Is this misplaced guilt?

WheatenLover

Well-known Member
Location
Georgia
I have always used feeling guilt as a stepping stone to considering my actions - kind of as a warning signal that maybe I am doing something I shouldn't be doing. The situation I'm in now, though, is one I think I must do, but I don't like the effect it will have on my husband.

We have been married for 33 years. We have been separated for 1.5 years. I live in town, and he lives about 11 miles away. We get along fine. He does not support me, and I don't support him, financially. He doesn't support me in other ways either. When I first got cancer, I had to move out. He wouldn't take Covid precautions and very soon the house became a germfest. I was extremely ill, and basically just laid on the sofa and took care of myself.

I will be moving to Mass soon, along with my son, to live with our cousin. We haven't told my husband about this yet. He will be devastated. Our other sons live in CA, and our daughter is moving to CA in a month.

My husband doesn't like people, in general, and has no personal friends. He doesn't like any of my friends or relatives so we have had no social life during our marriage. He didn't like it when my friends visited - no strangers in the house. As well, my friends don't like him because of the way he treats them. From what he says, he feels superior to most people. He thinks they are stupid. He ignores my friends when (and if) they visit, and he gets angry and frustrated at the stupidity of others, and tells them about it.

He is also disabled. He can barely walk. He has Parkinson's disease, glaucoma, type 2 diabetes, and has had several strokes. He doesn't do things to help himself - like move to a place that is all on one floor, change his eating habits, etc.

He does not manage money. He doesn't believe in budgets or saving money. He buys what he wants without regard to how much he has in the bank, and overdraws his account.

He cannot clean up after himself now (very well, anyway), but he never has. He cannot cook because he isn't interested. He eats frozen meals and goes to a restaurant every day.

His house is the absolutely most unclean house I have ever seen. He has a crop of mice who live there. I cannot clean it because I don't have the stamina and energy to do it, especially when I'd also have to keep up with his daily messes. I also do not want to live in a germ-filled house when I am still recovering from cancer.

He wants me to move back in, basically to the life I left. Clean, cook, do laundry, do his taxes, shop for groceries, solve the problems that arise in his life, never mention saving money or making a budget or moving to a one-floor apartment. Fix everything that needs fixing in the house and 2-acre yard. Never mention anything, actually, that I already know he won't agree with (and that is a lot of topics).

He is lonely, and that's why he says he wants me to move back in with him. But he doesn't talk to me. He talks at me about various topics but doesn't want a conversation. When I talk to him, he reads a book or the Wall Street Journal.

He gets angry easily, at the drop of a hat. When he moved his office into our home about 6 years ago, it took all of us a long time not to startle at his angry outbursts. We'd never heard them because he was only home to sleep, basically. He also says that he will take care of me, but he has never done that in his life. I don't mean financially, I mean me, in my current condition physically.

But I feel guilty about leaving him to move to Mass because he will be totally alone. The Council on Aging folks have visited him and he refuses to accept any help from them. He absolutely *hates* any change, and just refuses to consider it even when it is clearly the best thing for him.

Also, I am 100% sure that he will tell me, at length, how my moving to Mass will ruin his life. I have ruined his life before, and I am really not up for that conversation. Suffice it to say that I can do anything I want to, as far as he is concerned, as long as he either wants me to do it, or it doesn't effect him.

On the bright side, he doesn't drink at all any more (and rarely did), he is not physically violent (and never was), never used any illegal drugs.

This guilt is killing me (not literally). Then it dawned on me that it is misplaced, but maybe I'm wrong. Maybe I'm a heartless wife. We aren't getting divorced because it doesn't effect my life to do so, and it would just be another nail in the coffin of me ruining his life.

What do you think? Before anyone says that I am vilifying him, I have tons of support for divorcing him and/or moving to another state (it wasn't originally planned to be Mass). People see things and for decades have told me to exit stage left. He got really mad when I said I was planning to move to Atlanta and said I had to stay or I would ruin his life, and he would not go with me.

I am moving to Mass because of financial reasons. The best part of this plan is that my cousin is wheelchair-bound with MS and is very lonely. We get along well, and have a lot in common. He is my only relative in the US from the my mother's side of the family (the rest are in Germany).

Is the guilt misplaced in your opinion? If so, how do I rid myself of it? I am dreading telling him I am moving. If I "should" feel guilty, what are your reasons for concluding that?

Thank you for your help.
 

But I feel guilty about leaving him to move to Mass because he will be totally alone. The Council on Aging folks have visited him and he refuses to accept any help from them. He absolutely *hates* any change, and just refuses to consider it even when it is clearly the best thing for him.

Also, I am 100% sure that he will tell me, at length, how my moving to Mass will ruin his life. I have ruined his life before, and I am really not up for that conversation. Suffice it to say that I can do anything I want to, as far as he is concerned, as long as he either wants me to do it, or it doesn't effect him.

On the bright side, he doesn't drink at all any more (and rarely did), he is not physically violent (and never was), never used any illegal drugs.

This guilt is killing me (not literally). Then it dawned on me that it is misplaced, but maybe I'm wrong. Maybe I'm a heartless wife. We aren't getting divorced because it doesn't effect my life to do so, and it would just be another nail in the coffin of me ruining his life.

What do you think? Before anyone says that I am vilifying him, I have tons of support for divorcing him and/or moving to another state (it wasn't originally planned to be Mass). People see things and for decades have told me to exit stage left. He got really mad when I said I was planning to move to Atlanta and said I had to stay or I would ruin his life, and he would not go with me.

I am moving to Mass because of financial reasons. The best part of this plan is that my cousin is wheelchair-bound with MS and is very lonely. We get along well, and have a lot in common. He is my only relative in the US from the my mother's side of the family (the rest are in Germany).

Is the guilt misplaced in your opinion? If so, how do I rid myself of it? I am dreading telling him I am moving. If I "should" feel guilty, what are your reasons for concluding that?

Thank you for your help.
You're a good person and he was blessed that you put up with his BS for as long as you did already. Please, do not feel guilty at all. He's a selfish jerk, and if anything, he's ruined your life.

Time to do something for yourself. Life is short, you're a senior with serious health issues. You deserve to live your last years in a mentally, emotionally and physically healthy environment. Time to love yourself and stop thinking about him. He wants to use you, screw him if he's lonely, most hateful, lazy, selfish people are and they deserve to lie in the bed they made for themselves.

I'll repeat....please do not feel guilty. He doesn't give a damn about you, your life and your health. Time for you to move on into the sunshine and rid yourself of that negative gray cloud hovering over your head. Sending love your way, please change your thinking about this, it's a dead end for you, and he is just going to use you and squeeze every bit he can out of you, he is toxic. That is no way for you to live and you have absolutely nothing to feel guilty about. Stop being his doormat. He's ruined his life, and he is dead set on taking you down with him. The move is long overdue, IMO. Hugs. 💙
 
get the heck outta there. This man despite your history with him and your feelings for him regarding that, is a very selfish person. Yes he's got his own medical problems and that can't be fun for him of course , but he had no interest in you when you needed all the support you could get while fighting cancer.. he simply wasn't interested, and left you to fight it yourself.... ..now you're on the mend he wants you to move back in...

33 years is a long time.. I'm seperated from my husband for 10 months so I know the pull your husband will still have on you.. but run ..don't walk... get away from him as fast as you can. All the time you're staying around , you're not leading your life.. you've got a chance to lead a much better life than you have for 33 years.. get going now while you still can.. you have nothing to feel guilt about..
 
@WheatenLover , What you describe sounds a lot like what I'm seeing in couples I know / am acquainted with. I get your feelings of guilt, but by the same token you have needs that only you can fulfill. Your husband's life situation is his responsibility, but I'm sure you would take care of him, if only he would give you "something" of the man that he was(kindness, warmth...) in return. His anger issues are a sign (in my opinion) of his frustration in life, loss of control over his own destiny etc. I'm generalizing here, but as I said this situation looks all too familiar. Be kind, be firm in your commitment to a better life.
 
You feel guilty because you know he is selfish beyond reason. Why do you feel guilty? Maybe not on purpose but the reality is you described a man that doesn't care about anyone but himself.

Why then shouldn't you care about yourself enough to live the rest of your life with some degree of happiness? Go to Mass. & enjoy all there is.
 
I have always used feeling guilt as a stepping stone to considering my actions - kind of as a warning signal that maybe I am doing something I shouldn't be doing. The situation I'm in now, though, is one I think I must do, but I don't like the effect it will have on my husband.

We have been married for 33 years. We have been separated for 1.5 years. I live in town, and he lives about 11 miles away. We get along fine. He does not support me, and I don't support him, financially. He doesn't support me in other ways either. When I first got cancer, I had to move out. He wouldn't take Covid precautions and very soon the house became a germfest. I was extremely ill, and basically just laid on the sofa and took care of myself.

I will be moving to Mass soon, along with my son, to live with our cousin. We haven't told my husband about this yet. He will be devastated. Our other sons live in CA, and our daughter is moving to CA in a month.

My husband doesn't like people, in general, and has no personal friends. He doesn't like any of my friends or relatives so we have had no social life during our marriage. He didn't like it when my friends visited - no strangers in the house. As well, my friends don't like him because of the way he treats them. From what he says, he feels superior to most people. He thinks they are stupid. He ignores my friends when (and if) they visit, and he gets angry and frustrated at the stupidity of others, and tells them about it.

He is also disabled. He can barely walk. He has Parkinson's disease, glaucoma, type 2 diabetes, and has had several strokes. He doesn't do things to help himself - like move to a place that is all on one floor, change his eating habits, etc.

He does not manage money. He doesn't believe in budgets or saving money. He buys what he wants without regard to how much he has in the bank, and overdraws his account.

He cannot clean up after himself now (very well, anyway), but he never has. He cannot cook because he isn't interested. He eats frozen meals and goes to a restaurant every day.

His house is the absolutely most unclean house I have ever seen. He has a crop of mice who live there. I cannot clean it because I don't have the stamina and energy to do it, especially when I'd also have to keep up with his daily messes. I also do not want to live in a germ-filled house when I am still recovering from cancer.

He wants me to move back in, basically to the life I left. Clean, cook, do laundry, do his taxes, shop for groceries, solve the problems that arise in his life, never mention saving money or making a budget or moving to a one-floor apartment. Fix everything that needs fixing in the house and 2-acre yard. Never mention anything, actually, that I already know he won't agree with (and that is a lot of topics).

He is lonely, and that's why he says he wants me to move back in with him. But he doesn't talk to me. He talks at me about various topics but doesn't want a conversation. When I talk to him, he reads a book or the Wall Street Journal.

He gets angry easily, at the drop of a hat. When he moved his office into our home about 6 years ago, it took all of us a long time not to startle at his angry outbursts. We'd never heard them because he was only home to sleep, basically. He also says that he will take care of me, but he has never done that in his life. I don't mean financially, I mean me, in my current condition physically.

But I feel guilty about leaving him to move to Mass because he will be totally alone. The Council on Aging folks have visited him and he refuses to accept any help from them. He absolutely *hates* any change, and just refuses to consider it even when it is clearly the best thing for him.

Also, I am 100% sure that he will tell me, at length, how my moving to Mass will ruin his life. I have ruined his life before, and I am really not up for that conversation. Suffice it to say that I can do anything I want to, as far as he is concerned, as long as he either wants me to do it, or it doesn't effect him.

On the bright side, he doesn't drink at all any more (and rarely did), he is not physically violent (and never was), never used any illegal drugs.

This guilt is killing me (not literally). Then it dawned on me that it is misplaced, but maybe I'm wrong. Maybe I'm a heartless wife. We aren't getting divorced because it doesn't effect my life to do so, and it would just be another nail in the coffin of me ruining his life.

What do you think? Before anyone says that I am vilifying him, I have tons of support for divorcing him and/or moving to another state (it wasn't originally planned to be Mass). People see things and for decades have told me to exit stage left. He got really mad when I said I was planning to move to Atlanta and said I had to stay or I would ruin his life, and he would not go with me.

I am moving to Mass because of financial reasons. The best part of this plan is that my cousin is wheelchair-bound with MS and is very lonely. We get along well, and have a lot in common. He is my only relative in the US from the my mother's side of the family (the rest are in Germany).

Is the guilt misplaced in your opinion? If so, how do I rid myself of it? I am dreading telling him I am moving. If I "should" feel guilty, what are your reasons for concluding that?

Thank you for your help.
You are already living separately - Why take up a former position as his neglected servant? I'm glad you made a decision about your move. Hopefully, that's one big first step towards salvaging the rest of your life. You have nothing to feel guilty about, in my opinion. I admire your courage in making this life change. As for telling him, if it is too difficult to do in person, just write him a short, matter-of-fact letter - I'm moving to Massachusetts on (date). Not accusatory, not apologetic - Just the fact. (My opinion only)
 
Can't add much to what others have said. Most of us have occasions of appropriate guilt, it is unhealthy to assume misplaced blame/guilt. The most you should feel bad about is enabling his helplessness and sense of entitlement. Forgive yourself for that and move on.

i have been in similar position tho the marriage was shorter. When decision to split up was made, i slept on couch for months and continued to drive him to/from work while he procrastinated about even looking for an apt or a vehicle. When i insisted he finally did find apt but DD & i physically moved his belongings for him and i continued to drive him to work (for 6a.m. shift, my work started at 8) for weeks till he found a vehicle. Finally had to say 'enough'. Got divorce done, goodbye!

At least it is unlikely your estranged husband could do more than make angry phone calls &/or write angry letters. Mine stalked me at 2yrs and 7yrs post divorce.
 

Is this misplaced guilt?​


Your answers below

My husband doesn't like people, in general, and has no personal friends. He doesn't like any of my friends or relatives so we have had no social life during our marriage.
He is lonely, and that's why he says he wants me to move back in with him. But he doesn't talk to me. He talks at me about various topics but doesn't want a conversation. When I talk to him, he reads a book or the Wall Street Journal.
Sounds like he really likes himself
So.....seems you're doing him a favor by leaving him to himself......all day.......all night

Bottom line;
He seems quite selfish
Needs professional help
 

WheatenLover..I am trying to figure out why in the world would you feel guilty... :unsure: From what I read you have been there for him over and over. We can't help people who do not want to help themselves. Sounds like you are in a no-win situation and are punishing yourself and maybe do not feel you are worthy of happiness for yourself? I don't know but I do know we all have to be our own best friend. I wish you could be kinder to yourself. You sound like a very lovely, caring person, to him but not to yourself. You tried but at some point, you might want to consider there is a limit to what can be done for your husband. I think you have reached it and have to take better care of yourself.​

You deserve to be happy...Perhaps your husband will have to hit rock bottom and maybe he will change, but it does not sound as if he will. That can't be your responsibility and certainly, you have no reason to feel guilty. Please be good to yourself and for once do what is in your best interest. I wish you all the best of health and happiness!🌹

 
Yes, IMO, and if you look back at your marriage you‘ll probably realize he was always making you feel guilty or inadequate even though you weren’t either. It was a form of mental abuse to control you.

Get out of Dodge as quickly as possible and don’t let him know too far ahead. Maybe if you’re not there, he’ll finally take some of the care offered by the system.
 
I will be moving to Mass soon, along with my son, to live with our cousin. We haven't told my husband about this yet. He will be devastated. Our other sons live in CA, and our daughter is moving to CA in a month.

My husband doesn't like people, in general, and has no personal friends. ....

He is also disabled. He can barely walk. He has Parkinson's disease, glaucoma, type 2 diabetes, and has had several strokes.

I can see why you feel guilty, is there anything you can do to feel like you aren't abandoning him? Someone on these boards (I think) talked about they have a weekly family zoom get together, could you get your husband and CA family members to participate in something like that, then at least once a week he would get some human interaction with people he is familiar with and you could keep an eye on him in case you need to contact someone to go help him.
Does he own the house he lives in, if so, you could suggest to him that he could sell it and move to MA also (and then probably hope he doesn't!).
 
I can see why you feel guilty, is there anything you can do to feel like you aren't abandoning him? Someone on these boards (I think) talked about they have a weekly family zoom get together, could you get your husband and CA family members to participate in something like that, then at least once a week he would get some human interaction with people he is familiar with and you could keep an eye on him in case you need to contact someone to go help him.
Does he own the house he lives in, if so, you could suggest to him that he could sell it and move to MA also (and then probably hope he doesn't!).
NO way... she needs a clean break from this guy... she doesn't owe him a thing. He doesn't like family or friends in any case..., it's not up to her to find him friends, he's a grown man
 
@WheatenLover It makes me sad to think of anyone having to cope with cancer and living in the situation you have described. If I were you, I would just pack and move on as fast as I could. The more you talk to your estranged husband about your plans, the more complicated and difficult it will become for both of you.

Once you have moved on and feel stronger, you may want to get some advice re the divorce. I have no idea what the matrimonial laws are in the US but, you want to make sure that you, as his wife, will not be responsible for any debts he may incur.

Best wishes for a happier future :)
 
The reason you feel guilty is because that is what he wants you to do. He wants you there to look after him. Well, he didn't look after you when you were sick with cancer. He uses you so please, don't let him use you again. Move and don't talk to him about it until after you have moved. I wouldn't do it even then. You need to do what's best for you and not what's best for him!
 


Back
Top