@JonSR77 said:
"...that whatever burden we are to our relatives...it is THEIR duty to be accommodating to us, not the reverse. We are the ones in pain, who need and deserve proper attention and care."
As you read what I'm about say keep in mind that if my mother had survived her the stroke she had just weeks before her 60th birthday my brother and i would have stepped up to be caregivers despite our problematic relationships with her because her last spouse way too self absorbed and controlling to fill that roll well. Also i didn't hear from my beloved Dad from the time imy parents divorced when i was 11 till i physically went to his home when i was almost 20 totally unsure of the reception i would get (a story for a different time) but when he was terminally ill almost 30 years later my then husband, 11 yr old daughter and i cared for him his final weeks so he could die at home as he wished.
Duty? Of whom? Which relatives? Parents,siblings, children, spouses? That may sound reasonable to you, but when you consider the broad spectrum of family dynamics, it may not be.
Does an abuse survivor have any duty or obligation to provide care for a now weak and vulnerable, yet often unrepentant abuser? And would that even be wise, safe?
We'll never know for sure how many cases of elder neglect or abuse stem from a reversal of roles. But readings i did as part of BA studies suggest it a fairly common scenario.
My Maternal Grandmother was physically and verbally abusive to her 3 daughters while spoiling her son. Yes she lived with my Uncle after grandpa died, but only till her inheritance from grandpa ran out and her only income was spousal SSA, cause she was never employed. Then she lived with first my Mom, her youngest, for afew years and then the eldest till her issues required 24/7 supervision.
The middle sister, who was most like their Mother (hypercritical and mean spirited) refused to be under the same roof except for big holiday meals, but at least contributed $$ to her care, while the son she so adored who had used her inheritance to relocate and set himself up well never contributed a dime.
Even when she was in the nursing home her eldest and youngest visited regular, tho she was in and out of lucidity. My eldest Aunt had medical power of attorney, and during the last year of grandma's life when her heart was stopping frequently the nursing home urged her to sign a DNR. She told them they'd have to catch her mother in a lucid moment because Aunt Maddy didn't trust herself about it. "Would I be signing it so she could be at peace, or so we could be finally free of her?" Is how she explained it to me, and yet she also faulted herself for how much her mother was suffering, hanging on to life.
One final question, do you really think the elderly are the only ones with pain and/or difficulties?
Personally, if i thought my daughter was here out of duty/obligation now or in the future i would not want her with me. Nor my sons.