Would they do that? Adding to the child's trauma by enforced separation? Probably they would have. Nothing made much sense in 2020/2021.
Some counties will take kids from a foster home with 5 children only to "top off" another with 2 or 3. And it doesn't seem to matter to CPS how long the children lived with the foster parents they're taken from.
Sacramento County CPS is a lot better at prioritizing children's needs than the county that currently has Paxton's case; Amador County. However, Sac County Family Court gave him back to his mother when he was very nearly 3 and had lived with me his whole life.
She abused him. Daily. I reported it and his preschool teacher reported it many times. I even texted and emailed photos of his bruises and scratches (his mother left him with me every weekend). But Paxton endured 8 whole months of mother's physical and emotional abuse before CPS in Amador County (where the mother lived) finally removed him from her home.....and that was because she failed a drug test.
Pax is 5 now, and living with a couple who hope to adopt him. They bring him to visit me once or twice a month, which is awesome. He's doing well, considering. He seems happy. He has no complaints about his new family, and he doesn't cry when his foster dad picks him up.
A couple years ago, when it was his mother picking him up, he'd beg me to send her away. "Pweez, Unco Fwank! Pweez, pweez, let me stay!"
I'll never stop hearing that as long as I live. Man, it still makes my eyes water.
It's a joy now to see a big ol' smile on his face when he gives me squeezy goodbye hugs. That tells me he feels safe and loved with his new foster parents.
His mother's final hearing is on the 27th, btw. That's when we'll know if the court finally terminates her parental rights, and allows the current foster parents to adopt Paxton and his younger twin siblings.
Fingers Crossed!
(and fingers crossed for CPS reform!!)