Dwayne Johnson and Oprah Winfrey face backlash for asking fans to donate to Maui fund

Paco Dennis

SF VIP
Location
Mid-Missouri
No wonder we can't fix our problems. The wealthy seem to be concerned about their wealth, not truly helping others IN DESPERATE TIMES!.

Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson and Oprah Winfrey launched a relief fund to help aid local residents who were affected by wildfires that ravaged large sections of Maui, Hawaii, but viewers hit back and asked why the celebrity duo couldn't donate more of their own millions, instead of appealing to people with less money.

In August, deadly wildfires swept through the island, damaging or destroying thousands of structures, leading to the deaths of 115 people, with dozens more still unaccounted for, CNN reported.

As of September 3, the fire in Lahaina had been contained, while the fires in Olinda and Kula were 90% and 95% contained respectively, according to a statement published by the County of Maui.

On August 31, the pair posted a video to their millions of followers on Instagram in which Winfrey could be seen standing beside Johnson as they introduced the "People's Fund of Maui," which they said aimed to help raise money for local residents affected by the tragedy.

In the video, she said the pair had been inspired by Dolly Parton's philanthropy and believed people were skeptical about how to help Maui residents, so they created a fund where people could donate, and the money would go directly to the people who needed it.

A lengthy caption alongside the post stated that every adult resident who was "displaced by the wildfires in Lahaina and Kula" would be "eligible to receive $1200 per month to help them through this period of recovery" and provided a link where those directly impacted could apply for the funds.

"We are honored to start this campaign with $10 million dollars and ask for your help in donating to those who have lost their homes. We thank you in advance for your contribution," the caption went on to read.

The upload received more than 60,000 comments, many of which appeared opposed to the idea of wealthy celebrities appealing to regular working people to provide additional funds.

"Math ain't mathing with this one. You guy's literally have so much money…. You can donate it and make it back within a year," one top comment with over 10,000 likes read.
Neither Winfrey nor Johnson appears to have addressed the controversy, and neither immediately responded to a request for comment from Insider.
5 minute read


Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson and Oprah Winfrey face backlash for asking fans to donate to Maui fund instead of contributing more themselves
 

They are starting with donating $10 million. Not each. Seems generous; maybe they'll give more. I wanted to go rogue and start with a critique but I won't. If it makes anyone feel better, their bosses, the people they work for, have even more money than they do.
10 million is less than 0.5 % of their income.. For a person making $100,000 that is about $300. A penance of charity, no? "Let them eat cake!"
 

According to Forbes:

Oprah Winfrey's net worth is roughly $2.5 billion. $5 million dollars is chump change to her.
The Rock is worth $800 million and likely wouldn't notice $5 million dollars one way or the other either.

While it's a lot of money to almost everyone else, it's actually a pretty stingy donation relative to their net worth.

@Pepper, Oprah is her own boss. Nobody in her organization makes more than she does. She writes her own rules.

Just another example of the obscene amount of wealth controlled by the top 1% in this country.
 
According to Forbes:

Oprah Winfrey's net worth is roughly $2.5 billion. $5 million dollars is chump change to her.
The Rock is worth $800 million and likely wouldn't notice $5 million dollars one way or the other either.

While it's a lot of money to almost everyone else, it's actually a pretty stingy donation relative to their net worth.

@Pepper, Oprah is her own boss. Nobody in her organization makes more than she does. She writes her own rules.

Just another example of the obscene amount of wealth controlled by the top 1% in this country.
I thought it was generous and caring of them to do what they are doing to help. There are so many extremely rich celebrities who don't give anything or very little to needy causes.
 
Call me cold, but there are a lot of rich people who can donate. Yet they ask struggling poorer, working and even middle class to donate. If someone can and wants to, that is fine. But how much money, how many homes and boats and islands does someone need. I don't know what these people have but rich people do.

I pretty much just donate for animals. I'm struggling myself with the wildfire fall out, price increases and low inventory in my area.

I keep wanting to give up but I went to the kitten adoption place this week. I could have taken two so fast. I need my own place so I can. I'd eat noodles and katsup for dinner 5 days a week for more cats.
 
I thought it was generous and caring of them to do what they are doing to help. There are so many extremely rich celebrities who don't give anything or very little to needy causes.
You're right, of course.

The reason for the uproar was their donations were a relative pittance compared to their net worth. Perhaps they shouldn't be criticized, but neither should they be lauded.
I read that Oprah has ...er, had some properties in Maui, but she has some in Cali, too.
Oprah has some 1000 acres in Maui. All reportedly outside of the firestorm areas.

Please understand, I have no grudge against D.J. or Oprah. But from a context perspective, their donations were paltry.
 
It's hard to fault anyone who donates ten million dollars, regardless of their overall wealth. It should also be considered how much other money they donate thru the year, or how much good will is done thru their foundations and charities.

Bottom line is they didn't have to donate a cent, but they did. Good for them.
 
So when did we start validating charity donations against what people make.
Would any one of us want our net worth to be scrutinize when we donate to anything?

If you wrote a check to a charity and you had people coming up to you asking how much you make and saying you should have donated more, would you be receptive to that?.....I know I wouldn't. Would that make you donate more?

We are so ready to throw rocks at successful people but would cry 'privacy' if the same approach were taken with them.
 
Last edited:
Mentioned this before...

Whenever a store clerk asks me to donate to this or that cause, I always ask if the store itself matches what the people donate. If not, I decline.
 
So when did we start validating charity donations against what people make.
Would any one of us want our net worth to be scrutinize when we donate to anything?

If you wrote a check to a charity and you had people coming up to you asking how much you make and saying you should have donated more, would you be receptive to that?.....I know I wouldn't. Would that make you donate more?

We are so ready to throw rocks at successful people but would cry 'privacy' if the same approach were taken with then.
About 2000 years ago.

Mark 12:41-44

New International Version

The Widow’s Offering​

41 Jesus sat down opposite the place where the offerings were put and watched the crowd putting their money into the temple treasury. Many rich people threw in large amounts. 42 But a poor widow came and put in two very small copper coins, worth only a few cents.
43 Calling his disciples to him, Jesus said, “Truly I tell you, this poor widow has put more into the treasury than all the others. 44 They all gave out of their wealth; but she, out of her poverty, put in everything—all she had to live on.”
 
About 2000 years ago.

Mark 12:41-44​

New International Version​

The Widow’s Offering​

41 Jesus sat down opposite the place where the offerings were put and watched the crowd putting their money into the temple treasury. Many rich people threw in large amounts. 42 But a poor widow came and put in two very small copper coins, worth only a few cents.
43 Calling his disciples to him, Jesus said, “Truly I tell you, this poor widow has put more into the treasury than all the others. 44 They all gave out of their wealth; but she, out of her poverty, put in everything—all she had to live on.”
So, we are being Jesus? We will determine what every person on the planet should contribute?
Who should decided what is enough? Everyone?
We are not enforcers of what Jesus would determine what is enough.
Adding value to people that need help isn't always based on a dollar value.
There are many ways to help people than giving them money.
The popular “teach a man to fish” Bible verse is found in Luke 11:10-13 and reminds us of the importance of helping people in need – not just through temporary solutions, but by teaching them how to do things for themselves.
 
Just curious...how does Luke 10-13 relate to this thread?
the importance of helping people in need – not just through temporary solutions(money), but by teaching them how to do things for themselves. Meaning going there and helping them, side by side rebuilding.
Call me cynical, but I don't trust contributing to organizations that can throw up a web site.
The Maui Food Bank has been around for generations, helping people. I saw first hand what the food bank does on my last trip there.
To further explain how donations works for companies asking customers to contribute. That company takes the tax write-off. Illegal? No, disingenuous, yes.
 
Mentioned this before...

Whenever a store clerk asks me to donate to this or that cause, I always ask if the store itself matches what the people donate. If not, I decline.
Match it 100% or up to.... what. What if the donations exceed their annual revenue. You expect them to go bankrupt?
 
No wonder we can't fix our problems. The wealthy seem to be concerned about their wealth, not truly helping others IN DESPERATE TIMES!.

Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson and Oprah Winfrey launched a relief fund to help aid local residents who were affected by wildfires that ravaged large sections of Maui, Hawaii, but viewers hit back and asked why the celebrity duo couldn't donate more of their own millions, instead of appealing to people with less money.

In August, deadly wildfires swept through the island, damaging or destroying thousands of structures, leading to the deaths of 115 people, with dozens more still unaccounted for, CNN reported.

As of September 3, the fire in Lahaina had been contained, while the fires in Olinda and Kula were 90% and 95% contained respectively, according to a statement published by the County of Maui.

On August 31, the pair posted a video to their millions of followers on Instagram in which Winfrey could be seen standing beside Johnson as they introduced the "People's Fund of Maui," which they said aimed to help raise money for local residents affected by the tragedy.

In the video, she said the pair had been inspired by Dolly Parton's philanthropy and believed people were skeptical about how to help Maui residents, so they created a fund where people could donate, and the money would go directly to the people who needed it.

A lengthy caption alongside the post stated that every adult resident who was "displaced by the wildfires in Lahaina and Kula" would be "eligible to receive $1200 per month to help them through this period of recovery" and provided a link where those directly impacted could apply for the funds.

"We are honored to start this campaign with $10 million dollars and ask for your help in donating to those who have lost their homes. We thank you in advance for your contribution," the caption went on to read.

The upload received more than 60,000 comments, many of which appeared opposed to the idea of wealthy celebrities appealing to regular working people to provide additional funds.

"Math ain't mathing with this one. You guy's literally have so much money…. You can donate it and make it back within a year," one top comment with over 10,000 likes read.
Neither Winfrey nor Johnson appears to have addressed the controversy, and neither immediately responded to a request for comment from Insider.
5 minute read


Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson and Oprah Winfrey face backlash for asking fans to donate to Maui fund instead of contributing more themselves
I think that most people have feel good when they donate. I do and donate every month to five charities. It all adds up, look at the Jerry Lewis labor day telethon.

I say good to Winfrey and Johnson for starting this fund.
 
Match it 100% or up to.... what. What if the donations exceed their annual revenue. You expect them to go bankrupt?
When billion dollar companies like Walmart ask me for a donation, I ask if they will match it. Sorry, but that's just the way I go about my stuff.
 


Back
Top