Why Not "Thank You For Your Service" For Our School Teachers?

fmdog44

Well-known Member
Location
Houston, Texas
We say "Thank you for your service" to our military service people, firefighters and police while we ignore our school teachers. I think that should change starting now. Without good teachers the soldiers, cops and fire fighters might be prisoners. Pass it on.
 

That was my career for many years. I taught children AND adults. 4 evenings / week I taught ESL to adults @ the local high school.
 

I thank and respect all who are or have been teachers.

However, and I don't want to start an argument, imo military service people, police officers, and firefighters put their lives at risk everyday ...I know teaching isn't easy but it's still different than the military or law enforcement.

Agree.
 
I was a teacher and most of the time it was great fun. I really enjoyed working with teenagers, watching them mature and being a part of that process. If someone had said "Thank you for your service" I would have been flabbergasted.
 
I thank and respect all who are or have been teachers.

However, and I don't want to start an argument, imo military service people, police officers, and firefighters put their lives at risk everyday ...I know teaching isn't easy but it's still different than the military or law enforcement.

I agree that they are not the same.
 
Teachers are more important now than ever before due in part to the collapse of the American family. Single parents cannot never duplicate two parents. Add the drugs saturating parents and kids. Single parent also are away from the home more due to the economic pressure to pay bills drives them out of the home to work part time jobs for minimum wage. It is sad to think people view a cop or a firefighter or a military person more important than a teacher.
 
I agree with Aunt Bea....matter of fact I'll add, maybe thank the garbage man.....What kind of a world would it be without them?...and who really wants to do it? Even if [in some areas] it does pay fairly well?
 
Most of these people do not need to be thanked whatsoever.
Including teachers like myself.
If you did a truly heroic service or act above and beyond then yes.
Or if you did your job strictly from moral duty, not pleasure.
If you are a volunteer, yes.
If you are or were paid decently, then no. It all depends on what the
person did to deserve thanks. A desk job? Kitchen work? Police and fire
know the possible risks, so do many others.
I know this is not a popular opinion, don't care.
 
Most of these people do not need to be thanked whatsoever.
Including teachers like myself.
If you did a truly heroic service or act above and beyond then yes.
Or if you did your job strictly from moral duty, not pleasure.
If you are a volunteer, yes.
If you are or were paid decently, then no. It all depends on what the
person did to deserve thanks. A desk job? Kitchen work? Police and fire
know the possible risks, so do many others.
I know this is not a popular opinion, don't care.


While I agree...really it's never wrong to say thank you either.

Along your thought?...I never really understood why doctors are addressed as 'doctor' I mean it is after all an occupation, not a royal ranking, or a position of authority. [although sometimes they act like it is]

Imagine addressing everyone like that...hello carpenter Smith, excuse me plumber Jones, etc.....silly!..........jmo.
 
I view this as an apples to oranges comparison for thanking an individual.


Service personel typically are in uniform or for some reason identified as having been or still in some branch of the military. Thanking them for their service is recognition of volunteering to protect our way of life. Or if really old like myself signing up for the draft. Thanking police or other people that apply for employment to meet societies needs is a nice gesture. Other than being directly affected in some way and knowing what they did for a wage, is it realistic to walk up to a civilian public service employee and thank them.
 
Most of these people do not need to be thanked whatsoever.
Including teachers like myself.
If you did a truly heroic service or act above and beyond then yes.
Or if you did your job strictly from moral duty, not pleasure.
If you are a volunteer, yes.
If you are or were paid decently, then no. It all depends on what the
person did to deserve thanks. A desk job? Kitchen work? Police and fire
know the possible risks, so do many others.
I know this is not a popular opinion, don't care.

I thought I was the only one who feels this way, Victor. Yes, I'm glad that the police department is there for me, but cops get paid. (And paid quite well in Los Angeles - starting salary is close to $70K per year before adding in benefits, pension and overtime.)

People choose their professions based on what speaks to them. I'm grateful to ALL who do their jobs well, from the waitress whose feet ache at the end of a long shift but she nevertheless smiles when I place my order, to the cheerful caregivers at my father-in-law's assisted living facility, to the seamstress who earns barely above slave wages in China but still managed to sew the seams straight on the shirt I'm wearing, to the police officer who helps maintain order, to the teachers who taught me and my children, to the mental health professionals who help people sort out their troubles, to the farm owners and migrant workers who make it possible to have food on my table, to the water and power people who keep the utilities flowing, to the members of the press who inform us, and so on.

We are all important little cogs in keeping society's machinery working. Without any of these jobs being performed adequately the works would gum up pretty quickly.

IMHO the word "hero" has become overused to the point where it is nearly as meaningless as "awesome." Both should describe someone or something exceedingly rare. Not all who serve in the military, police or fire are heroes, just as not every breakfast taco is awesome.
 
I thank and respect all who are or have been teachers.

However, and I don't want to start an argument, imo military service people, police officers, and firefighters put their lives at risk everyday ...I know teaching isn't easy but it's still different than the military or law enforcement.
I have to agree with you on this whole heartedly. We recently have had a school shooting incident north of Indianapolis. The teacher present didn't hesitate one second to jump into the fray. He was wounded a couple of times and has been recognized and rewarded for his bravery as he should have been. And the unarmed teachers/administrators at Sandy Hook who RAN toward the gunfire: Beyond Brave.
 
I think it's more about whether only specific people are deserving of our gratitude. By my reckoning all people who do their jobs well are equally deserving of being thanked.

Nobody is forcing or preventing gratitude. Whether or not that gratitude is deserved and to what degree is not our call to make, imo.
 
Nobody is forcing or preventing gratitude. Whether or not that gratitude is deserved and to what degree is not our call to make, imo.

No disagreement. The OP said:
We say "Thank you for your service" to our military service people, firefighters and police while we ignore our school teachers. I think that should change starting now. Without good teachers the soldiers, cops and fire fighters might be prisoners. Pass it on.

That's what some of us were responding to. Personally, I'm grateful and frequently thank all manner of people who do their jobs well including - and sometimes especially - janitorial staff. Talk about heroes!
 


Back
Top