesn't really pair well with turkey or ham, or for that matter any of the traditional side dishes.

I second the motion to remove it! Potato salad is unusual but it's not a deal breaker.

 

[Naturally]

Potato salad ... my mom LOVED it but I don't recall ever having it on Thanksgiving.
... did the Pilgrims have potato salad ??

 

[Llynn]

mac and cheese

 

[chic]

I do not want potato salad but I want to add mashed potatoes!

My thoughts exactly!

 

[caroln]

No to potato salad and mac and cheese. Replace with mashed potatoes/gravy and candied sweet potatoes.

I do love potato salad, but with hamburgers or hot dogs, not turkey. And I may be in 1% of the entire population when I say I can't stand mac and cheese...ever!

 

[jujube]

Deep six the potato salad. Nope and noper for Thanksgiving.

 

[Ruthanne]

Mac & cheese. I have no idea how a dish like mac & cheese has a place at any holiday meal. It doesn't really pair well with turkey or ham, or for that matter any of the traditional side dishes.

Some cultures love it on the holidays.

 

[caroln]

I should amend my previous answer about potato salad. I still don't think it belongs on the Thanksgiving Day table, but it sure would be good the next day with a turkey sandwich!

 

[ohioboy]

I hate Cornbread!

 

[Gemma]

Mac & cheese has got to go. Never heard of serving that with Thanksgiving dinner.

 

[Ruthanne]

Mac & cheese has got to go. Never heard of serving that with Thanksgiving dinner.

Maybe not in your culture but other cultures do. That's probably why you never heard it before.

 

[perplexed]

No mac and cheese

 

[Bella]

Oh, what the hell? Bring it all on, including mashed potatoes, and let's not forget sweet potatoes, too. Something for everyone. I'll have a little of everything! Thank you very much!

 

[Lethe200]

potato salad.

 

[Gary O']

No to the sauce and crumbly 'bread'

 

[Lara]

No Potato Salad, no Ham, no Mac & Cheese
add the Mash Potatoes, Gravy, Cranberry Sauce
and I put Cornbread in my Stuffing

 

[RadishRose]

Please don't candy the sweet potatoes, they're already sweet. Just gobs of butter.
I don't want gravy on my potato salad.
Mac and cheese isn't a cultural thing, it's just a cheap and delicious baked casserole.
I also hate cornbread.