Lethe200
Senior Member
- Location
- San Francisco Bay Area
I've often said to friends that it isn't always the best team that makes it into the Super Bowl. It's the two that have had the least critical injuries over the season. And that is strictly luck - bad for some teams, good for others.
In 55+ yrs of watching football I have to say the 2019 Niners are a mostly young team, led by a newbie coach (only 3 yrs experience as HC, all with the Niners). They are turning themselves around in commendable fashion after extraordinarily poor front office mgmt devastated the team for the better part of 20 yrs.
Over 80% of the Niners players in 2019 were not on the team in 2018. Plus, Shanahan runs a very complex offense. He is not yet at the point - and neither are his players - to where they can make seamless adjustments when things do not go well....such as players going down. As I mentioned, SF lacks depth.
John Lynch (who went into the HoF this year) was a risky choice as GM (also 3 yrs w/Niners, NO front office experience at all) but he and Shanahan have drafted very well and wisely. It takes time to rebuild a team from the disaster it was in 2016:
2016: 2-16, dead last in division
2017: 6-10, still last! But Jimmy G. came on-board and won the last 4 games, so there was hope.
2018: 4-12 (this was when JG went down on 9/23 and had surgery, ending his season), ended in 3rd when AZ was even worse and took last place in 4th.
Consider that even if they only split their remaining 6 games in 2019, they will end up 11-5. This is WAY beyond what anyone who follows the team and is not blind to their faults, would have expected. Even if they don't win the division, they have developed a solid basis for 2020 that is necessary for getting to the next level.
On the boards, most of us fans were forecasting 2019 to be maybe 8-8, if we were lucky 9-7 or 10-6.
Re the Monday night game:
Even with the Niners D understrength, Wilson had his lowest totals this season. If Kittle and Sanders had played, I feel the Niners would have won. Jimmy G's rapport with those two receivers is unreal. Sanders is new, but Kittle and JG have been solid ever since their first game together. In 2019 JG's passer rating with Sanders AND Kittle is.....perfect. Yup, a solid 158 rating.
Even one of them playing would have helped. The Niners second-string receivers are an inconsistent and poor bunch, except for Deebo Samuels. Samuels is a promising rookie, however, and given some serious work could turn into a solid second-stringer.
Because of the Niners overachieving in 2019, even if they win the division I would not expect them to advance past the first round. They are still raw around the edges, but I think they will be a more solid contender in 2020.
***
Re the Seahawks: I've watched Wilson ever since he broke in. Although overall the team is flawed compared to previous years, Wilson's 2019 performance is absolutely the best it has ever been. I think he is proving to everyone that multiple Lombardi Trophies or not, he deserves first ballot vote-in to the HoF as soon as he's eligible.
It was clear on Monday Night the pick-up of Jadeveon Clowney was what the Seattle D needed. He is the Charles Haley / Deion Sanders of this generation when he is on fire - the only negative being he has not shown himself to be consistent in every game.
I think if Seattle had not gotten Clowney, they would not have advanced through the playoffs. With him, I think they have a much better chance. I reiterate, it is not offense that wins in the playoffs and championship - it is defense. This is why the Patriots are more vulnerable this year, and why if the Ravens stay healthy they may very well get back into the SB.
In 55+ yrs of watching football I have to say the 2019 Niners are a mostly young team, led by a newbie coach (only 3 yrs experience as HC, all with the Niners). They are turning themselves around in commendable fashion after extraordinarily poor front office mgmt devastated the team for the better part of 20 yrs.
Over 80% of the Niners players in 2019 were not on the team in 2018. Plus, Shanahan runs a very complex offense. He is not yet at the point - and neither are his players - to where they can make seamless adjustments when things do not go well....such as players going down. As I mentioned, SF lacks depth.
John Lynch (who went into the HoF this year) was a risky choice as GM (also 3 yrs w/Niners, NO front office experience at all) but he and Shanahan have drafted very well and wisely. It takes time to rebuild a team from the disaster it was in 2016:
2016: 2-16, dead last in division
2017: 6-10, still last! But Jimmy G. came on-board and won the last 4 games, so there was hope.
2018: 4-12 (this was when JG went down on 9/23 and had surgery, ending his season), ended in 3rd when AZ was even worse and took last place in 4th.
Consider that even if they only split their remaining 6 games in 2019, they will end up 11-5. This is WAY beyond what anyone who follows the team and is not blind to their faults, would have expected. Even if they don't win the division, they have developed a solid basis for 2020 that is necessary for getting to the next level.
On the boards, most of us fans were forecasting 2019 to be maybe 8-8, if we were lucky 9-7 or 10-6.
Re the Monday night game:
Even with the Niners D understrength, Wilson had his lowest totals this season. If Kittle and Sanders had played, I feel the Niners would have won. Jimmy G's rapport with those two receivers is unreal. Sanders is new, but Kittle and JG have been solid ever since their first game together. In 2019 JG's passer rating with Sanders AND Kittle is.....perfect. Yup, a solid 158 rating.
Even one of them playing would have helped. The Niners second-string receivers are an inconsistent and poor bunch, except for Deebo Samuels. Samuels is a promising rookie, however, and given some serious work could turn into a solid second-stringer.
Because of the Niners overachieving in 2019, even if they win the division I would not expect them to advance past the first round. They are still raw around the edges, but I think they will be a more solid contender in 2020.
***
Re the Seahawks: I've watched Wilson ever since he broke in. Although overall the team is flawed compared to previous years, Wilson's 2019 performance is absolutely the best it has ever been. I think he is proving to everyone that multiple Lombardi Trophies or not, he deserves first ballot vote-in to the HoF as soon as he's eligible.
It was clear on Monday Night the pick-up of Jadeveon Clowney was what the Seattle D needed. He is the Charles Haley / Deion Sanders of this generation when he is on fire - the only negative being he has not shown himself to be consistent in every game.
I think if Seattle had not gotten Clowney, they would not have advanced through the playoffs. With him, I think they have a much better chance. I reiterate, it is not offense that wins in the playoffs and championship - it is defense. This is why the Patriots are more vulnerable this year, and why if the Ravens stay healthy they may very well get back into the SB.